-
Upper bound of heat flux in an anelastic model for Rayleigh-Bénard convection
Authors:
T. Alboussière,
Y. Ricard,
S. Labrosse
Abstract:
Bounds on heat transfer have been the subject of previous studies concerning convection in the Boussinesq approximation: in the Rayleigh-Bénard configuration, the first result obtained by \cite{howard63} states that $Nu < (3/64 \ Ra)^{1/2}$ for large values of the Rayleigh number $Ra$, independently of the Prandtl number $Pr$. This is still the best known upper bound, only with the prefactor impro…
▽ More
Bounds on heat transfer have been the subject of previous studies concerning convection in the Boussinesq approximation: in the Rayleigh-Bénard configuration, the first result obtained by \cite{howard63} states that $Nu < (3/64 \ Ra)^{1/2}$ for large values of the Rayleigh number $Ra$, independently of the Prandtl number $Pr$. This is still the best known upper bound, only with the prefactor improved to $Nu < 1/6 \ Ra^{1/2}$ by \cite{DoeringConstantin96}. In the present paper, this result is extended to compressible convection. An upper bound is obtained for the anelastic liquid approximation, which is similar to the anelastic model used in astrophysics based on a turbulent diffusivity for entropy. The anelastic bound is still scaling as $Ra^{1/2}$, independently of $Pr$, but depends on the dissipation number $\mathcal{D}$ and on the equation of state. For monatomic gases and large Rayleigh numbers, the bound is $Nu < 146\, Ra^{\frac{1}{2}} / (2-\mathcal{D} )^{\frac{5}{2}}$.
△ Less
Submitted 7 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Remarks on compressible convection in Super-Earths
Authors:
Yanick Ricard,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
The radial density of planets increases with depth due to compressibility, leading to impacts on their convective dynamics. To account for these effects, including the presence of a quasi-adiabatic temperature profile and entropy sources due to dissipation, the compressibility is expressed through a dissipation number, $\mathcal{D}$, proportional to the planet's radius and gravity. In Earth's mant…
▽ More
The radial density of planets increases with depth due to compressibility, leading to impacts on their convective dynamics. To account for these effects, including the presence of a quasi-adiabatic temperature profile and entropy sources due to dissipation, the compressibility is expressed through a dissipation number, $\mathcal{D}$, proportional to the planet's radius and gravity. In Earth's mantle, compressibility effects are moderate, but in large rocky or liquid exoplanets (Super-Earths), the dissipation number can become very large. This paper explores the properties of compressible convection when the dissipation number is significant. We start by selecting a simple Murnaghan equation of state that embodies the fundamental properties of condensed matter at planetary conditions. Next, we analyze the characteristics of adiabatic profiles and demonstrate that the ratio between the bottom and top adiabatic temperatures is relatively small and probably less than 2. We examine the marginal stability of compressible mantles and reveal that they can undergo convection with either positive or negative superadiabatic Rayleigh numbers. Lastly, we delve into simulations of convection performed using the exact equations of mechanics, neglecting inertia (infinite Prandtl number case), and examine their consequences for Super-Earths dynamics.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
A playground for compressible natural convection with a nearly uniform density
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere,
Jezabel Curbelo,
Fabien Dubuffet,
Stephane Labrosse,
Yanick Ricard
Abstract:
In the quest to understand the basic universal features of compressible convection, one would like to disentangle genuine consequences of compression from spatial variations of transport properties. In the present work, we consider a very peculiar equation of state, whereby entropy is solely dependent on density, so that a nearly isentropic fluid domain is nearly isochoric. Within this class of eq…
▽ More
In the quest to understand the basic universal features of compressible convection, one would like to disentangle genuine consequences of compression from spatial variations of transport properties. In the present work, we consider a very peculiar equation of state, whereby entropy is solely dependent on density, so that a nearly isentropic fluid domain is nearly isochoric. Within this class of equations of state, there is a thermal adiabatic gradient and a key property of compressible convection is still present, namely its capacity to viscously dissipate a large fraction of the thermal energy involved, of the order of the well-named dissipation number. In a series of anelastic approximations, under the assumption of an infinite Prandtl number, the number of governing parameters can be brought down to two, the Rayleigh number and the dissipation number. This framework is proposed as a playground for compressible convection, an opportunity to extend the vast corpus of theoretical analyses on the Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations regarding stability, bifurcations or the determination of upper bounds for the turbulent heat transfer. Here, in a two-dimensional geometry, we concentrate on the structure of upward and downward plumes depending on the dissipation number, on the heat flux dependence on the dissipation number and on the ratio of dissipation to convective heat flux. For dissipation numbers of order unity, in the limit of large Rayleigh numbers, dissipation becomes related to the entropy heat flux at each depth, so that the vertical dissipation profile can be predicted, and consequently so does the total ratio of dissipation to convective heat flux.