-
Challenges for quantum computation of nonlinear dynamical systems using linear representations
Authors:
Yen Ting Lin,
Robert B. Lowrie,
Denis Aslangil,
Yiğit Subaşı,
Andrew T. Sornborger
Abstract:
A number of recent studies have proposed that linear representations are appropriate for solving nonlinear dynamical systems with quantum computers, which fundamentally act linearly on a wave function in a Hilbert space. Linear representations, such as the Koopman representation and Koopman von Neumann mechanics, have regained attention from the dynamical-systems research community. Here, we aim t…
▽ More
A number of recent studies have proposed that linear representations are appropriate for solving nonlinear dynamical systems with quantum computers, which fundamentally act linearly on a wave function in a Hilbert space. Linear representations, such as the Koopman representation and Koopman von Neumann mechanics, have regained attention from the dynamical-systems research community. Here, we aim to present a unified theoretical framework, currently missing in the literature, with which one can compare and relate existing methods, their conceptual basis, and their representations. We also aim to show that, despite the fact that quantum simulation of nonlinear classical systems may be possible with such linear representations, a necessary projection into a feasible finite-dimensional space will in practice eventually induce numerical artifacts which can be hard to eliminate or even control. As a result, a practical, reliable and accurate way to use quantum computation for solving general nonlinear dynamical systems is still an open problem.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2024; v1 submitted 4 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Filtering, averaging and scale dependency in homogeneous variable density turbulence
Authors:
J. A. Saenz,
D. Aslangil,
D. Livescu
Abstract:
We investigate relationships between statistics obtained from filtering and from ensemble or Reynolds-averaging turbulence flow fields as a function of length scale. Generalized central moments in the filtering approach are expressed as inner products of generalized fluctuating quantities, $q'(ξ,x)=q(ξ)-\overline q(x)$, representing fluctuations of a field $q(ξ)$, at any point $ξ$, with respect to…
▽ More
We investigate relationships between statistics obtained from filtering and from ensemble or Reynolds-averaging turbulence flow fields as a function of length scale. Generalized central moments in the filtering approach are expressed as inner products of generalized fluctuating quantities, $q'(ξ,x)=q(ξ)-\overline q(x)$, representing fluctuations of a field $q(ξ)$, at any point $ξ$, with respect to its filtered value at $x$. For positive-definite filter kernels, these expressions provide a scale-resolving framework, with statistics and realizability conditions at any length scale. In the small-scale limit, scale-resolving statistics become zero. In the large-scale limit, scale-resolving statistics and realizability conditions are the same as in the Reynolds-averaged description. Using direct numerical simulations (DNS) of homogeneous variable density turbulence, we diagnose Reynolds stresses, $\mathcal{T}_{ij}$, resolved kinetic energy, $k_r$, turbulent mass-flux velocity, $a_i$, and density-specific volume covariance, $b$, defined in the scale-resolving framework. These variables, and terms in their governing equations, vary smoothly between zero and their Reynolds-averaged definitions at the small and large scale limits, respectively. At intermediate scales, the governing equations exhibit interactions between terms that are not active in the Reynolds-averaged limit. For example, in the Reynolds-averaged limit, $b$ follows a decaying process driven by a destruction term; at intermediate length scales it is a balance between production, redistribution, destruction, and transport, where $b$ grows as the density spectrum develops, and then decays when mixing becomes strong enough. This work supports the notion of a generalized, length-scale adaptive model that converges to DNS at high resolutions, and to Reynolds-averaged statistics at coarse resolutions.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Predicting Nonlinear Seismic Response of Structural Braces Using Machine Learning
Authors:
Elif Ecem Bas,
Denis Aslangil,
Mohamed A. Moustafa
Abstract:
Numerical modeling of different structural materials that have highly nonlinear behaviors has always been a challenging problem in engineering disciplines. Experimental data is commonly used to characterize this behavior. This study aims to improve the modeling capabilities by using state of the art Machine Learning techniques, and attempts to answer several scientific questions: (i) Which ML algo…
▽ More
Numerical modeling of different structural materials that have highly nonlinear behaviors has always been a challenging problem in engineering disciplines. Experimental data is commonly used to characterize this behavior. This study aims to improve the modeling capabilities by using state of the art Machine Learning techniques, and attempts to answer several scientific questions: (i) Which ML algorithm is capable and is more efficient to learn such a complex and nonlinear problem? (ii) Is it possible to artificially reproduce structural brace seismic behavior that can represent real physics? (iii) How can our findings be extended to the different engineering problems that are driven by similar nonlinear dynamics? To answer these questions, the presented methods are validated by using experimental brace data. The paper shows that after proper data preparation, the long-short term memory (LSTM) method is highly capable of capturing the nonlinear behavior of braces. Additionally, the effects of tuning the hyperparameters on the models, such as layer numbers, neuron numbers, and the activation functions, are presented. Finally, the ability to learn nonlinear dynamics by using deep neural network algorithms and their advantages are briefly discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Atwood and Reynolds numbers effects on the evolution of buoyancy-driven homogeneous variable-density turbulence
