-
The Nonlinear Evolution of Whistler-Mode Chorus Revisited: Modulation Instability as the Source of Tones
Authors:
Daniel Ratliff,
Oliver Allanson
Abstract:
We review the modulation stability of parallel propagating/field aligned Whistler Mode Chorus waves propagating in a warm plasma from a formal perspective with a focus on wave-particle interactions. The modulation instability criteria is characterised by a curvature of the dispersion relation for Whistler mode waves and a condition on the ratio between the group velocity $c_g$ and the electron sou…
▽ More
We review the modulation stability of parallel propagating/field aligned Whistler Mode Chorus waves propagating in a warm plasma from a formal perspective with a focus on wave-particle interactions. The modulation instability criteria is characterised by a curvature of the dispersion relation for Whistler mode waves and a condition on the ratio between the group velocity $c_g$ and the electron sound speed $c_{s,e}$. We also demonstrate the in order to investigate the spatiotemporal evolution of the envelope and the formation of packets, one necessarily needs to account for the motion of ions within the system, leading to an ionic influence on the modulation instability threshold determined by the ion fraction of the plasma. Finally, we demonstrate that chir** may be captured when higher order effects are included within the spatiotemporal evolution of the amplitude. This yields not only an explicit expression for the sweep rate but identifies a possible origin for the power band gap that occurs at half the electron gyrofrequency. Numerical validation demonstrates that the interaction between wave packets is a source for the emergence of tones observed within mission data, and such interactions may be a major source of the electron energisation which Whistler-Mode chorus are responsible for.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Linear, Quasi-Linear and Nonlinear Radial Transport in the Earth's Radiation Belts
Authors:
Adnane Osmane,
Emilia Kilpua,
Harriet George,
Oliver Allanson,
Milla Kalliokoski
Abstract:
Observational studies of the Earth's radiation belts indicate that Alfvénic fluctuations in the frequency range of 2-25 mHz accelerate magnetically trapped electrons to relativistic energies. For decades, statistical models of the Earth's radiation belts have quantified the impact of Alfvénic waves in terms of quasi-linear diffusive models. However, quasi-linear models are inadequate to quantify A…
▽ More
Observational studies of the Earth's radiation belts indicate that Alfvénic fluctuations in the frequency range of 2-25 mHz accelerate magnetically trapped electrons to relativistic energies. For decades, statistical models of the Earth's radiation belts have quantified the impact of Alfvénic waves in terms of quasi-linear diffusive models. However, quasi-linear models are inadequate to quantify Alfvénic radial transport occurring on timescales comparable to the azimuthal drift period of $0.1- 10$ MeV electrons. With recent advances in observational methodologies offering spatial and temporal coverage of the Earth's radiation belts on fast timescales, a theoretical framework that distinguishes between fast and diffusive radial transport can also be tested for the first time with in situ measurements. In this report, we present a drift kinetic description of radial transport for planetary radiation belts. We characterize linear processes that are too fast to be modelled by quasi-linear models and determine the conditions under which nonlinearities become dynamically significant. In the linear regime, wave-particle interactions are categorized in terms of resonant and non-resonant responses. We demonstrate that the phenomenon of zebra stripes is non-resonant and can originate from the injection of particles in the inner radiation belts. We derive a radial diffusion coefficient for a field model that satisfies Faraday's law and that contains two terms: one scaling as $L^{10}$ independent of the azimuthal number $m$, and a second one scaling as $m^2 L^6$. In the nonlinear regime, we show that azimuthally symmetric waves with properties consistent with in situ measurements can energize 10-100 keV electrons in less than a drift period. This coherent process provides new evidence that acceleration by Alfvénic waves in radiation belts cannot be fully contained within diffusive models.