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Fast and Furious dynamo action in the anisotropic dynamo
Authors:
Franck Plunian,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
In the limit of large magnetic Reynolds numbers, it is shown that a smooth differential rotation can lead to fast dynamo action, provided that the electrical conductivity or magnetic permeability is anisotropic. If the shear is infinite, for example between two rotating solid bodies, the anisotropic dynamo becomes furious, meaning that the magnetic growth rate increases toward infinity with an inc…
▽ More
In the limit of large magnetic Reynolds numbers, it is shown that a smooth differential rotation can lead to fast dynamo action, provided that the electrical conductivity or magnetic permeability is anisotropic. If the shear is infinite, for example between two rotating solid bodies, the anisotropic dynamo becomes furious, meaning that the magnetic growth rate increases toward infinity with an increasing magnetic Reynolds number.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Fury: an experimental dynamo with anisotropic electrical conductivity
Authors:
Thierry Alboussière,
Franck Plunian,
Marc Moulin
Abstract:
We report measurements of dynamo action in a new experimental setup, named Fury, based on the use of an anisotropic electrical conductivity. It consists in a copper rotor rotating inside a copper stator, electrically connected with a thin layer of liquid metal, galinstan. Grooves have been cut in the copper so that, everywhere, electrical conductivity can be considered to be that of copper along t…
▽ More
We report measurements of dynamo action in a new experimental setup, named Fury, based on the use of an anisotropic electrical conductivity. It consists in a copper rotor rotating inside a copper stator, electrically connected with a thin layer of liquid metal, galinstan. Grooves have been cut in the copper so that, everywhere, electrical conductivity can be considered to be that of copper along two directions while it is zero along the third one. The configuration is efficient and dynamo action can be powered by hand. We have also used a motor with better control, enabling us to drive the rotor at specified velocity or torque functions of time. The structure of the axisymmetric magnetic field produced is found to be close to the numerical modelling using FreeFem++. The experimental dynamo behaves very nearly as expected for a kinematic dynamo, so that the threshold dynamo velocity cannot be exceeded, or only briefly. More mechanical power in the rotor rotation leads to an increase in the magnetic field intensity, the magnetic energy being proportional to the extra mechanical power beyond threshold. In the transient following a step increase of torque, magnetic and angular velocity oscillations have been observed and explained.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2022; v1 submitted 31 May, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Axisymmetric dynamo action produced by differential rotation, with anisotropic electrical conductivity and anisotropic magnetic permeability
Authors:
Franck Plunian,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
The effect on dynamo action of an anisotropic electrical conductivity conjugated to an anisotropic magnetic permeability is considered. Not only is the dynamo fully axisymmetric, but it requires only a simple differential rotation, which twice challenges the well-established dynamo theory. Stability analysis is conducted entirely analytically, leading to an explicit expression of the dynamo thresh…
▽ More
The effect on dynamo action of an anisotropic electrical conductivity conjugated to an anisotropic magnetic permeability is considered. Not only is the dynamo fully axisymmetric, but it requires only a simple differential rotation, which twice challenges the well-established dynamo theory. Stability analysis is conducted entirely analytically, leading to an explicit expression of the dynamo threshold. The results show a competition between the anisotropy of electrical conductivity and that of magnetic permeability, the dynamo effect becoming impossible if the two anisotropies are identical. For isotropic electrical conductivity, Cowling's neutral point argument does imply the absence of an azimuthal component of current density, but does not prevent the dynamo effect as long as the magnetic permeability is anisotropic.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Rayleigh-Taylor instability during impact cratering experiments
