-
Direct Measurement of Microwave Loss in Nb Films for Superconducting Qubits
Authors:
B. Abdisatarov,
D. Bafia,
A. Murthy,
G. Eremeev,
H. E. Elsayed-Ali,
J. Lee,
A. Netepenko,
C. P. A. Carlos,
S. Leith,
G. J. Rosaz,
A. Romanenko,
A. Grassellino
Abstract:
Niobium films are a key component in modern two-dimensional superconducting qubits, yet their contribution to the total qubit decay rate is not fully understood. The presence of different layers of materials and interfaces makes it difficult to identify the dominant loss channels in present two-dimensional qubit designs. In this paper we present the first study which directly correlates measuremen…
▽ More
Niobium films are a key component in modern two-dimensional superconducting qubits, yet their contribution to the total qubit decay rate is not fully understood. The presence of different layers of materials and interfaces makes it difficult to identify the dominant loss channels in present two-dimensional qubit designs. In this paper we present the first study which directly correlates measurements of RF losses in such films to material parameters by investigating a high-power impulse magnetron sputtered (HiPIMS) film atop a three-dimensional niobium superconducting radiofrequency (SRF) resonator. By using a 3D SRF structure, we are able to isolate the niobium film loss from other contributions. Our findings indicate that microwave dissipation in the HiPIMS-prepared niobium films, within the quantum regime, resembles that of record-high intrinsic quality factor of bulk niobium SRF cavities, with lifetimes extending into seconds. Microstructure and impurity level of the niobium film do not significantly affect the losses. These results set the scale of microwave losses in niobium films and show that niobium losses do not dominate the observed coherence times in present two-dimensional superconducting qubit designs, instead highlighting the dominant role of the dielectric oxide in limiting the performance. We can also set a bound for when niobium film losses will become a limitation for qubit lifetimes.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
Exploration of Parameters That Affect High Field Q-Slope
Authors:
K. Howard,
Y. -K. Kim,
D. Bafia,
A. Grassellino
Abstract:
The onset of high field Q-slope (HFQS) around 25 MV/m prevents cavities in electropolished (EP) condition from reaching high quality factors at high gradients due to the precipitation of niobium hydrides during cooldown. These hydrides are non-superconducting at 2 K, and contribute to losses such as Q disease and HFQS. We are interested in exploring the parameters that affect the behavior of HFQS.…
▽ More
The onset of high field Q-slope (HFQS) around 25 MV/m prevents cavities in electropolished (EP) condition from reaching high quality factors at high gradients due to the precipitation of niobium hydrides during cooldown. These hydrides are non-superconducting at 2 K, and contribute to losses such as Q disease and HFQS. We are interested in exploring the parameters that affect the behavior of HFQS. We study a high RRR cavity that received an 800 C by 3 hour bake and EP treatment to observe HFQS. First, we explore the effect of trapped magnetic flux. The cavity is tested after cooling slowly through Tc while applying various levels of ambient field. We observe the onset of the HFQS and correlate this behavior with the amount of trapped flux. Next, we investigate the effect of the size/concentration of hydrides. The cavity is tested after holding the temperature at 100 K for 12 hours during the cooldown to promote the growth of hydrides. We can correlate the behavior of the HF QS with the increased hydride concentration. Our results will help further the understanding of the mechanism of HFQS.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The Collaborative Effects of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Impurities in Low RRR SRF Cavities
Authors:
K. Howard,
Y. -K. Kim,
D. Bafia,
A. Grassellino
Abstract:
The superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) community has shown that introducing certain impurities into high-purity niobium can improve quality factors and accelerating gradients. We question why some impurities improve RF performance while others hinder it. The purpose of this study is to characterize the impurity profile of niobium with a low residual resistance ratio (RRR) and correlate these im…
▽ More
The superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) community has shown that introducing certain impurities into high-purity niobium can improve quality factors and accelerating gradients. We question why some impurities improve RF performance while others hinder it. The purpose of this study is to characterize the impurity profile of niobium with a low residual resistance ratio (RRR) and correlate these impurities with the RF performance of low RRR cavities so that the mechanism of impurity-based improvements can be better understood and improved upon. The combination of RF testing and material analysis reveals a microscopic picture of why low RRR cavities experience low temperature-dependent BCS resistance behavior more prominently than their high RRR counterparts. We performed surface treatments, low temperature baking and nitrogen-do**, on low RRR cavities to evaluate how the intentional addition of oxygen and nitrogen to the RF layer further improves performance through changes in the mean free path and impurity profile. The results of this study have the potential to unlock a new understanding on SRF materials and enable the next generation of SRF surface treatments.