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2023; v1 submitted 6 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
A family of Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium distribution functions describing a transition from the Harris sheet to the force-free Harris sheet
Authors:
T. Neukirch,
F. Wilson,
O. Allanson
Abstract:
We discuss a family of Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium distribution functions for current sheet equilibria that are intermediate cases between the Harris sheet and the force-free (or modified) Harris sheet. These equilibrium distribution functions have potential applications to space and astrophysical plasmas. The existence of these distribution function had been briefly discussed in by Harrison and Ne…
▽ More
We discuss a family of Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium distribution functions for current sheet equilibria that are intermediate cases between the Harris sheet and the force-free (or modified) Harris sheet. These equilibrium distribution functions have potential applications to space and astrophysical plasmas. The existence of these distribution function had been briefly discussed in by Harrison and Neukirch 2009, but here it is shown that their approach runs into problems in the limit where the guide field goes to zero. The nature of this problem will be discussed and an alternative approach will be suggested that avoids the problem. This is achieved by considering a slight variation of the magnetic field profile, which allows a smooth transition between the Harris and force-free Harris sheet cases.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Kinetic models of tangential discontinuities in the solar wind
Authors:
T. Neukirch,
I. Y. Vasko,
A. V. Artemyev,
O. Allanson
Abstract:
Kinetic-scale current sheets observed in the solar wind are frequently approximately force-free despite the fact that their plasma $β$ is of the order of one. In-situ measurements have recently shown that plasma density and temperature often vary across the current sheets, while the plasma pressure is approximately uniform. In many cases these density and temperature variations are asymmetric with…
▽ More
Kinetic-scale current sheets observed in the solar wind are frequently approximately force-free despite the fact that their plasma $β$ is of the order of one. In-situ measurements have recently shown that plasma density and temperature often vary across the current sheets, while the plasma pressure is approximately uniform. In many cases these density and temperature variations are asymmetric with respect to the center of the current sheet. To model these observations theoretically we develop in this paper equilibria of kinetic-scale force-free current sheets that have plasma density and temperature gradients. The models can also be useful for analysis of stability and dissipation of the current sheets in the solar wind.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
The in-situ exploration of Jupiter's radiation belts (A White Paper submitted in response to ESA's Voyage 2050 Call)
Authors:
Elias Roussos,
Oliver Allanson,
Nicolas André,
Bruna Bertucci,
Graziella Branduardi-Raymont,
George Clark,
Kostantinos Dialynas,
Iannis Dandouras,
Ravindra Desai,
Yoshifumi Futaana,
Matina Gkioulidou,
Geraint Jones,
Peter Kollmann,
Anna Kotova,
Elena Kronberg,
Norbert Krupp,
Go Murakami,
Quentin Nénon,
Tom Nordheim,
Benjamin Palmaerts,
Christina Plainaki,
Jonathan Rae,
Daniel Santos-Costa,
Theodore Sarris,
Yuri Shprits
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Jupiter has the most energetic and complex radiation belts in our solar system. Their hazardous environment is the reason why so many spacecraft avoid rather than investigate them, and explains how they have kept many of their secrets so well hidden, despite having been studied for decades. In this White Paper we argue why these secrets are worth unveiling. Jupiter's radiation belts and the vast m…
▽ More
Jupiter has the most energetic and complex radiation belts in our solar system. Their hazardous environment is the reason why so many spacecraft avoid rather than investigate them, and explains how they have kept many of their secrets so well hidden, despite having been studied for decades. In this White Paper we argue why these secrets are worth unveiling. Jupiter's radiation belts and the vast magnetosphere that encloses them constitute an unprecedented physical laboratory, suitable for both interdisciplinary and novel scientific investigations: from studying fundamental high energy plasma physics processes which operate throughout the universe, such as adiabatic charged particle acceleration and nonlinear wave-particle interactions; to exploiting the astrobiological consequences of energetic particle radiation. The in-situ exploration of the uninviting environment of Jupiter's radiation belts present us with many challenges in mission design, science planning, instrumentation and technology development. We address these challenges by reviewing the different options that exist for direct and indirect observation of this unique system. We stress the need for new instruments, the value of synergistic Earth and Jupiter-based remote sensing and in-situ investigations, and the vital importance of multi-spacecraft, in-situ measurements. While simultaneous, multi-point in-situ observations have long become the standard for exploring electromagnetic interactions in the inner solar system, they have never taken place at Jupiter or any strongly magnetized planet besides Earth. We conclude that a dedicated multi-spacecraft mission to Jupiter's radiation belts is an essential and obvious way forward and deserves to be given a high priority in ESA's Voyage 2050 programme.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Collisionless distribution functions for force-free current sheets: using a pressure transformation to lower the plasma beta
Authors:
Fiona Wilson,
Thomas Neukirch,
Oliver Allanson
Abstract:
So far, only one distribution function giving rise to a collisionless nonlinear force-free current sheet equilibrium allowing for a plasma beta less than one is known (Allanson et al., 2015; 2016). This distribution function can only be expressed as an infinite series of Hermite functions with very slow convergence and this makes its practical use cumbersome. It is the purpose of this paper to pre…
