What it takes to solve the Origin(s) of Life: An integrated review of techniques
Authors:
OoLEN,
Silke Asche,
Carla Bautista,
David Boulesteix,
Alexandre Champagne-Ruel,
Cole Mathis,
Omer Markovitch,
Zhen Peng,
Alyssa Adams,
Avinash Vicholous Dass,
Arnaud Buch,
Eloi Camprubi,
Enrico Sandro Colizzi,
Stephanie Colón-Santos,
Hannah Dromiack,
Valentina Erastova,
Amanda Garcia,
Ghjuvan Grimaud,
Aaron Halpern,
Stuart A Harrison,
Seán F. Jordan,
Tony Z Jia,
Amit Kahana,
Artemy Kolchinsky,
Odin Moron-Garcia
, et al. (13 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Understanding the origin(s) of life (OoL) is a fundamental challenge for science in the 21st century. Research on OoL spans many disciplines, including chemistry, physics, biology, planetary sciences, computer science, mathematics and philosophy. The sheer number of different scientific perspectives relevant to the problem has resulted in the coexistence of diverse tools, techniques, data, and sof…
▽ More
Understanding the origin(s) of life (OoL) is a fundamental challenge for science in the 21st century. Research on OoL spans many disciplines, including chemistry, physics, biology, planetary sciences, computer science, mathematics and philosophy. The sheer number of different scientific perspectives relevant to the problem has resulted in the coexistence of diverse tools, techniques, data, and software in OoL studies. This has made communication between the disciplines relevant to the OoL extremely difficult because the interpretation of data, analyses, or standards of evidence can vary dramatically. Here, we hope to bridge this wide field of study by providing common ground via the consolidation of tools and techniques rather than positing a unifying view on how life emerges. We review the common tools and techniques that have been used significantly in OoL studies in recent years. In particular, we aim to identify which information is most relevant for comparing and integrating the results of experimental analyses into mathematical and computational models. This review aims to provide a baseline expectation and understanding of technical aspects of origins research, rather than being a primer on any particular topic. As such, it spans broadly -- from analytical chemistry to mathematical models -- and highlights areas of future work that will benefit from a multidisciplinary approach to tackling the mystery of life's origin. Ultimately, we hope to empower a new generation of OoL scientists by reviewing how they can investigate life's origin, rather than dictating how to think about the problem.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2023; v1 submitted 22 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
Learning a reactive potential for silica-water through uncertainty attribution
Authors:
Swagata Roy,
Johannes P. Dürholt,
Thomas S. Asche,
Federico Zipoli,
Rafael Gómez-Bombarelli
Abstract:
The reactivity of silicates in an aqueous solution is relevant to various chemistries ranging from silicate minerals in geology, to the C-S-H phase in cement, nanoporous zeolite catalysts, or highly porous precipitated silica. While simulations of chemical reactions can provide insight at the molecular level, balancing accuracy and scale in reactive simulations in the condensed phase is a challeng…
▽ More
The reactivity of silicates in an aqueous solution is relevant to various chemistries ranging from silicate minerals in geology, to the C-S-H phase in cement, nanoporous zeolite catalysts, or highly porous precipitated silica. While simulations of chemical reactions can provide insight at the molecular level, balancing accuracy and scale in reactive simulations in the condensed phase is a challenge. Here, we demonstrate how a machine-learning reactive interatomic potential can accurately capture silicate-water reactivity. The model was trained on a new dataset comprising 400,000 energies and forces of molecular clusters at the $ω$-B97XD def2-TVZP level. To ensure the robustness of the model, we introduce a new and general active learning strategy based on the attribution of the model uncertainty, that automatically isolates uncertain regions of bulk simulations to be calculated as small-sized clusters. Our trained potential is found to reproduce static and dynamic properties of liquid water and solid crystalline silicates, despite having been trained exclusively on cluster data. Furthermore, we utilize enhanced sampling simulations to recover the self-ionization reactivity of water accurately, and the acidity of silicate oligomers, and lastly study the silicate dimerization reaction in a water solution at neutral conditions and find that the reaction occurs through a flanking mechanism.
△ Less
Submitted 4 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