Authors:
V. Lherm,
R. Deguen,
T. Alboussière,
M. Landeau
Abstract:
When a liquid drop strikes a deep pool of a second liquid, an impact crater opens while the liquid of the drop decelerates and spreads on the surface of the crater. If the density of the drop is larger than the surrounding, the interface between the drop liquid layer and its surrounding becomes unstable, producing mushroom-shaped plumes growing radially outward. We interpret this instability as a…
▽ More
When a liquid drop strikes a deep pool of a second liquid, an impact crater opens while the liquid of the drop decelerates and spreads on the surface of the crater. If the density of the drop is larger than the surrounding, the interface between the drop liquid layer and its surrounding becomes unstable, producing mushroom-shaped plumes growing radially outward. We interpret this instability as a spherical Rayleigh-Taylor instability associated with the deceleration of the interface between the drop and its surrounding, which significantly exceeds the ambient vertical gravity. We investigate experimentally how changing the density contrast and the impact Froude number affects the instability and the resulting mixing layer. Using backlighting and planar laser-induced fluorescence methods, the position of the air-liquid interface, the thickness of the mixing layer, and an estimate of the instability wavelength are obtained. First, the evolution of the mean crater radius is derived from an energy conservation model. The observed mixing layer dynamics is then explained by a model involving a competition between the geometrical expansion of the crater tending to decrease its thickness, and mixing produced by the Rayleigh-Taylor instability tending to increase its thickness. The estimated instability wavelength is finally compared to an approximate linear stability analysis of a radially accelerated fluid sphere into a less dense fluid. Mixing properties of this impact-related instability have geophysical implications regarding the differentiation of terrestrial planets, in particular by estimating the mass of magma ocean silicates that equilibrates with the metal core of the impacting planetesimals.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Small scales and anisotropy in low $Rm$ magnetohydrodynamic turbulence
Authors:
Alban Pothérat,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
In this paper, we derive estimates for size of the small scales and the attractor dimension in low $Rm$ magnetohydrodynamic turbulence by deriving a rigorous upper bound of the dimension of the attractor representing this flow. To this end, we find an upper bound for the maximum growth rate of any $n$-dimensional volume of the phase space by the evolution operator associated to the Navier-Stokes e…
▽ More
In this paper, we derive estimates for size of the small scales and the attractor dimension in low $Rm$ magnetohydrodynamic turbulence by deriving a rigorous upper bound of the dimension of the attractor representing this flow. To this end, we find an upper bound for the maximum growth rate of any $n$-dimensional volume of the phase space by the evolution operator associated to the Navier-Stokes equations. As explained by Constantin et al. (J. Fluid Mech., 1985), The value of $n$ for which this maximum is zero is an upper bound for the attractor dimension. In order to use this property in the more precise case of a 3D periodical domain, we are led to calculate the distribution of $n$ modes which minimises the total (viscous and Joule) dissipation. This set of modes turns out to exhibit most of the well known properties of MHD turbulence, previously obtained by heuristic considerations such as the existence of the Joule cone under strong magnetic field. The sought estimates for the small scales and attractor dimension are then obtained under no physical assumption as functions of the Hartmann and the Reynolds numbers and match the Hartmann number dependency of heuristic results. A necessary condition for the flow to be tridimensional and anisotropic (as opposed to purely two-dimensional) is also built.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Mathematical estimates for the attractor dimension in MHD turbulence
Authors:
Alban Pothérat,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
The aim of the present work is to derive rigorous estimates for turbulent MHD flow quantities such as the size and anisotropy of the dissipative scales, as well as the transition between 2D and 3D state. To this end, we calculate an upper bound for the attractor dimension of the motion equations, which indicates the number of modes present in the fully developed flow. This method has already been…
▽ More