▽ More
So far, only one distribution function giving rise to a collisionless nonlinear force-free current sheet equilibrium allowing for a plasma beta less than one is known (Allanson et al., 2015; 2016). This distribution function can only be expressed as an infinite series of Hermite functions with very slow convergence and this makes its practical use cumbersome. It is the purpose of this paper to present a general method that allows us to find distribution functions consisting of a finite number of terms (therefore easier to use in practice), but which still allow for current sheet equilibria that can, in principle, have an arbitrarily low plasma beta. The method involves using known solutions and transforming them into new solutions using transformations based on taking integer powers ($N$) of one component of the pressure tensor. The plasma beta of the current sheet corresponding to the transformed distribution functions can then, in principle, have values as low as $1/N$. We present the general form of the distribution functions for arbitrary $N$ and then, as a specific example, discuss the case for $N=2$ in detail.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
The inverse problem for collisionless plasma equilibria
Authors:
O. Allanson,
S. Troscheit,
T. Neukirch
Abstract:
Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria are described by the self-consistent solutions of the time-independent Maxwell equations for the real-space dynamics of electromagnetic fields, and the Vlasov equation for the phase-space dynamics of particle distributions in a collisionless plasma. These two systems (macroscopic and microscopic) are coupled via the source terms in Maxwell's equations, which are sums of v…
▽ More
Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria are described by the self-consistent solutions of the time-independent Maxwell equations for the real-space dynamics of electromagnetic fields, and the Vlasov equation for the phase-space dynamics of particle distributions in a collisionless plasma. These two systems (macroscopic and microscopic) are coupled via the source terms in Maxwell's equations, which are sums of velocity-space 'moment' integrals of the particle distribution function. This paper considers 'the inverse problem for collisionless equilibria' (IPCE), viz. "given information regarding the real-space/macroscopic configuration of a specific collisionless plasma equilibrium, what self-consistent equilibrium distributions exist?" We develop the constants of motion approach to IPCE using the assumptions of a 'modified Maxwellian' distribution function, and a strictly neutral and spatially one-dimensional plasma. In such circumstances, IPCE formally reduces to the inversion of Weierstrass transformations (Bilodeau, 1962), such as those transformations that feature in the initial value problem for the heat/diffusion equation. We discuss the various mathematical conditions that a candidate solution of IPCE must satisfy. One method that can be used to invert the Weierstrass transform is expansions in Hermite polynomials. Building on the results of Allanson et al. (2016), we establish under what circumstances a solution obtained by these means converges, and allows velocity moments of all orders. Ever since the seminal work by Bernstein et al. (1957), on 'stationary' electrostatic plasma waves, the necessary quality of non-negativity has been noted as a feature that any candidate solution of IPCE will not $\textit{a priori}$ satisfy. We also discuss this problem in the context of for our formalism, for magnetised plasmas.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Theory of one-dimensional Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria: with applications to collisionless current sheets and flux tubes
Authors:
Oliver Allanson
Abstract:
We study the theory of Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria in one spatial dimension, as well as its application to current sheet and flux tube models. The 'inverse problem' is that of determining a Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium distribution function self-consistent with a given magnetic field. We develop the theory of inversion using expansions in Hermite polynomials of the canonical momenta. Sufficient condit…
▽ More
We study the theory of Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria in one spatial dimension, as well as its application to current sheet and flux tube models. The 'inverse problem' is that of determining a Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium distribution function self-consistent with a given magnetic field. We develop the theory of inversion using expansions in Hermite polynomials of the canonical momenta. Sufficient conditions for the convergence of a Hermite expansion are found, given a pressure tensor. For large classes of DFs, we prove that non-negativity of the distribution function is contingent on the magnetisation of the plasma, and make conjectures for all classes.
The inverse problem is considered for nonlinear 'force-free Harris sheets'. By applying the Hermite method, we construct new models that can describe sub-unity values of the plasma beta $(β_{pl})$ for the first time. Whilst analytical convergence is proven for all $β_{pl}$, numerical convergence is attained for $β_{pl}= 0.85$, and then $β_{pl} = 0.05$ after a 're-gauging' process.
We consider the properties that a pressure tensor must satisfy to be consistent with 'asymmetric Harris sheets', and construct new examples. It is possible to analytically solve the inverse problem in some cases, others must be tackled numerically. We present new exact Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria for asymmetric current sheets, which can be written as a sum of shifted Maxwellian distributions, ideal for implementations in particle-in-cell simulations.
We study the correspondence between the microscopic and macroscopic descriptions of equilibrium in cylindrical geometry, and then attempt to find Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria for the nonlinear force-free 'Gold-Hoyle' model. However, it is necessary to include a background field, which can be arbitrarily weak if desired. The equilibrium can be electrically non-neutral, depending on the bulk flows.
