-
The Numerical Solution in the Sense of Prager&Synge
Authors:
A. K. Alekseev,
A. E. Bondarev
Abstract:
The solution in sense of Prager&Synge is the alternative to the commonly used notion of the numerical solution, which is considered as a limit of grid functions at mesh refinement. Prager&Synge solution is defined as a hypersphere containing the projection of the true solution of the system of partial differentiation equations (PDE) onto the computational grid and does not use any asymptotics. In…
▽ More
The solution in sense of Prager&Synge is the alternative to the commonly used notion of the numerical solution, which is considered as a limit of grid functions at mesh refinement. Prager&Synge solution is defined as a hypersphere containing the projection of the true solution of the system of partial differentiation equations (PDE) onto the computational grid and does not use any asymptotics. In the original variant it is determined using orthogonal properties specific for certain equations. In the proposed variant, the center and radius of the hypersphere is estimated using the ensemble of numerical solutions obtained by independent algorithms. This approach may be easily expanded for solutions of an arbitrary system of partial differentiation equations that significantly expands the domain of its applicability. Several options for the computation of the Prager&Synge solution are considered and compared herein. The first one is based on the search for the orthogonal truncation errors and their transformation. The second is based on the orthogonalization of approximation errors obtained using the defect correction method and applies a superposition of numerical solutions. These options are intrusive. In third option (nonintrusive) the information regarding orthogonality of errors, which is crucial for the Prager&Synge approach method, is replaced by information that stems from the properties of the ensemble of numerical solutions, obtained by independent numerical algorithms. The values of the angle between the truncation errors on such ensemble or the distances between elements of the ensemble may be used to replace the orthogonality. The variant based on the width of the ensemble of independent numerical solutions does not require any additional a priori information and is the approximate nonintrusive version of the method based on the orthogonalization of approximation errors.
△ Less
Submitted 10 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Status of the Yakutsk air shower array and future plans
Authors:
A. K. Alekseev,
E. A. Atlasov,
N. G. Bolotnikov,
A. V. Bosikov,
N. A. Dyachkovskiy,
N. S. Gerasimova,
A. V. Glushkov,
A. A. Ivanov,
O. N. Ivanov,
D. N. Kardashevsky,
I. A. Kellarev,
S. P. Knurenko,
A. D. Krasilnikov,
A. N. Krivenkov,
I. V. Ksenofontov,
L. T. Ksenofontov,
K. G. Lebedev,
S. V. Matarkin,
V. P. Mokhnachevskaya,
E. V. Nikolaeva,
N. I. Neustroev,
I. S. Petrov,
N. D. Platonov,
A. S. Proshutinsky,
A. V. Sabourov
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Yakutsk Extensive Air Shower Array has been continuously operating for more than 50 years (since 1970) and up until recently it has been one of world's largest ground-based instruments aimed at studying the properties of cosmic rays in the ultra-high energy domain. In this report we discuss results recently obtained at the array - on cosmic rays energy spectrum, mass composition and directiona…
▽ More
The Yakutsk Extensive Air Shower Array has been continuously operating for more than 50 years (since 1970) and up until recently it has been one of world's largest ground-based instruments aimed at studying the properties of cosmic rays in the ultra-high energy domain. In this report we discuss results recently obtained at the array - on cosmic rays energy spectrum, mass composition and directional anisotropy - and how they fit into the world data. Special attention is paid to the measurements of muonic component of extensive air showers. Theoretical results of particle acceleration at shocks are also briefly reviewed. Future scientific and engineering plans on the array modernization are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 15 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
On the relation of truncation and approximation errors for the set of solutions obtained by different numerical methods
Authors:
A. K. Alekseev,
A. E. Bondarev
Abstract:
The truncation and approximation errors for the set of numerical solutions computed by methods based on the algorithms of different structure are calculated and analyzed for the case of the two-dimensional steady inviscid compressible flow. The truncation errors are calculated using a special postprocessor, while the approximation errors are obtained by the comparison of the numerical solution and…
▽ More
The truncation and approximation errors for the set of numerical solutions computed by methods based on the algorithms of different structure are calculated and analyzed for the case of the two-dimensional steady inviscid compressible flow. The truncation errors are calculated using a special postprocessor, while the approximation errors are obtained by the comparison of the numerical solution and the analytic one. The extent of the independence of errors for the numerical solutions may be estimated via the Pearson correlation coefficient that may be geometrically expressed by the angle between errors. Due to this reason, the angles between the approximation errors are computed and related with the corresponding angles between the truncation errors. The angles between the approximation errors are found to be far from zero that enables a posteriori estimation of the error norm. The analysis of the distances between these solutions provides another approach to the estimation of the error. The comparison of the error norms, obtained by these two procedures, is provided that demonstrates the acceptable values of their effectivity indices. The results of the approximation error norm estimation for the supersonic flows, containing shock waves, are presented. The measure concentration phenomenon and the algorithmic randomness give some insights into these results.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
On Triangle Inequality Based Approximation Error Estimation
Authors:
A. K. Alekseev,
A. E. Bondarev,
I. M. Navon
Abstract:
The distance between the true and numerical solutions in some metric is considered as the discretization error magnitude. If error magnitude ranging is known, the triangle inequality enables the estimation of the vicinity of the approximate solution that contains the exact one (exact solution enclosure). The analysis of distances between the numerical solutions enables discretization error ranging…
▽ More
The distance between the true and numerical solutions in some metric is considered as the discretization error magnitude. If error magnitude ranging is known, the triangle inequality enables the estimation of the vicinity of the approximate solution that contains the exact one (exact solution enclosure). The analysis of distances between the numerical solutions enables discretization error ranging, if solutions errors are significantly different. Numerical tests conducted using the steady supersonic flows, governed by the two dimensional Euler equations, demonstrate the properties of the exact solution enclosure. The set of solutions generated by solvers of different orders of approximation is used. The success of this approach depends on the choice of metric.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2018; v1 submitted 15 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
On Estimation of Discretization Error Norm via Ensemble of Approximate Solutions
Authors:
A. K. Alekseev,
A. E. Bondarev,
I. M. Navon
Abstract:
The issue of single-grid discretization error estimator, operating in the postprocessor mode, is addressed in the paper. An ensemble of numerical solutions, obtained using solvers of different accuracy, is shown to provide an upper estimate for the norm of the discretization error. Numerical tests for the supersonic flows, governed by two dimensional Euler equations, confirm the feasibility for th…
▽ More
The issue of single-grid discretization error estimator, operating in the postprocessor mode, is addressed in the paper. An ensemble of numerical solutions, obtained using solvers of different accuracy, is shown to provide an upper estimate for the norm of the discretization error. Numerical tests for the supersonic flows, governed by two dimensional Euler equations, confirm the feasibility for the norm estimation, if the ensemble of numerical solutions is separated into clusters of accurate and inaccurate solutions.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2018; v1 submitted 17 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