△ Less
Submitted 12 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Multipacting Processing in Cryomodules For LCLS-II And LCLS-II-HE
Authors:
A. Cravatta,
T. Arkan,
D. Bafia,
J. Kaluzny,
S. Posen,
J. Vennekate,
M. Drury,
S. Aderhold,
M. Checchin,
D. Gonnella,
J. Hogan,
J. Maniscalco,
J. Nelson,
R. Porter,
L. Zacarias
Abstract:
Multipacting (MP) is a phenomenon which can affect stability in particle accelerators and limit performance in superconducting radio frequency cavities. In the TESLA shaped, 1.3 GHz, 9-cell cavities used in the LCLS-II (L2) and LCLS-II-HE (HE) projects, the MP-band (~17-24 MV/m) lies within the required accelerating gradients. For HE, the operating gradient of 20.8 MV/m lies well within the MP-ban…
▽ More
Multipacting (MP) is a phenomenon which can affect stability in particle accelerators and limit performance in superconducting radio frequency cavities. In the TESLA shaped, 1.3 GHz, 9-cell cavities used in the LCLS-II (L2) and LCLS-II-HE (HE) projects, the MP-band (~17-24 MV/m) lies within the required accelerating gradients. For HE, the operating gradient of 20.8 MV/m lies well within the MP-band and cryomodule testing has confirmed that this is an issue. As such, MP processing for the HE cryomodule test program will be discussed. Early results on MP processing in cryomodules installed in the L2 linac will also be presented, demonstrating that the methods used in cryomodule acceptance testing are also successful at conditioning MP in the accelerator and that this processing is preserved in the mid-term.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Systematic Improvements in Transmon Qubit Coherence Enabled by Niobium Surface Encapsulation
Authors:
Mustafa Bal,
Akshay A. Murthy,
Shaojiang Zhu,
Francesco Crisa,
Xinyuan You,
Ziwen Huang,
Tanay Roy,
Jaeyel Lee,
David van Zanten,
Roman Pilipenko,
Ivan Nekrashevich,
Andrei Lunin,
Daniel Bafia,
Yulia Krasnikova,
Cameron J. Kopas,
Ella O. Lachman,
Duncan Miller,
Josh Y. Mutus,
Matthew J. Reagor,
Hilal Cansizoglu,
Jayss Marshall,
David P. Pappas,
Kim Vu,
Kameshwar Yadavalli,
**-Su Oh
, et al. (15 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We present a novel transmon qubit fabrication technique that yields systematic improvements in T$_1$ relaxation times. We fabricate devices using an encapsulation strategy that involves passivating the surface of niobium and thereby preventing the formation of its lossy surface oxide. By maintaining the same superconducting metal and only varying the surface structure, this comparative investigati…
▽ More
We present a novel transmon qubit fabrication technique that yields systematic improvements in T$_1$ relaxation times. We fabricate devices using an encapsulation strategy that involves passivating the surface of niobium and thereby preventing the formation of its lossy surface oxide. By maintaining the same superconducting metal and only varying the surface structure, this comparative investigation examining different cap** materials, such as tantalum, aluminum, titanium nitride, and gold, and film substrates across different qubit foundries definitively demonstrates the detrimental impact that niobium oxides have on the coherence times of superconducting qubits, compared to native oxides of tantalum, aluminum or titanium nitride. Our surface-encapsulated niobium qubit devices exhibit T$_1$ relaxation times 2 to 5 times longer than baseline niobium qubit devices with native niobium oxides. When cap** niobium with tantalum, we obtain median qubit lifetimes above 300 microseconds, with maximum values up to 600 microseconds, that represent the highest lifetimes to date for superconducting qubits prepared on both sapphire and silicon. Our comparative structural and chemical analysis suggests why amorphous niobium oxides may induce higher losses compared to other amorphous oxides. These results are in line with high-accuracy measurements of the niobium oxide loss tangent obtained with ultra-high Q superconducting radiofrequency (SRF) cavities. This new surface encapsulation strategy enables even further reduction of dielectric losses via passivation with ambient-stable materials, while preserving fabrication and scalable manufacturability thanks to the compatibility with silicon processes.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2024; v1 submitted 25 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
200 MV Record Voltage Of vCM And LCLS-II-HE Cryomodules Production Start At Fermilab
Authors:
T. Arkan,
J. Kaluzny,
D. Bafia,
D. Bice,
J. Blowers,
A. Cravatta,
M. Checchin,
B. Giaccone,
C. Grimm,
B. Hartsell,
M. Martinello,
T. Nicol,
Y. Orlov,
S. Posen
Abstract:
The Linac Coherent Light Source (LCLS) is an X-ray science facility at SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory. The LCLS-II project (an upgrade to LCLS) is in the commissioning phase; the LCLS-II-HE (High Energy) project is another upgrade to the facility, enabling higher energy operation. An electron beam is accelerated using superconducting radio frequency (SRF) cavities built into cryomodules. It…