The aim of the present work is to derive rigorous estimates for turbulent MHD flow quantities such as the size and anisotropy of the dissipative scales, as well as the transition between 2D and 3D state. To this end, we calculate an upper bound for the attractor dimension of the motion equations, which indicates the number of modes present in the fully developed flow. This method has already been used successfully to derive such estimates for 2D and 3D hydrodynamic turbulence as a function of the $\mathcal L_\infty$ norm of the dissipation, as in \cite{doering95}. We tackle here the problem of a flow periodic in the 3 spatial directions (spatial period $2πL$), to which a permanent magnetic field is applied. In addition, the detailed study of the dissipation operator provides more indications about the structure of the flow. In section 2, we review the tools of the dynamical system theory as well as the results they have led to in the case of 3D hydrodynamic turbulence. Section 3 is devoted to the study of the set of modes which minimises the trace of the operator associated to the total dissipation in MHD turbulence (viscous and Joule). Eventually, the estimates for the attractor dimension and dissipative scales in MHD turbulence under strong magnetic field are derived in section 4 and compared to results obtained from heuristic considerations.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Bounds on the attractor dimension for low-R m wall-bound magnetohydrodynamic turbulence
Authors:
Alban Pothérat,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
Steady Low $R_m$ MHD turbulence is investigated here through estimates of upper bounds for attractor dimension. A flow between two parallel walls with an imposed perpendicular magnetic field is considered. The flow is defined by its maximum velocity and the intensity of the magnetic field. Given the corresponding Reynolds and Hartmann numbers, we derive an upper bound for the dimension of the attr…
▽ More
Steady Low $R_m$ MHD turbulence is investigated here through estimates of upper bounds for attractor dimension. A flow between two parallel walls with an imposed perpendicular magnetic field is considered. The flow is defined by its maximum velocity and the intensity of the magnetic field. Given the corresponding Reynolds and Hartmann numbers, we derive an upper bound for the dimension of the attractor and find out which modes must be chosen to achieve this bound. Thier, are compared to heuristics estimates for the size of the smallest scales and anisotropy of the turbulence. We identify boundaries separating different sets of modes in the space of non-dimensional parameters, which are reminiscent of three important previously identified transitions observed in the real flow. The first boundary separates classical hydrodynamic sets of modes from MHD sets where anisotropy takes the form of a ``Joule cone''. The second boundary separates 3D MHD sets from quasi-2D MHD sets. The third separates sets where all the modes exhibit the same boundary layer thickness or so, and sets where many different ``boundary layer modes'' co-exists in the set. The non-dimensional relations defining these boundaries are then compared to the heuristics known for the transition between isotropic and anisotropic MHD turbulence, 3D and quasi-2D MHD turbulence and that between a turbulent and a laminar Hartmann layer. In addition to this 3D approach, we also determine upper bounds for the dimension of forced turbulent flows modelled using a 2D MHD equation, relevant in the quasi-2D MHD regime. The advantage of this 2D approach is that, while upper bounds are quite loose in three dimensions, optimal upper bounds exist for the 2D nonlinear term. This allows us to derive realistic attractor dimensions for quasi-2D MHD flows.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Dynamo action in sliding plates of anisotropic electrical conductivity
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere,
Kamel Drif,
Franck Plunian
Abstract:
With materials of anisotropic electrical conductivity, it is possible to generate a dynamo with a simple velocity field, of the type precluded by Cowling's theorems with isotropic materials. Following a previous study by Ruderman and Ruzmaikin [1] who considered the dynamo effect induced by a uniform shear flow, we determine the conditions for the dynamo threshold when a solid plate is sliding ove…
▽ More
With materials of anisotropic electrical conductivity, it is possible to generate a dynamo with a simple velocity field, of the type precluded by Cowling's theorems with isotropic materials. Following a previous study by Ruderman and Ruzmaikin [1] who considered the dynamo effect induced by a uniform shear flow, we determine the conditions for the dynamo threshold when a solid plate is sliding over another one, both with anisotropic electrical conductivity. We obtain numerical solutions for a general class of anisotropy and obtain the conditions for the lowest magnetic Reynolds number, using a collocation Chebyshev method. In a particular geometry of anisotropy and wavenumber, we also derive an analytical solution, where the eigenvectors are just combinations of four exponential functions. An explicit analytical expression is obtained for the critical magnetic Reynold number. Above the critical magnetic Reynold number, we have also derived an analytical expression for the growth rate showing that this is a 'very fast' dynamo, extrapolating on the 'slow' and 'fast' terminology introduced by Vainshtein and Zeldovich [2].
