-
In-depth analysis of solar models with high-metallicity abundances and updated opacity tables
Authors:
G. Buldgen,
A. Noels,
R. Scuflaire,
A. M. Amarsi,
N. Grevesse,
P. Eggenberger,
J. Colgan,
C. J. Fontes,
V. A. Baturin,
A. V. Oreshina,
S. V. Ayukov,
P. Hakel,
D. P. Kilcrease
Abstract:
Due to the high quality constraints available for the Sun, we can carry out combined analyses using neutrino, spectroscopic and helioseismic observations. Such studies lay the ground for future improvements of key physical components of solar and stellar models, such as the equation of state, radiative opacities or prescriptions for macroscopic transport processes of chemicals which are then used…
▽ More
Due to the high quality constraints available for the Sun, we can carry out combined analyses using neutrino, spectroscopic and helioseismic observations. Such studies lay the ground for future improvements of key physical components of solar and stellar models, such as the equation of state, radiative opacities or prescriptions for macroscopic transport processes of chemicals which are then used to study other stars in the Universe. We study the existing degeneracies in solar models using the recent high-metallicity spectroscopic abundances by comparing them to helioseismic and neutrino data and discuss how their properties are impacted by changes in various physical ingredients. We carry out a detailed study of solar models computed with a high-metallicity composition from the literature based on averaged-3D models that was claimed to solve the solar problem. The properties of the solar models are significantly affected by using the recent OPLIB opacities and the inclusion of macroscopic transport. The properties of the standard solar models computed using the OPAL opacities are similar to those using the OP opacities. We show that a modifying the temperature gradient just below the base of the convective zone is required to erase the discrepancies in solar models, particularly in the presence of macroscopic mixing. This can be simulated by a local increase of opacity of a few percent. We conclude that the existing degeneracies and issues in solar modelling are not erased by an increase in the solar metallicity in contradiction to was suggested in recent papers. Therefore, standard solar models cannot be used as an argument for a high metallicity composition. While further work is required to improve solar models, we note that direct helioseismic inversions indicate a low metallicity in the convective envelope, in agreement with spectroscopic analyses based on full 3D models.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Helioseismic determination of the solar metal mass fraction
Authors:
G. Buldgen,
A. Noels,
V. A. Baturin,
A. V. Oreshina,
S. V. Ayukov,
R. Scuflaire,
A. M. Amarsi,
N. Grevesse
Abstract:
Context. The metal mass fraction of the Sun Z is a key constraint in solar modelling, but its value is still under debate. The standard solar chemical composition of the late 2000s have the ratio of metals to hydrogen Z/X = 0.0181, with a small increase to 0.0187 in 2021, as inferred from 3D non-LTE spectroscopy. However, more recent work on a horizontally and temporally averaged <3D> model claim…
▽ More
Context. The metal mass fraction of the Sun Z is a key constraint in solar modelling, but its value is still under debate. The standard solar chemical composition of the late 2000s have the ratio of metals to hydrogen Z/X = 0.0181, with a small increase to 0.0187 in 2021, as inferred from 3D non-LTE spectroscopy. However, more recent work on a horizontally and temporally averaged <3D> model claim Z/X = 0.0225, consistent with the high values of twenty-five years ago based on 1D LTE spectroscopy. Aims. We aim to determine a precise and robust value of the solar metal mass fraction from helioseismic inversions, thus providing independent constraints from spectroscopic methods. Methods. We devise a detailed seismic reconstruction technique of the solar envelope, combining multiple inversions and equations of state to accurately and precisely determine the metal mass fraction value. Results. We show that a low value of the solar metal mass fraction corresponding to Z/X = 0.0187 is favoured by helioseismic constraints and that a higher metal mass fraction corresponding to Z/X = 0.0225 are strongly rejected by helioseismic data. Conclusions. We conclude that direct measurement of the metal mass fraction in the solar envelope favours a low metallicity, in line with the 3D non-LTE spectroscopic determination of 2021. A high metal mass fraction as measured using a <3D> model in 2022 is disfavoured by helioseismology for all modern equations of state used to model the solar convective envelope.
△ Less
Submitted 25 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Ionization of heavy elements and the adiabatic exponent in the solar plasma
Authors:
V. A. Baturin,
A. V. Oreshina,
W. Däppen,
S. V. Ayukov,
A. B. Gorshkov,
V. K. Gryaznov,
I. L. Iosilevskiy
Abstract:
Context. The adiabatic exponent $Γ_1$ is studied as a thermodynamic quantity in the partially ionized plasma of the solar convection zone.
Aims. The aim of this study is to understand the impact of heavy elements on the $Γ_1$ profile. We calculated $Γ_1$ with the SAHA-S equation of state for different chemical compositions of plasma, and we analyzed contributions of individual elements to $Γ_1$.…
▽ More
Context. The adiabatic exponent $Γ_1$ is studied as a thermodynamic quantity in the partially ionized plasma of the solar convection zone.
