-
Demonstration of a Mobile Optical Clock Ensemble at Sea
Authors:
E. Ahern,
J. W. Allison,
C. Billington,
N. Bourbeau Hébert,
A. P. Hilton,
E. Klantsataya,
C. Locke,
A. N. Luiten,
M. Nelligan,
R. F. Offer,
C. Perrella,
S. K. Scholten,
B. White,
B. M. Sparkes,
R. Beard,
J. D. Elgin,
K. W. Martin
Abstract:
Atomic clocks have been at the leading edge of accuracy and precision since their inception in the 1950s. However, typically the most capable of these clocks have been confined to laboratories despite the fact that there are compelling reasons to apply them in the field and/or while in motion. These applications include synchronization of distributed critical infrastructure (e.g. data servers, com…
▽ More
Atomic clocks have been at the leading edge of accuracy and precision since their inception in the 1950s. However, typically the most capable of these clocks have been confined to laboratories despite the fact that there are compelling reasons to apply them in the field and/or while in motion. These applications include synchronization of distributed critical infrastructure (e.g. data servers, communications, electricity grids), scientific applications (e.g. radio-astronomy) and to mitigate the effects of interruption to Global Navigation Satellite Systems.
Over the last 20 years, there has been a breakthrough in the performance of atomic clocks by transitioning from an atomic reference based on a microwave transition to an optical frequency transition. The $10^5$-fold increase in reference frequency confers the potential for significantly higher performance. However, this performance increase has come at the cost of size, complexity and fragility which has continued the confinement of these clocks to the laboratory.
Here we report on a recent international collaboration where three emerging optical clocks, each operating on different principles, were trialed at sea. These clocks incorporate optical frequency combs so that their stable frequency outputs can be used directly in electronic apparatus and were also automated so that they do not require expert supervision. We present the frequency stability and reliability of these three clocks over multiple weeks of unsupervised naval trials, both in harbour and on the ocean. The performance of all three devices was orders of magnitude superior to existing best-in-class commercial solutions over short and medium timescales. This demonstrates that optical clocks are ready to deliver advantages for real-world applications.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2024; v1 submitted 5 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Structure and dynamics investigations of a partially hydrogenated graphene/Ni(111) surface
Authors:
Emanuel Bahn,
Anton Tamtögl,
John Ellis,
William Allison,
Peter Fouquet
Abstract:
Using helium-3 atom scattering, we have studied the adsorption kinetics, the structure and the diffusional dynamics of atomic hydrogen on the surface of a graphene monolayer on Ni(111). Diffraction measurements reveal a 4$^\circ$ rotated rectangular hydrogen overstructure. Hydrogen adsorption and desorption exhibit activation barriers of $E_a=(89\pm7)\,$meV and $E_d=(1.8\pm0.2)\,$eV, respectively.…
▽ More
Using helium-3 atom scattering, we have studied the adsorption kinetics, the structure and the diffusional dynamics of atomic hydrogen on the surface of a graphene monolayer on Ni(111). Diffraction measurements reveal a 4$^\circ$ rotated rectangular hydrogen overstructure. Hydrogen adsorption and desorption exhibit activation barriers of $E_a=(89\pm7)\,$meV and $E_d=(1.8\pm0.2)\,$eV, respectively. Helium-3 spin-echo measurements showed no decay of the spatial correlation function (or intermediate scattering function) within the time range of the spectrometer. Hence, we are able to set lower limits for a possible hydrogen surface diffusion rate.