▽ More
The Linac Coherent Light Source (LCLS) is an X-ray science facility at SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory. The LCLS-II project (an upgrade to LCLS) is in the commissioning phase; the LCLS-II-HE (High Energy) project is another upgrade to the facility, enabling higher energy operation. An electron beam is accelerated using superconducting radio frequency (SRF) cavities built into cryomodules. It is planned to build 24 1.3 GHz standard cryomodules and one 1.3 GHz single-cavity Buncher Capture Cavity (BCC) cryomodule for the LCLS-II-HE project. Fourteen of these standard cryomodules and the BCC are planned to be assembled and tested at Fermilab. Procurements for standard cryomodule components are nearing completion. The first LCLS-II-HE cryomodule, referred to as the verification cryomodule (vCM) was assembled and tested at Fermilab. Fermilab has completed the assembly of the second cryomodule. This paper presents LCLS-II-HE cryomodule production status at Fermilab, emphasizing the changes done based on the successes, challenges, mitigations, and lessons learned from LCLS-II; validation of the changes with the excellent vCM results.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
High quality superconducting Nb co-planar resonators on sapphire substrate
Authors:
S. Zhu,
F. Crisa,
M. Bal,
A. A. Murthy,
J. Lee,
Z. Sung,
A. Lunin,
D. Frolov,
R. Pilipenko,
D. Bafia,
A. Mitra,
A. Romanenko,
A. Grassellino
Abstract:
We present measurements and simulations of superconducting Nb co-planar waveguide resonators on sapphire substrate down to millikelvin temperature range with different readout powers. In the high temperature regime, we demonstrate that the Nb film residual surface resistance is comparable to that observed in the ultra-high quality, bulk Nb 3D superconducting radio frequency cavities while the reso…
▽ More
We present measurements and simulations of superconducting Nb co-planar waveguide resonators on sapphire substrate down to millikelvin temperature range with different readout powers. In the high temperature regime, we demonstrate that the Nb film residual surface resistance is comparable to that observed in the ultra-high quality, bulk Nb 3D superconducting radio frequency cavities while the resonator quality is dominated by the BCS thermally excited quasiparticles. At low temperature both the resonator quality factor and frequency can be well explained using the two-level system models. Through the energy participation ratio simulations, we find that the two-level system loss tangent is $\sim 10^{-2}$, which agrees quite well with similar studies performed on the Nb 3D cavities.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Key directions for research and development of superconducting radio frequency cavities
Authors:
S. Belomestnykh,
S. Posen,
D. Bafia,
S. Balachandran,
M. Bertucci,
A. Burrill,
A. Cano,
M. Checchin,
G. Ciovati,
L. D. Cooley,
G. Dalla Lana Semione,
J. Delayen,
G. Eremeev,
F. Furuta,
F. Gerigk,
B. Giaccone,
D. Gonnella,
A. Grassellino,
A. Gurevich,
W. Hillert,
M. Iavarone,
J. Knobloch,
T. Kubo,
W. K. Kwok,
R. Laxdal
, et al. (31 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Radio frequency superconductivity is a cornerstone technology for many future HEP particle accelerators and experiments from colliders to proton drivers for neutrino facilities to searches for dark matter. While the performance of superconducting RF (SRF) cavities has improved significantly over the last decades, and the SRF technology has enabled new applications, the proposed HEP facilities and…
▽ More
Radio frequency superconductivity is a cornerstone technology for many future HEP particle accelerators and experiments from colliders to proton drivers for neutrino facilities to searches for dark matter. While the performance of superconducting RF (SRF) cavities has improved significantly over the last decades, and the SRF technology has enabled new applications, the proposed HEP facilities and experiments pose new challenges. To address these challenges, the field continues to generate new ideas and there seems to be a vast room for improvements. In this paper we discuss the key research directions that are aligned with and address the future HEP needs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2022; v1 submitted 3 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
LCLS-II-HE verification cryomodule high gradient performance and quench behavior
Authors:
S. Posen,
A. Cravatta,
M. Checchin,
S. Aderhold,
C. Adolphsen,
T. Arkan,
D. Bafia,
A. Benwell,
D. Bice,
B. Chase,
C. Contreras-Martinez,
L. Dootlittle,
J. Fuerst,
D. Gonnella,
A. Grassellino,
C. Grimm,
B. Hansen,
E. Harms,
B. Hartsell,
G. Hays,
J. Holzbauer,
S. Hoobler,
J. Kaluzny,
T. Khabiboulline,
M. Kucera