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Axisymmetric dynamo action is possible with anisotropic conductivity
Authors:
Franck Plunian,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
A milestone of dynamo theory is Cowling's theorem, known in its modern form as the impossibility for an axisymmetric velocity field to generate an axisymmetric magnetic field by dynamo action. Using an anisotropic electrical conductivity we show that an axisymmetric dynamo is in fact possible with a motion as simple as solid body rotation. On top of that the instability analysis can be conducted e…
▽ More
A milestone of dynamo theory is Cowling's theorem, known in its modern form as the impossibility for an axisymmetric velocity field to generate an axisymmetric magnetic field by dynamo action. Using an anisotropic electrical conductivity we show that an axisymmetric dynamo is in fact possible with a motion as simple as solid body rotation. On top of that the instability analysis can be conducted entirely analytically, leading to an explicit expression of the dynamo threshold which is the only example in dynamo theory.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Experimental study of convection in the compressible regime
Authors:
Rémi Menaut,
Yoann Corre,
Ludovic Huguet,
Thomas Le Reun,
Thierry Alboussière,
Michael Bergman,
Renaud Deguen,
Stéphane Labrosse,
Marc Moulin
Abstract:
An experiment of thermal convection with significant compressible effects is presented. The high-gravity environment of a centrifuge and the choice of xenon gas enable us to observe an average adiabatic temperature gradient up to 3.5 K cm$^{-1}$ over a 4 cm high cavity. At the highest rotation rate investigated, 9990 rpm, the superadiabatic temperature difference applied to the gas layer is less t…
▽ More
An experiment of thermal convection with significant compressible effects is presented. The high-gravity environment of a centrifuge and the choice of xenon gas enable us to observe an average adiabatic temperature gradient up to 3.5 K cm$^{-1}$ over a 4 cm high cavity. At the highest rotation rate investigated, 9990 rpm, the superadiabatic temperature difference applied to the gas layer is less than the adiabatic temperature difference. The convective regime is characterized by a large Rayleigh number, about 10$^{12}$, and dominant Coriolis forces (Ekman number of order 10$^{-6}$). The analysis of temperature and pressure fluctuations in our experiments shows that the dynamics of the flow is in a quasi-geostrophic regime. Still, a classical power law (exponent 0.3 $\pm$ 0.04) is observed between the Nusselt number (dimensionless heat flux) and the superadiabatic Rayleigh number (dimensionless superadiabatic temperature difference). However, a potential hysteresis is seen between this classical high flux regime and a lower heat flux regime. It is unclear whether this is due to compressible or Coriolis effects. In the transient regime of convection from an isothermal state, we observe a local decrease of temperature which can only be explained by adiabatic decompression.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2019; v1 submitted 11 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Rayleigh-Bénard convection in a cree** solid with melting and freezing at either or both its horizontal boundaries
Authors:
Stéphane Labrosse,
Adrien Morison,
Renaud Deguen,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
Solid state convection can take place in the rocky or icy mantles of planetary objects and these mantles can be surrounded above or below or both by molten layers of similar composition. A flow toward the interface can proceed through it by changing phase. This behaviour is modeled by a boundary condition taking into account the competition between viscous stress in the solid, that builds topograp…
▽ More