Aims. The aim of this study is to understand the impact of heavy elements on the $Γ_1$ profile. We calculated $Γ_1$ with the SAHA-S equation of state for different chemical compositions of plasma, and we analyzed contributions of individual elements to $Γ_1$.
Methods. We studied the decrease in $Γ_1$ due to the ionization of heavy elements in comparison with the value obtained for a pure hydrogen-helium plasma. These types of differences are denoted as "Z contributions", and we analyzed them for eight elements (C, N, O, Ne, Mg, S, Si, and Fe) as well as for a mixture of elements corresponding to the solar chemical composition. We compared linear combinations of individual Z contributions with the exact Z contribution. Applying a least-squares technique to the decomposition of the full Z contribution to a basis of individual-element contributions, we obtained the mass fractions of the heavy elements.
Results. The Z contribution of heavy elements can be described by a linear combination of individual-element Z contributions with a high level of accuracy of 5e-6 . The inverse problem of estimating the mass fractions of heavy elements from a given $Γ_1$ profile was considered for the example of solar-type mixtures. In ideal numerical simulations, the mass fractions of the most abundant elements could be determined with a relative accuracy better than a few tenths of a percent. In the presence of random or systematic errors in the $Γ_1$ profile, abundance estimations become remarkably less accurate. If the amplitude of the errors does not exceed 1e-4, we can expect a determination of at least the oxygen abundance with a relative error of about 10%.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Interpolation of equation-of-state data
Authors:
V. A. Baturin,
W. Däppen,
A. V. Oreshina,
S. V. Ayukov,
A. B. Gorshkov
Abstract:
Aims. We use Hermite splines to interpolate pressure and its derivatives simultaneously, thereby preserving mathematical relations between the derivatives. The method therefore guarantees that thermodynamic identities are obeyed even between mesh points. In addition, our method enables an estimation of the precision of the interpolation by comparing the Hermite-spline results with those of frequen…
▽ More
Aims. We use Hermite splines to interpolate pressure and its derivatives simultaneously, thereby preserving mathematical relations between the derivatives. The method therefore guarantees that thermodynamic identities are obeyed even between mesh points. In addition, our method enables an estimation of the precision of the interpolation by comparing the Hermite-spline results with those of frequent cubic (B-) spline interpolation.
Methods. We have interpolated pressure as a function of temperature and density with quintic Hermite 2D-splines. The Hermite interpolation requires knowledge of pressure and its first and second derivatives at every mesh point. To obtain the partial derivatives at the mesh points, we used tabulated values if given or else thermodynamic equalities, or, if not available, values obtained by differentiating B-splines.
Results. The results were obtained with the grid of the SAHA-S equation-of-state (EOS) tables. The maximum $lg P$ difference lies in the range from $10^{-9}$ to $10^{-4}$, and $Γ_1$ difference varies from $10^{-9}$ to $10^{-3}$. Specifically, for the points of a solar model, the maximum differences are one order of magnitude smaller than the aforementioned values. The poorest precision is found in the dissociation and ionization regions, occurring at $T \sim 1.5\cdot 10^3 - 10^5$ K. The best precision is achieved at higher temperatures, $T>10^5$ K. To discuss the significance of the interpolation errors we compare them with the corresponding difference between two different equation-of-state formalisms, SAHA-S and OPAL 2005. We find that the interpolation errors of the pressure are a few orders of magnitude less than the differences from between the physical formalisms, which is particularly true for the solar-model points.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019; v1 submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Helioseismic Measurements in the Solar Envelope Using Group Velocities of Surface Waves
Authors:
S. V. Vorontsov,
V. A. Baturin,
S. V. Ayukov,
V. K. Gryaznov
Abstract:
At intermediate and high degree $l$, solar p- and f modes can be considered as surface waves. Using variational principle, we derive an integral expression for the group velocities of the surface waves in terms of adiabatic eigenfunctions of normal modes, and address the benefits of using group-velocity measurements as a supplementary diagnostic tool in solar seismology. The principal advantage of…
▽ More
At intermediate and high degree $l$, solar p- and f modes can be considered as surface waves. Using variational principle, we derive an integral expression for the group velocities of the surface waves in terms of adiabatic eigenfunctions of normal modes, and address the benefits of using group-velocity measurements as a supplementary diagnostic tool in solar seismology. The principal advantage of using group velocities, when compared with direct analysis of the oscillation frequencies, comes from their smaller sensitivity to the uncertainties in the near-photospheric layers. We address some numerical examples where group velocities are used to reveal inconsistencies between the solar models and the seismic data. Further, we implement the group-velocity measurements to the calibration of the specific entropy, helium abundance Y and heavy-element abundance Z in the adiabatically-stratified part of the solar convective envelope, using different recent versions of the equation of state. The results are in close agreement with our earlier measurements based on more sophisticated analysis of the solar oscillation frequencies (Vorontsov et al. 2013, MNRAS 430, 1636). These results bring further support to the downward revision of the solar heavy-element abundances in recent spectroscopic measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
