-
A Turvey-Shapley Value Method for Distribution Network Cost Allocation
Authors:
Donald Azuatalam,
Archie C. Chapman,
Gregor Verbič
Abstract:
This paper proposes a novel cost-reflective and computationally efficient method for allocating distribution network costs to residential customers. First, the method estimates the growth in peak demand with a 50% probability of exceedance (50POE) and the associated network augmentation costs using a probabilistic long-run marginal cost computation based on the Turvey perturbation method. Second,…
▽ More
This paper proposes a novel cost-reflective and computationally efficient method for allocating distribution network costs to residential customers. First, the method estimates the growth in peak demand with a 50% probability of exceedance (50POE) and the associated network augmentation costs using a probabilistic long-run marginal cost computation based on the Turvey perturbation method. Second, it allocates these costs to customers on a cost-causal basis using the Shapley value solution concept. To overcome the intractability of the exact Shapley value computation for real-world applications, we implement a fast, scalable and efficient clustering technique based on customers' peak demand contribution, which drastically reduces the Shapley value computation time. Using customer load traces from an Australian smart grid trial (Solar Home Electricity Data), we demonstrate the efficacy of our method by comparing it with established energy- and peak demand-based cost allocation approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 3 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Energy management of small-scale PV-battery systems: A systematic review considering practical implementation, computational requirements, quality of input data and battery degradation
Authors:
Donald Azuatalam,
Kaveh Paridari,
Yiju Ma,
Markus Förstl,
Archie C. Chapman,
Gregor Verbič
Abstract:
The home energy management problem has many different facets, including economic viability, data uncertainty and quality of strategy employed. The existing literature in this area focuses on individual aspects of this problem without a detailed, holistic analysis of the results with regards to practicality in implementation. In this paper, we fill this gap by performing a comprehensive comparison…
▽ More
The home energy management problem has many different facets, including economic viability, data uncertainty and quality of strategy employed. The existing literature in this area focuses on individual aspects of this problem without a detailed, holistic analysis of the results with regards to practicality in implementation. In this paper, we fill this gap by performing a comprehensive comparison of seven different energy management strategies, each with different levels of practicality, sophistication and computational requirements. We analyse the results in the context of these three characteristics, and also critique the modelling assumptions made by each strategy. Our analysis finds that using a more sophisticated energy management strategy may not necessarily improve the performance and economic viability of the PV-battery system due to the effects of modeling assumptions, such as the treatment of uncertainties in the input data and battery degradation effects.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Probabilistic assessment of the impact of flexible loads under network tariffs in low voltage distribution networks
Authors:
Donald Azuatalam,
Archie C. Chapman,
Gregor Verbič
Abstract:
Given the historically static nature of low-voltage networks, distribution network companies do not possess tools for dealing with an increasingly variable demand due to the high penetration of distributed energy resources (DER). Within this context, this paper proposes a probabilistic framework for tariff design that minimises the impact of DER on network performance, stabilise network company re…
▽ More
Given the historically static nature of low-voltage networks, distribution network companies do not possess tools for dealing with an increasingly variable demand due to the high penetration of distributed energy resources (DER). Within this context, this paper proposes a probabilistic framework for tariff design that minimises the impact of DER on network performance, stabilise network company revenue, and improves the equity of network costs allocation. To address the issue of the lack of customers' response, we also show how DER-specific tariffs can be complemented with an automated home energy management system (HEMS) that reduces peak demand while retaining the desired comfort level. The proposed framework comprises a nonparametric Bayesian model which statistically generates synthetic load and PV traces, a hot-water-use statistical model, a novel HEMS to schedule customers' controllable devices, and a probabilistic power-flow model. Test cases using both energy- and demand-based network tariffs show that flat tariffs with a peak demand component reduce the customers' cost, and alleviate network constraints. This demonstrates, first, the efficacy of the proposed tool for the development of tariffs that are beneficial for networks with a high DER penetration, and second, how customers' HEM systems can be part of the solution.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2020; v1 submitted 3 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Impacts of Community and Distributed Energy Storage Systems on Unbalanced Low Voltage Networks
Authors:
Yiju Ma,
Mohammad Seydali Seyf Abad,
Donald Azuatalam,
Gregor Verbic,
Archie. C. Chapman
Abstract:
Energy storage systems (EES) are expected to be an indispensable resource for mitigating the effects on networks of high penetrations of distributed generation in the near future. This paper analyzes the benefits of EES in unbalanced low voltage (LV) networks regarding three aspects, namely, power losses, the hosting capacity and network unbalance. For doing so, a mixed integer quadratic programmm…
▽ More
Energy storage systems (EES) are expected to be an indispensable resource for mitigating the effects on networks of high penetrations of distributed generation in the near future. This paper analyzes the benefits of EES in unbalanced low voltage (LV) networks regarding three aspects, namely, power losses, the hosting capacity and network unbalance. For doing so, a mixed integer quadratic programmming model (MIQP) is developed to minimize annual energy losses and determine the sizing and placement of ESS, while satisfying voltage constraints. A real unbalanced LV UK grid is adopted to examine the effects of ESS under two scenarios: the installation of one community ESS (CESS) and multiple distributed ESSs (DESSs). The results illustrate that both scenarios present high performance in accomplishing the above tasks, while DESSs, with the same aggregated size, are slightly better. This margin is expected to be amplified as the aggregated size of DESSs increases.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A Novel Probabilistic Framework to Study the Impact of PV-battery Systems on Low-Voltage Distribution Networks
Authors:
Yiju Ma,
Donald Azuatalam,
Thomas Power,
Gregor Verbic,
Archie C. Chapman
Abstract:
Battery storage, particularly residential battery storage coupled with rooftop PV, is emerging as an essential component of the smart grid technology mix. However, including battery storage and other flexible resources like electric vehicles and loads with thermal inertia into a probabilistic analysis based on Monte Carlo (MC) simulation is challenging, because their operational profiles are deter…
▽ More
Battery storage, particularly residential battery storage coupled with rooftop PV, is emerging as an essential component of the smart grid technology mix. However, including battery storage and other flexible resources like electric vehicles and loads with thermal inertia into a probabilistic analysis based on Monte Carlo (MC) simulation is challenging, because their operational profiles are determined by computationally intensive optimization. Additionally, MC analysis requires a large pool of statistically-representative demand profiles to sample from. As a result, the analysis of the network impact of PV-battery systems has attracted little attention in the existing literature. To fill these knowledge gaps, this paper proposes a novel probabilistic framework to study the impact of PV-battery systems on low-voltage distribution networks. Specifically, the framework incorporates home energy management(HEM) operational decisions within the MC time series power flow analysis. First, using available smart meter data, we use a Bayesian nonparametric model to generate statistically-representative synthetic demand and PV profiles. Second, a policy function approximation that emulates battery scheduling decisions is used to make the simulation of optimization-based HEM feasible within the MC framework. The efficacy of our method is demonstrated on three representative low-voltage feeders, where the computation time to execute our MC framework is 5% of that when using explicit optimization methods in each MC sample. The assessment results show that uncoordinated battery scheduling has a limited beneficial impact, which is against the conjecture that batteries will serendipitously mitigate the technical problems induced by PV generation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2019; v1 submitted 20 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.