Solid state convection can take place in the rocky or icy mantles of planetary objects and these mantles can be surrounded above or below or both by molten layers of similar composition. A flow toward the interface can proceed through it by changing phase. This behaviour is modeled by a boundary condition taking into account the competition between viscous stress in the solid, that builds topography of the interface with a timescale $τ_η$, and convective transfer of the latent heat in the liquid from places of the boundary where freezing occurs to places of melting, which acts to erase topography, with a timescale $τ_φ$. The ratio $Φ=τ_φ/τ_η$ controls whether the boundary condition is the classical non-penetrative one ($Φ\rightarrow \infty$) or allows for a finite flow through the boundary (small $Φ$). We study Rayleigh-Bénard convection in a plane layer subject to this boundary condition at either or both its boundaries using linear and weakly non-linear analyses. When both boundaries are phase change interfaces with equal values of $Φ$, a non-deforming translation mode is possible with a critical Rayleigh number equal to $24Φ$. At small values of $Φ$, this mode competes with a weakly deforming mode having a slightly lower critical Rayleigh number and a very long wavelength, $λ_c\sim 8\sqrt{2}π/ 3\sqrtΦ$. Both modes lead to very efficient heat transfer, as expressed by the relationship between the Nusselt and Rayleigh numbers. When only one boundary is subject to a phase change condition, the critical Rayleigh number is $\Ray_c=153$ and the critical wavelength is $λ_c=5$. The Nusselt number increases about twice faster with Rayleigh number than in the classical case with non-penetrative conditions when the bottom boundary is a phase change interface.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2018; v1 submitted 2 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Rayleigh-Benard stability and the validity of quasi-Boussinesq or quasi-anelastic liquid approximations
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere,
Yanick Ricard
Abstract:
The linear stability threshold of the Rayleigh-Benard configuration is analyzed with compressible effects taken into account. It is assumed that the fluid obeys a Newtonian rheology and Fourier's law of thermal transport with constant, uniform (dynamic) viscosity and thermal conductivity in a uniform gravity field. Top and bottom boundaries are maintained at different constant temperatures and we…
▽ More
The linear stability threshold of the Rayleigh-Benard configuration is analyzed with compressible effects taken into account. It is assumed that the fluid obeys a Newtonian rheology and Fourier's law of thermal transport with constant, uniform (dynamic) viscosity and thermal conductivity in a uniform gravity field. Top and bottom boundaries are maintained at different constant temperatures and we consider here boundary conditions of zero tangential stress and impermeable walls. Under these conditions, and with the Boussinesq approximation, Rayleigh (1916) first obtained analytically the critical value 27pi^4/4 for a dimensionless parameter, now known as the Rayleigh number, at the onset of convection. This manuscript describes the changes of the critical Rayleigh number due to the compressibility of the fluid, measured by the dimensionless dissipation parameter D and due to a finite temperature difference between the hot and cold boundaries, measured by a dimensionless temperature gradient a. Different equations of state are examined: ideal gas equation, Murnaghan's model and a generic equation of state, which can represent any possible equation of state. We also consider two variations of this stability analysis. In a so-called quasi-Boussinesq model, we consider that density perturbations are solely due to temperature perturbations. In a so-called quasi-anelastic liquid approximation, we consider that entropy perturbations are solely due to temperature perturbations. In addition to the numerical Chebyshev-based stability analysis, an analytical approximation is obtained when temperature fluctuations are written as a combination of only two modes. This analytical expression allows us to show that the superadiabatic critical Rayleigh number quadratic departure in a and D from 27pi^4/4 involves the expansion of density up to the degree three in terms of pressure and temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 7 July, 2016;
originally announced July 2016.