△ Less
Submitted 3 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Exact Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria for asymmetric current sheets
Authors:
O. Allanson,
F. Wilson,
T. Neukirch,
Y. -H. Liu,
J. D. B. Hodgson
Abstract:
The NASA Magnetospheric Multiscale mission has made in situ diffusion region and kinetic-scale resolution measurements of asymmetric magnetic reconnection for the first time, in the Earth's magnetopause. The principal theoretical tool currently used to model collisionless asymmetric reconnection is particle-in-cell simulations. Many particle-in-cell simulations of asymmetric collisionless reconnec…
▽ More
The NASA Magnetospheric Multiscale mission has made in situ diffusion region and kinetic-scale resolution measurements of asymmetric magnetic reconnection for the first time, in the Earth's magnetopause. The principal theoretical tool currently used to model collisionless asymmetric reconnection is particle-in-cell simulations. Many particle-in-cell simulations of asymmetric collisionless reconnection start from an asymmetric Harris-type magnetic field but with distribution functions that are not exact equilibrium solutions of the Vlasov equation. We present new and exact equilibrium solutions of the Vlasov-Maxwell system that are self-consistent with one-dimensional asymmetric current sheets, with an asymmetric Harris-type magnetic field profile, plus a constant nonzero guide field. The distribution functions can be represented as a combination of four shifted Maxwellian distribution functions. This equilibrium describes a magnetic field configuration with more freedom than the previously known exact solution and has different bulk flow properties.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Force-free collisionless current sheet models with non-uniform temperature and density profiles
Authors:
F. Wilson,
T. Neukirch,
O. Allanson
Abstract:
We present a class of one-dimensional, strictly neutral, Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium distribution functions for force-free current sheets, with magnetic fields defined in terms of Jacobian elliptic functions, extending the results of Abraham-Shrauner (Phys. Plasmas 20, 102117, 2013) to allow for non-uniform density and temperature profiles. To achieve this, we use an approach previously applied to…
▽ More
We present a class of one-dimensional, strictly neutral, Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium distribution functions for force-free current sheets, with magnetic fields defined in terms of Jacobian elliptic functions, extending the results of Abraham-Shrauner (Phys. Plasmas 20, 102117, 2013) to allow for non-uniform density and temperature profiles. To achieve this, we use an approach previously applied to the force-free Harris sheet by Kolotkov et al. (Phys. Plasmas 22, 112902, 2015). In one limit of the parameters, we recover the model of Kolotkov et al., while another limit gives a linear force-free field. We discuss conditions on the parameters such that the distribution functions are always positive, and give expressions for the pressure, density, temperature and bulk-flow velocities of the equilibrium, discussing differences from previous models. We also present some illustrative plots of the distribution function in velocity space.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Neutral and non-neutral collisionless plasma equilibria for twisted flux tubes: The Gold-Hoyle model in a background field
Authors:
O. Allanson,
F. Wilson,
T. Neukirch
Abstract:
We calculate exact one-dimensional collisionless plasma equilibria for a continuum of flux tube models, for which the total magnetic field is made up of the `force-free' Gold-Hoyle magnetic flux tube embedded in a uniform and anti-parallel background magnetic field. For a sufficiently weak background magnetic field, the axial component of the total magnetic field reverses at some finite radius. Th…
▽ More
We calculate exact one-dimensional collisionless plasma equilibria for a continuum of flux tube models, for which the total magnetic field is made up of the `force-free' Gold-Hoyle magnetic flux tube embedded in a uniform and anti-parallel background magnetic field. For a sufficiently weak background magnetic field, the axial component of the total magnetic field reverses at some finite radius. The presence of the background magnetic field means that the total system is not exactly force-free, but by reducing its magnitude the departure from force-free can be made as small as desired. The distribution function for each species is a function of the three constants of motion; namely the Hamiltonian and the canonical momenta in the axial and azimuthal directions. Poisson's Equation and Ampère's Law are solved exactly, and the solution allows either electrically neutral or non-neutral configurations, depending on the values of the bulk ion and electron flows. These equilibria have possible applications in various solar, space and astrophysical contexts, as well as in the laboratory.