△ Less
Submitted 14 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Inter-adsorbate forces and coherent scattering in helium spin-echo experiments
Authors:
David J. Ward,
Arjun Raghavan,
Anton Tamtögl,
Andrew P. Jardine,
Emanuel Bahn,
John Ellis,
Salvador Miret-Artés,
William Allison
Abstract:
In studies of dynamical systems, helium atoms scatter coherently from an ensemble of adsorbates as they diffuse on the surface. The results give information on the co-operative behaviour of interacting adsorbates and thus include the effects of both adsorbate-substrate and adsorbate-adsorbate interactions. Here, we discuss a method to disentangle the effects of interactions between adsorbates from…
▽ More
In studies of dynamical systems, helium atoms scatter coherently from an ensemble of adsorbates as they diffuse on the surface. The results give information on the co-operative behaviour of interacting adsorbates and thus include the effects of both adsorbate-substrate and adsorbate-adsorbate interactions. Here, we discuss a method to disentangle the effects of interactions between adsorbates from those with the substrate. The result gives an approximation to observations that would be obtained if the scattering was incoherent. Information from the experiment can therefore be used to distinguish more clearly between long-range inter-adsorbate forces and the short range effects arising from the local lattice potential and associated thermal excitations. The method is discussed in the context of a system with strong inter-adsorbate interactions, sodium atoms diffusing on a copper (111) surface.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2020; v1 submitted 5 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Motion of water monomers reveals a kinetic barrier to ice nucleation on graphene
Authors:
Anton Tamtögl,
Emanuel Bahn,
Marco Sacchi,
Jianding Zhu,
David J. Ward,
Andrew P. Jardine,
Steven J. Jenkins,
Peter Fouquet,
John Ellis,
William Allison
Abstract:
The interfacial behaviour of water remains a central question to fields as diverse as protein folding, friction and ice formation[1,2]. While the structural and dynamical properties of water at interfaces differ strongly from those in the bulk, major gaps in our knowledge at the molecular level still prevent us from understanding these ubiquitous chemical processes. Information concerning the micr…
▽ More
The interfacial behaviour of water remains a central question to fields as diverse as protein folding, friction and ice formation[1,2]. While the structural and dynamical properties of water at interfaces differ strongly from those in the bulk, major gaps in our knowledge at the molecular level still prevent us from understanding these ubiquitous chemical processes. Information concerning the microscopic motion of water comes mostly from computational simulation[3,4] but the dynamics of molecules, on the atomic scale, is largely unexplored by experiment. Here we present experimental results combined with ab initio calculations to provide a detailed insight into the behaviour of water monomers on a graphene surface. We show that motion occurs by activated hop** on the graphene lattice. The dynamics of water diffusion displays remarkably strong signatures of cooperative behaviour due to repulsive forces between the monomers. The repulsive forces enhance the monomer lifetime ($t_m \approx 3$ s at $T_S = 125$ K) in a $\textit{free-gas}$ phase that precedes the nucleation of ice islands and, in turn, provides the opportunity for our experiments to be performed. Our results give a unique molecular perspective of barriers to ice nucleation on material surfaces, providing new routes to understand and potentially control the more general process of ice formation.
△ Less
Submitted 23 March, 2021; v1 submitted 1 October, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
-
Nanoscale Surface Dynamics of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111): Observation of a Prominent Surface Acoustic Wave and the Role of van der Waals Interactions
Authors:
Anton Tamtögl,
Davide Campi,
Martin Bremholm,
Ellen M. J. Hedegaard,
Bo B. Iversen,
Marco Bianchi,
Philip Hofmann,
Nicola Marzari,
Giorgio Benedek,
John Ellis,
William Allison
Abstract:
We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of the surface vibrational modes of the topological insulator Bi$_2$Te$_3$. Using high-resolution helium-3 spin-echo spectroscopy we are able to resolve the acoustic phonon modes of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111). The low energy region of the lattice vibrations is mainly dominated by the Rayleigh mode which has been claimed to be absent in previous exper…
▽ More
We present a combined experimental and theoretical study of the surface vibrational modes of the topological insulator Bi$_2$Te$_3$. Using high-resolution helium-3 spin-echo spectroscopy we are able to resolve the acoustic phonon modes of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111). The low energy region of the lattice vibrations is mainly dominated by the Rayleigh mode which has been claimed to be absent in previous experimental studies. The appearance of the Rayleigh mode is consistent with previous bulk lattice dynamics studies as well as theoretical predictions of the surface phonon modes. Density functional perturbation theory calculations including van der Waals corrections are in excellent agreement with the experimental data. Comparison of the experimental results with theoretically obtained values for films with a thickness of several layers further demonstrate, that for an accurate theoretical description of three-dimensional topological insulators with their layered structure the inclusion of van der Waals corrections is essential. The presence of a prominent surface acoustic wave and the contribution of van der Waals bonding to the lattice dynamics may hold important implications for the thermoelectric properties of thin-film and nanoscale devices.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2018; v1 submitted 29 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