-
Thermal convection in Earth's inner core with phase change at its boundary
Authors:
Renaud Deguen,
Thierry Alboussière,
Philippe Cardin
Abstract:
Inner core translation, with solidification on one hemisphere and melting on the other, provides a promising basis for understanding the hemispherical dichotomy of the inner core, as well as the anomalous stable layer observed at the base of the outer core - the F-layer - which might be sustained by continuous melting of inner core material. In this paper, we study in details the dynamics of inner…
▽ More
Inner core translation, with solidification on one hemisphere and melting on the other, provides a promising basis for understanding the hemispherical dichotomy of the inner core, as well as the anomalous stable layer observed at the base of the outer core - the F-layer - which might be sustained by continuous melting of inner core material. In this paper, we study in details the dynamics of inner core thermal convection when dynamically induced melting and freezing of the inner core boundary (ICB) are taken into account. If the inner core is unstably stratified, linear stability analysis and numerical simulations consistently show that the translation mode dominates only if the viscosity $η$ is large enough, with a critical viscosity value, of order $3 10^{18}$ Pas, depending on the ability of outer core convection to supply or remove the latent heat of melting or solidification. If $η$ is smaller, the dynamical effect of melting and freezing is small. Convection takes a more classical form, with a one-cell axisymmetric mode at the onset and chaotic plume convection at large Rayleigh number. [...] Thermal convection requires that a superadiabatic temperature profile is maintained in the inner core, which depends on a competition between extraction of the inner core internal heat by conduction and cooling at the ICB. Inner core thermal convection appears very likely with the low thermal conductivity value proposed by Stacey & Davis (2007), but nearly impossible with the much higher thermal conductivity recently put forward. We argue however that the formation of an iron-rich layer above the ICB may have a positive feedback on inner core convection: it implies that the inner core crystallized from an increasingly iron-rich liquid, resulting in an unstable compositional stratification which could drive inner core convection, perhaps even if the inner core is subadiabatic.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Reflections on dissipation associated with thermal convection
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere,
Yanick Ricard
Abstract:
This paper was originally published in June 2013 in JFM (vol. 725). There was one result concerning an expression of viscous dissipation in convective flows and a second result on the condition of applicability of the anelastic liquid equation ($γ- 1 \ll 1$). We then found that this second result was wrong and the explanation why this is so was published as a corrigendum in July 2014 in JFM (vol.…
▽ More
This paper was originally published in June 2013 in JFM (vol. 725). There was one result concerning an expression of viscous dissipation in convective flows and a second result on the condition of applicability of the anelastic liquid equation ($γ- 1 \ll 1$). We then found that this second result was wrong and the explanation why this is so was published as a corrigendum in July 2014 in JFM (vol. 751). In a few words, the origin of the error is that we have derived an expression for dissipation in the framework of the exact equations and subsequently used it in the framework of the anelastic models. Here we have included the original article, followed by its corrigendum.
△ Less
Submitted 4 November, 2019; v1 submitted 19 October, 2012;
originally announced October 2012.