, et al. (21 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
An 8-cavity, 1.3 GHz, LCLS-II-HE cryomodule was assembled and tested at Fermilab to verify performance before the start of production. Its cavities were processed with a novel nitrogen do** treatment to improve gradient performance. The cryomodule was tested with a modified protocol to process sporadic quenches, which were observed in LCLS-II production cryomodules and are attributed to multipac…
▽ More
An 8-cavity, 1.3 GHz, LCLS-II-HE cryomodule was assembled and tested at Fermilab to verify performance before the start of production. Its cavities were processed with a novel nitrogen do** treatment to improve gradient performance. The cryomodule was tested with a modified protocol to process sporadic quenches, which were observed in LCLS-II production cryomodules and are attributed to multipacting. Dedicated vertical test experiments support the attribution to multipacting. The verification cryomodule achieved an acceleration voltage of 200 MV in continuous wave mode, corresponding to an average accelerating gradient of 24.1 MV/m, significantly exceeding the specification of 173 MV. The average Q0 (3.0x10^10) also exceeded its specification (2.7x10^10). After processing, no field emission was observed up to the maximum gradient of each cavity. This paper reviews the cryomodule performance and discusses operational issues and mitigations implemented during the several month program.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Oxygen Vacancies in Niobium Pentoxide as a Source of Two-Level System Losses in Superconducting Niobium
Authors:
Daniel Bafia,
Akshay Murthy,
Anna Grassellino,
Alexander Romanenko
Abstract:
We identify a major source of quantum decoherence in three-dimensional superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) resonators and two-dimensional transmon qubits composed of oxidized niobium: oxygen vacancies in the niobium pentoxide which drive two-level system (TLS) losses. By probing the effect of sequential \textit{in situ} vacuum baking treatments on the RF performance of bulk Nb SRF resonators and…
▽ More
We identify a major source of quantum decoherence in three-dimensional superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) resonators and two-dimensional transmon qubits composed of oxidized niobium: oxygen vacancies in the niobium pentoxide which drive two-level system (TLS) losses. By probing the effect of sequential \textit{in situ} vacuum baking treatments on the RF performance of bulk Nb SRF resonators and on the oxide structure of a representative Nb sample using time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry (ToF-SIMS), we find a non-monotonic evolution of cavity quality factor $Q_0$ which correlates with the interplay of Nb\textsubscript{2}O\textsubscript{5} vacancy generation and oxide thickness reduction. We localize this effect to the oxide itself and present the insignificant role of diffused interstitial oxygen in the underlying Nb by regrowing a new oxide \textit{via} wet oxidation which reveals a mitigation of aggravated TLS losses. We hypothesize that such vacancies in the pentoxide serve as magnetic impurities and are a source of TLS-driven RF loss.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2024; v1 submitted 30 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The Anomalous Resonant Frequency Variation of Microwave Superconducting Niobium Cavities Near $T_c$
Authors:
D. Bafia,
A. Grassellino,
M. Checchin,
J. F. Zasadzinski,
A. Romanenko
Abstract:
Superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) niobium cavities are the modern means of particle acceleration and an enabling technology for record coherence superconducting quantum systems and ultra-sensitive searches for new physics. Here, we report a systematic effect in Nb cavities indicative of improved superconducting properties - an anomalous decrease (dip) in the resonant frequency at temperatures…
▽ More
Superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) niobium cavities are the modern means of particle acceleration and an enabling technology for record coherence superconducting quantum systems and ultra-sensitive searches for new physics. Here, we report a systematic effect in Nb cavities indicative of improved superconducting properties - an anomalous decrease (dip) in the resonant frequency at temperatures just below the critical temperature $T_\mathrm{c}$. The frequency dip magnitude correlates with cavity quality factor, near-surface impurity distribution, and $T_\mathrm{c}$. It is also a precursor of the peculiar decrease in the BCS surface impedance with increasing RF current. A first demonstration of the coherence peak in the AC conductivity in Nb SRF cavities is also presented and found to correlate with a large frequency dip.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2021; v1 submitted 18 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