A Helium-Surface Interaction Potential of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) from Ultrahigh-Resolution Spin-Echo Measurements
Authors:
Anton Tamtögl,
Michael Pusterhofer,
Martin Bremholm,
Ellen M. J. Hedegaard,
Bo B. Iversen,
Philip Hofmann,
John Ellis,
William Allison,
S. Miret-Artés,
Wolfgang E. Ernst
Abstract:
We have determined an atom-surface interaction potential for the He$-$Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) system by analysing ultrahigh resolution measurements of selective adsorption resonances. The experimental measurements were obtained using $^3$He spin-echo spectrometry. Following an initial free-particle model analysis, we use elastic close-coupling calculations to obtain a three-dimensional potential. The th…
▽ More
We have determined an atom-surface interaction potential for the He$-$Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) system by analysing ultrahigh resolution measurements of selective adsorption resonances. The experimental measurements were obtained using $^3$He spin-echo spectrometry. Following an initial free-particle model analysis, we use elastic close-coupling calculations to obtain a three-dimensional potential. The three-dimensional potential is then further refined based on the experimental data set, giving rise to an optimised potential which fully reproduces the experimental data. Based on this analysis, the He$-$Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) interaction potential can be described by a corrugated Morse potential with a well depth $D=(6.22\pm0.05)~\mathrm{meV}$, a stiffness $κ=(0.92\pm0.01)~\mathrmÅ^{-1}$ and a surface electronic corrugation of $(9.6\pm0.2)$% of the lattice constant. The improved uncertainties of the atom-surface interaction potential should also enable the use in inelastic close-coupled calculations in order to eventually study the temperature dependence and the line width of selective adsorption resonances.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Polarisation in Spin-Echo Experiments: Multi-point and Lock-in Measurements
Authors:
Anton Tamtögl,
Benjamin Davey,
David J. Ward,
Andrew P. Jardine,
John Ellis,
William Allison
Abstract:
Spin-echo instruments are typically used to measure diffusive processes and the dynamics and motion in samples on ps and ns timescales. A key aspect of the spin-echo technique is to determine the polarisation of a particle beam. We present two methods for measuring the spin polarisation in spin-echo experiments. The current method in use is based on taking a number of discrete readings. The implem…
▽ More
Spin-echo instruments are typically used to measure diffusive processes and the dynamics and motion in samples on ps and ns timescales. A key aspect of the spin-echo technique is to determine the polarisation of a particle beam. We present two methods for measuring the spin polarisation in spin-echo experiments. The current method in use is based on taking a number of discrete readings. The implementation of a new method involves continuously rotating the spin and measuring its polarisation after being scattered from the sample. A control system running on a microcontroller is used to perform the spin rotation and to calculate the polarisation of the scattered beam based on a lock-in amplifier. First experimental tests of the method on a helium spin-echo spectrometer, show that it is clearly working and that it has advantages over the discrete approach i.e. it can track changes of the beam properties throughout the experiment. Moreover, we show that real-time numerical simulations can perfectly describe a complex experiment and can be easily used to develop improved experimental methods prior to a first hardware implementation.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2018;
originally announced January 2018.
-
Electron-Phonon Coupling and Surface Debye Temperature of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) from Helium Atom Scattering
Authors:
Anton Tamtögl,
Patrick Kraus,
Nadav Avidor,
Martin Bremholm,
Ellen M. J. Hedegaard,
Bo B. Iversen,
Marco Bianchi,
Philip Hofmann,
John Ellis,
William Allison,
Giorgio Benedek,
Wolfgang E. Ernst
Abstract:
We have studied the topological insulator Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) by means of helium atom scattering. The average electron-phonon coupling $λ$ of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) is determined by adapting a recently developed quantum-theoretical derivation of the helium scattering probabilities to the case of degenerate semiconductors. Based on the Debye-Waller attenuation of the elastic diffraction peaks of Bi$_2$Te…
▽ More
We have studied the topological insulator Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) by means of helium atom scattering. The average electron-phonon coupling $λ$ of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) is determined by adapting a recently developed quantum-theoretical derivation of the helium scattering probabilities to the case of degenerate semiconductors. Based on the Debye-Waller attenuation of the elastic diffraction peaks of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111), measured at surface temperatures between $110~\mbox{K}$ and $355~\mbox{K}$, we find $λ$ to be in the range of $0.04-0.11$. This method allows to extract a correctly averaged $λ$ and to address the discrepancy between previous studies. The relatively modest value of $λ$ is not surprising even though some individual phonons may provide a larger electron-phonon interaction.