△ Less
Submitted 20 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
From one-dimensional fields to Vlasov equilibria: Theory and application of Hermite polynomials
Authors:
O. Allanson,
T. Neukirch,
S. Troscheit,
F. Wilson
Abstract:
We consider the theory and application of a solution method for the inverse problem in collisionless equilibria, namely that of calculating a Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium for a given macroscopic (fluid) equilibrium. Using Jeans' Theorem, the equilibrium distribution functions are expressed as functions of the constants of motion, in the form of a Maxwellian multiplied by an unknown function of the c…
▽ More
We consider the theory and application of a solution method for the inverse problem in collisionless equilibria, namely that of calculating a Vlasov-Maxwell equilibrium for a given macroscopic (fluid) equilibrium. Using Jeans' Theorem, the equilibrium distribution functions are expressed as functions of the constants of motion, in the form of a Maxwellian multiplied by an unknown function of the canonical momenta. In this case it is possible to reduce the inverse problem to inverting Weierstrass transforms, which we achieve by using expansions over Hermite polynomials. A sufficient condition on the pressure tensor is found which guarantees the convergence and the boundedness of the candidate solution, when satisfied. This condition is obtained by elementary means, and it is clear how to put it into practice. We also argue that for a given pressure tensor for which our method applies, there always exists a positive distribution function solution for a sufficiently magnetised plasma. Illustrative examples of the use of this method with both force-free and non-force-free macroscopic equilibria are presented, including the full verification of a recently derived distribution function for the force-free Harris Sheet (Allanson $\textit{et al., Phys. Plasmas}$, vol. 22 (10), 2015, 102116). In the effort to model equilibria with lower values of the plasma beta, solutions for the same macroscopic equilibrium in a new gauge are calculated, with numerical results presented for $β_{pl}=0.05$.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2016; v1 submitted 6 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
An exact collisionless equilibrium for the Force-Free Harris Sheet with low plasma beta
Authors:
O. Allanson,
T. Neukirch,
F. Wilson,
S. Troscheit
Abstract:
We present a first discussion and analysis of the physical properties of a new exact collisionless equilibrium for a one-dimensional nonlinear force-free magnetic field, namely the Force-Free Harris Sheet. The solution allows any value of the plasma beta, and crucially below unity, which previous nonlinear force-free collisionless equilibria could not. The distribution function involves infinite s…
▽ More
We present a first discussion and analysis of the physical properties of a new exact collisionless equilibrium for a one-dimensional nonlinear force-free magnetic field, namely the Force-Free Harris Sheet. The solution allows any value of the plasma beta, and crucially below unity, which previous nonlinear force-free collisionless equilibria could not. The distribution function involves infinite series of Hermite Polynomials in the canonical momenta, of which the important mathematical properties of convergence and non-negativity have recently been proven. Plots of the distribution function are presented for the plasma beta modestly below unity, and we compare the shape of the distribution function in two of the velocity directions to a Maxwellian distribution.
△ Less
Submitted 26 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Particular solutions of the inverse problem for 1D Vlasov-Maxwell equilibria using Hermite polynomials
Authors:
O. Allanson,
T. Neukirch,
S. Troscheit,
F. Wilson
Abstract:
We present the solution to an inverse problem arising in the context of finding a distribution function for a specific collisionless plasma equilibrium. The inverse problem involves the solution of two integral equations, each having the form of a Weierstrass transform. We prove that inverting the Weierstrass transform using Hermite polynomials leads to convergent infinite series. We also comment…
▽ More
We present the solution to an inverse problem arising in the context of finding a distribution function for a specific collisionless plasma equilibrium. The inverse problem involves the solution of two integral equations, each having the form of a Weierstrass transform. We prove that inverting the Weierstrass transform using Hermite polynomials leads to convergent infinite series. We also comment on the non-negativity of the distribution function, with more detail on this in Allanson $\textit{et al., Journal of Plasma Physics}$, vol. 82 (03), 2016. Whilst applied to a specific magnetic field, the inversion techniques used in this paper (as well as the derived convergence criteria and discussion of non-negativity) are of a general nature, and are applicable to other smooth pressure functions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2016; v1 submitted 31 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Optical angular momentum in dispersive media
Authors:
T. G. Philbin,
O. Allanson
Abstract:
The angular momentum density and flux of light in a dispersive, rotationally symmetric medium are derived from Noether's theorem. Optical angular momentum in a dispersive medium has no simple relation to optical linear momentum, even if the medium is homogeneous. A circularly polarized monochromatic beam in a homogeneous, dispersive medium carries a spin angular momentum of $\pm\hbar$ per energy…
▽ More
The angular momentum density and flux of light in a dispersive, rotationally symmetric medium are derived from Noether's theorem. Optical angular momentum in a dispersive medium has no simple relation to optical linear momentum, even if the medium is homogeneous. A circularly polarized monochromatic beam in a homogeneous, dispersive medium carries a spin angular momentum of $\pm\hbar$ per energy $\hbarω$, as in vacuum. This result demonstrates the non-trivial interplay of dispersive contributions to optical angular momentum and energy.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2012; v1 submitted 22 May, 2012;
originally announced May 2012.