Authors:
Denis Aslangil,
Daniel Livescu,
Arindam Banerjee
Abstract:
The evolution of buoyancy-driven homogeneous variable-density turbulence (HVDT) at Atwood numbers up to 0.75 and large Reynolds numbers is studied by using high-resolution Direct Numerical Simulations. To help understand the highly non-equilibrium nature of buoyancy-driven HVDT, the flow evolution is divided into four different regimes based on the behavior of turbulent kinetic energy derivatives.…
▽ More
The evolution of buoyancy-driven homogeneous variable-density turbulence (HVDT) at Atwood numbers up to 0.75 and large Reynolds numbers is studied by using high-resolution Direct Numerical Simulations. To help understand the highly non-equilibrium nature of buoyancy-driven HVDT, the flow evolution is divided into four different regimes based on the behavior of turbulent kinetic energy derivatives. The results show that each regime has a unique type of dependency on both Atwood and Reynolds numbers. It is found that the local statistics of the flow based on the flow composition are more sensitive to Atwood and Reynolds numbers compared to those based on the entire flow. It is also observed that at higher Atwood numbers, different flow features reach their asymptotic Reynolds number behavior at different times. The energy spectrum defined based on the Favre fluctuations momentum has less large scale contamination from viscous effects for variable density flows with constant properties, compared to other forms used previously. The evolution of the energy spectrum highlights distinct dynamical features of the four flow regimes. Thus, the slope of the energy spectrum at intermediate to large scales evolves from -7/3 to -1, as a function of the production to dissipation ratio. The classical Kolmogorov spectrum emerges at intermediate to high scales at the highest Reynolds numbers examined, after the turbulence starts to decay. Finally, the similarities and differences between buoyancy-driven HVDT and the more conventional stationary turbulence are discussed and new strategies and tools for analysis are proposed.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Variable-density buoyancy-driven turbulence with asymmetric initial density distribution
Authors:
Denis Aslangil,
Daniel Livescu,
Arindam Banerjee
Abstract:
The effects of different initial density distributions on the evolution of buoyancy-driven homogeneous variable-density turbulence (HVDT) at low (0.05) and high (0.75) Atwood numbers are studied by using high-resolution direct numerical simulations. HVDT aims to mimic the acceleration-driven Rayleigh-Taylor and shock-driven Richtmyer-Meshkov instabilities and reveals new physics that arise from va…
▽ More
The effects of different initial density distributions on the evolution of buoyancy-driven homogeneous variable-density turbulence (HVDT) at low (0.05) and high (0.75) Atwood numbers are studied by using high-resolution direct numerical simulations. HVDT aims to mimic the acceleration-driven Rayleigh-Taylor and shock-driven Richtmyer-Meshkov instabilities and reveals new physics that arise from variable-density effects on the turbulent mixing. Here, the initial amounts of pure light and pure heavy flows are altered primarily to mimic the variable-density turbulence at the different locations of the Rayleigh-Taylor and Richtmyer-Meshkov instabilities' mixing layers where the amounts of the mixing fluids are not equal. It is found that for the low Atwood number cases, the asymmetric initial density distribution has limited effects on both global and local flow evolution for HVDT. However, at high Atwood number, both global flow evolution and the local flow structures are strongly affected by the initial composition ratio. The flow composed of more light fluid reaches higher turbulent levels and the local statistics reach their fully-developed behavior earlier in the time evolution. During the late time decay, where most of the flow is well-mixed, all parameters become independent of the initial composition ratio for both low and high Atwood number cases.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2020; v1 submitted 30 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Two-point spectral model for variable-density homogeneous turbulence
Authors:
Nairita Pal,
Susan Kurien,
Timothy Clark,
Denis Aslangil,
Daniel Livescu
Abstract:
We present a study of buoyancy-driven variable-density homogeneous turbulence, using a two-point spectral closure model. We compute the time-evolution of the spectral distribution in wavenumber $k$ of the correlation of density and specific-volume $b(k)$, the mass flux $\bm{a}(k)$, and the turbulent kinetic energy $E(k)$, using a set of coupled equations. Under the modeling assumptions, each dynam…
▽ More
We present a study of buoyancy-driven variable-density homogeneous turbulence, using a two-point spectral closure model. We compute the time-evolution of the spectral distribution in wavenumber $k$ of the correlation of density and specific-volume $b(k)$, the mass flux $\bm{a}(k)$, and the turbulent kinetic energy $E(k)$, using a set of coupled equations. Under the modeling assumptions, each dynamical variable has two coefficients governing spectral transfer among modes. In addition, the mass flux $\bm{a}(k)$ has two coefficients governing the drag between the two fluids. Using a prescribed initial condition for $b(k)$ and starting from a quiescent flow, we first evaluate the relative importance of the different coefficients used to model this system, and their impact on the statistical quantities. We next assess the accuracy of the model, relative to Direct Numerical simulation of the complete hydrodynamical equations, using $b$, ${\bm a}$ and $E$ as metrics. We show that the model is able to capture the spectral distribution and global means of all three statistical quantities at both low and high Atwood number for a set of optimized coefficients. The optimization procedure also permits us to discern a minimal set of four coefficients which are sufficient to yield reasonable results while pointing to the mechanisms that dominate the mixing process in this problem.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.