Furthermore, the surface Debye temperature of Bi$_2$Te$_3$(111) is determined as ${\rm Θ}_D = (81\pm6)~\mbox{K}$. The electronic surface corrugation was analysed based on close-coupling calculations. By using a corrugated Morse potential a peak-to-peak corrugation of 9% of the lattice constant is obtained.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
How Atomic Steps Modify Diffusion and Inter-adsorbate Forces: Empirical Evidence From Hop** Dynamics in Na/Cu(115)
Authors:
O. Godsi,
G. Corem,
T. Kravchuk,
C. Bertram,
K. Morgenstern,
H. Hedgeland,
A. P. Jardine,
W. Allison,
J. Ellis,
G. Alexandrowicz
Abstract:
We followed the collective atomic-scale motion of Na atoms on a vicinal Cu(115) surface within a time scale of pico to nano-seconds using helium spin echo spectroscopy. The well defined stepped structure of Cu(115) allows us to study the effect that atomic steps have on the adsorption properties, the rate for motion parallel and perpendicular to the step edge and the interaction between the Na ato…
▽ More
We followed the collective atomic-scale motion of Na atoms on a vicinal Cu(115) surface within a time scale of pico to nano-seconds using helium spin echo spectroscopy. The well defined stepped structure of Cu(115) allows us to study the effect that atomic steps have on the adsorption properties, the rate for motion parallel and perpendicular to the step edge and the interaction between the Na atoms. With the support of a molecular dynamics simulation we show that the Na atoms perform strongly anisotropic one dimensional hop** motion parallel to the step edges. Furthermore, we observe that the spatial and temporal correlations between the Na atoms which lead to collective motion are also anisotropic, suggesting the steps efficiently screen the lateral interaction between Na atoms residing on different terraces.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Energy Dissipation during Diffusion at Metal Surfaces: Disentangling the Role of Phonons vs. Electron-Hole Pairs
Authors:
Simon P. Rittmeyer,
David J. Ward,
Patrick Gütlein,
John Ellis,
William Allison,
Karsten Reuter
Abstract:
Helium spin echo experiments combined with ab initio-based Langevin molecular dynamics simulations are used to quantify the adsorbate-substrate coupling during the thermal diffusion of Na atoms on Cu(111). An analysis of trajectories within the local density friction approximation allows the contribution from electron-hole pair excitations to be separated from the total energy dissipation. Despite…
▽ More
Helium spin echo experiments combined with ab initio-based Langevin molecular dynamics simulations are used to quantify the adsorbate-substrate coupling during the thermal diffusion of Na atoms on Cu(111). An analysis of trajectories within the local density friction approximation allows the contribution from electron-hole pair excitations to be separated from the total energy dissipation. Despite the minimal electronic friction coefficient of Na and the relatively small mass mismatch to Cu promoting efficient phononic dissipation, about $(20\pm5)\%$ of the total energy loss is attributable to electronic friction. The results suggest a significant role of electronic non-adiabaticity in the rapid thermalization generally relied upon in adiabatic diffusion theories.
△ Less
Submitted 14 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
Quantum effects in the diffusion of hydrogen on Ru(0001)
Authors:
Eliza M. McIntosh,
K. Thor Wikfeldt,
John Ellis,
Angelos Michaelides,
William Allison
Abstract:
An understanding of hydrogen diffusion on metal surfaces is important, not just for its role in heterogeneous catalysis and hydrogen fuel cell technology, but also because it provides model systems where tunneling can be studied under well-defined conditions. Here we report helium spin-echo measurements of the atomic-scale motion of hydrogen on the Ru(0001) surface between 75 and 250 K. Quantum ef…
▽ More
An understanding of hydrogen diffusion on metal surfaces is important, not just for its role in heterogeneous catalysis and hydrogen fuel cell technology, but also because it provides model systems where tunneling can be studied under well-defined conditions. Here we report helium spin-echo measurements of the atomic-scale motion of hydrogen on the Ru(0001) surface between 75 and 250 K. Quantum effects are evident at temperatures as high as 200 K, while below 120 K we observe a tunneling-dominated temperature independent jump rate of 1.9$\times$10$^9$ s$^{-1}$, many orders of magnitude faster than previously seen. Quantum transition state theory calculations based on ab initio path-integral simulations reproduce the temperature dependence of the rate at higher temperatures and predict a crossover to tunneling-dominated diffusion at low temperatures, although the tunneling rate is under-estimated, highlighting the need for future experimental and theoretical studies of hydrogen diffusion on well-defined surfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2014;
originally announced April 2014.
-
Atomic scale friction of molecular adsorbates during diffusion
Authors:
B. A. J. Lechner,
A. S. de Wijn,
H. Hedgeland,
A. P. Jardine,
B. J. Hinch,
W. Allison,
J. Ellis
Abstract:
Experimental observations suggest that molecular adsorbates exhibit a larger friction coefficient than atomic species of comparable mass, yet the origin of this increased friction is not well understood. We present a study of the microscopic origins of friction experienced by molecular adsorbates during surface diffusion. Helium spin-echo measurements of a range of five-membered aromatic molecules…
▽ More
Experimental observations suggest that molecular adsorbates exhibit a larger friction coefficient than atomic species of comparable mass, yet the origin of this increased friction is not well understood. We present a study of the microscopic origins of friction experienced by molecular adsorbates during surface diffusion. Helium spin-echo measurements of a range of five-membered aromatic molecules, cyclopentadienyl (Cp), pyrrole and thiophene, on a copper(111) surface are compared with molecular dynamics simulations of the respective systems. The adsorbates have different chemical interactions with the surface and differ in bonding geometry, yet the measurements show that the friction is greater than 2 ps$^{-1}$ for all these molecules. We demonstrate that the internal and external degrees of freedom of these adsorbate species are a key factor in the underlying microscopic processes and identify the rotation modes as the ones contributing most to the total measured friction coefficient.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2013;
originally announced May 2013.
-
Ab Initio Liquid Hydrogen Muon Cooling Simulations with ELMS in ICOOL
Authors:
W. W. M. Allison,
J. H. Cobb,
S. J. Holmes,
R. C. Fernow,
R. B. Palmer
Abstract:
This paper presents new theoretical results on the passage of muons through liquid hydrogen which have been confirmed in a recent experiment. These are used to demonstrate that muon bunches may be compressed by ionisation cooling more effectively than suggested by previous calculations.
Muon cooling depends on the differential cross section for energy loss and scattering of muons. We have calc…
▽ More
This paper presents new theoretical results on the passage of muons through liquid hydrogen which have been confirmed in a recent experiment. These are used to demonstrate that muon bunches may be compressed by ionisation cooling more effectively than suggested by previous calculations.
Muon cooling depends on the differential cross section for energy loss and scattering of muons. We have calculated this cross section for liquid H2 from first principles and atomic data, avoiding traditional assumptions. Thence, 2-D probability maps of energy loss and scattering in mm-scale thicknesses are derived by folding, and stored in a database. Large first-order correlations between energy loss and scattering are found for H2, which are absent in other simulations. This code is named ELMS, Energy Loss & Multiple Scattering. Single particle trajectories may then be tracked by Monte Carlo sampling from this database on a scale of 1 mm or less. This processor has been inserted into the cooling code ICOOL. Significant improvements in 6-D muon cooling are predicted compared with previous predictions based on GEANT. This is examined in various geometries. The large correlation effect is found to have only a small effect on cooling. The experimental scattering observed for liquid H2 in the MUSCAT experiment has recently been reported to be in good agreement with the ELMS prediction, but in poor agreement with GEANT simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2006;
originally announced September 2006.
-
Neutrino Oscillation Effects in Soudan-2 Upward-stop** muons
Authors:
Soudan-2 Collaboration,
W. W. M. Allison
Abstract:
Upward-going stop** muons initiated by atmospheric \numu and \anumu interactions in the rock below the Soudan 2 detector have been isolated, together with a companion sample of neutrino-induced single muons, created within the detector, which travel downwards and exit. The downward-going sample is consistent with the atmospheric-neutrino flux prediction, but the upward-going sample exhibits a…
▽ More
Upward-going stop** muons initiated by atmospheric \numu and \anumu interactions in the rock below the Soudan 2 detector have been isolated, together with a companion sample of neutrino-induced single muons, created within the detector, which travel downwards and exit. The downward-going sample is consistent with the atmospheric-neutrino flux prediction, but the upward-going sample exhibits a sizeable depletion. Both are consistent with previously reported Soudan-2 neutrino-oscillation results. Inclusion of the two samples in an all-event likelihood analysis, using recent 3D-atmospheric-neutrino-flux calculations, reduces both the allowed oscillation parameter region and the probability of the no-oscillation hypothesis.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2005;
originally announced July 2005.
-
The Atmospheric Neutrino Flavor Ratio from a 3.9 Fiducial Kiloton-Year Exposure of Soudan 2
Authors:
The Soudan 2 Collaboration,
W. W. M. Allison
Abstract:
We report a measurement of the atmospheric neutrino flavor ratio, R, using a sample of quasi-elastic neutrino interactions occurring in an iron medium. The flavor ratio (tracks/showers) of atmospheric neutrinos in a 3.9 fiducial kiloton-year exposure of Soudan 2 is 0.64 +- 0.11 (stat.) +- 0.06 (syst.) of that expected. Important aspects of our main analysis have been checked by carrying out two…
▽ More
We report a measurement of the atmospheric neutrino flavor ratio, R, using a sample of quasi-elastic neutrino interactions occurring in an iron medium. The flavor ratio (tracks/showers) of atmospheric neutrinos in a 3.9 fiducial kiloton-year exposure of Soudan 2 is 0.64 +- 0.11 (stat.) +- 0.06 (syst.) of that expected. Important aspects of our main analysis have been checked by carrying out two independent, alternative analyses; one is based upon automated scanning, the other uses a multivariate approach for background subtraction. Similar results are found by all three approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 1999;
originally announced January 1999.
-
Measurement of the atmospheric neutrino flavour composition in Soudan 2
Authors:
W. W. M. Allison,
G. J. Alner,
D. S. Ayres,
W. L. Barrett,
C. Bode,
P. M. Border,
C. B. Brooks,
J. H. Cobb,
D. J. A. Cockerill,
R. J. Cotton,
H. Courant,
D. M. DeMuth,
T. H. Fields,
H. R. Gallagher,
C. Garcia-Garcia,
M. C. Goodman,
R. N. Gray,
K. Johns,
T. Kafka,
S. M. S. Kasahara,
W. Leeson,
P. J. Litchfield,
N. P. Longley,
M. J. Lowe,
W. A. Mann
, et al. (30 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The atmospheric neutrino flavour ratio measured using a 1.52 kton-year exposure of Soudan 2 is found to be 0.72 +- 0.19 +0.05 -0.07 relative to the expected value from a Monte Carlo calculation. The possible background of interactions of neutrons and photons produced in muon interactions in the rock surrounding the detector has been investigated and is shown not to produce low values of the rati…
▽ More
The atmospheric neutrino flavour ratio measured using a 1.52 kton-year exposure of Soudan 2 is found to be 0.72 +- 0.19 +0.05 -0.07 relative to the expected value from a Monte Carlo calculation. The possible background of interactions of neutrons and photons produced in muon interactions in the rock surrounding the detector has been investigated and is shown not to produce low values of the ratio.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 1996; v1 submitted 13 November, 1996;
originally announced November 1996.