-
Melting-induced stratification above the Earth's inner core due to convective translation
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere,
Renaud Deguen,
Mickael Melzani
Abstract:
In addition to its global North-South anisotropy(1), there are two other enigmatic seismological observations related to the Earth's inner core: asymmetry between its eastern and western hemispheres(2-6) and the presence of a layer of reduced seismic velocity at the base of the outer core(6-12). This 250-km-thick layer has been interpreted as a stably stratified region of reduced composition in li…
▽ More
In addition to its global North-South anisotropy(1), there are two other enigmatic seismological observations related to the Earth's inner core: asymmetry between its eastern and western hemispheres(2-6) and the presence of a layer of reduced seismic velocity at the base of the outer core(6-12). This 250-km-thick layer has been interpreted as a stably stratified region of reduced composition in light elements(13). Here we show that this layer can be generated by simultaneous crystallization and melting at the surface of the inner core, and that a translational mode of thermal convection in the inner core can produce enough melting and crystallization on each hemisphere respectively for the dense layer to develop. The dynamical model we propose introduces a clear asymmetry between a melting and a crystallizing hemisphere which forms a basis for also explaining the East-West asymmetry. The present translation rate is found to be typically 100 million years for the inner core to be entirely renewed, which is one to two orders of magnitude faster than the growth rate of the inner core's radius. The resulting strong asymmetry of buoyancy flux caused by light elements is anticipated to have an impact on the dynamics of the outer core and on the geodynamo.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2012;
originally announced January 2012.
-
Experimental evidence of Alfvén wave propagation in a Gallium alloy
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere,
Philippe Cardin,
François Debray,
Patrick La Rizza,
Jean-Paul Masson,
Franck Plunian,
Adolfo Ribeiro,
Denys Schmitt
Abstract:
Experiments with a liquid metal alloy, galinstan, are reported and show clear evidence of Alfvén wave propagation as well as resonance of Alfvén modes. Galinstan is liquid at room temperature, and although its electrical conductivity is not as large as that of liquid sodium or NaK, it has still been possible to study Alfvén waves, thanks to the use of intense magnetic fi elds, up to 13 teslas. The…
▽ More
Experiments with a liquid metal alloy, galinstan, are reported and show clear evidence of Alfvén wave propagation as well as resonance of Alfvén modes. Galinstan is liquid at room temperature, and although its electrical conductivity is not as large as that of liquid sodium or NaK, it has still been possible to study Alfvén waves, thanks to the use of intense magnetic fi elds, up to 13 teslas. The maximal values of Lundquist number, around 60, are similar to that of the reference experimental study by Jameson [1]. The generation mechanism for Alfvén waves and their refl ection is studied carefully. Numerical simulations have been performed and have been able to reproduce the experimental results despite the fact that the simulated magnetic Prandtl number was much larger than that of galinstan. An originality of the present study is that a poloidal disturbance (magnetic and velocity fields) is generated, allowing us to track its propagation from outside the conducting domain, hence without interfering.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2011; v1 submitted 23 June, 2011;
originally announced June 2011.
-
Zonal shear and super-rotation in a magnetized spherical Couette flow experiment
Authors:
Daniel Brito,
Thierry Alboussière,
Philippe Cardin,
Nadège Gagnière,
Dominique Jault,
Patrick La Rizza,
Jean-Paul Masson,
Henri-Claude Nataf,
Denys Schmitt
Abstract:
We present measurements performed in a spherical shell filled with liquid sodium, where a 74 mm-radius inner sphere is rotated while a 210 mm-radius outer sphere is at rest. The inner sphere holds a dipolar magnetic field and acts as a magnetic propeller when rotated. In this experimental set-up called DTS, direct measurements of the velocity are performed by ultrasonic Doppler velocimetry. Differ…
▽ More
We present measurements performed in a spherical shell filled with liquid sodium, where a 74 mm-radius inner sphere is rotated while a 210 mm-radius outer sphere is at rest. The inner sphere holds a dipolar magnetic field and acts as a magnetic propeller when rotated. In this experimental set-up called DTS, direct measurements of the velocity are performed by ultrasonic Doppler velocimetry. Differences in electric potential and the induced magnetic field are also measured to characterize the magnetohydrodynamic flow. Rotation frequencies of the inner sphere are varied between -30 Hz and +30 Hz, the magnetic Reynolds number based on measured sodium velocities and on the shell radius reaching to about 33. We have investigated the mean axisymmetric part of the flow, which consists of differential rotation. Strong super-rotation of the fluid with respect to the rotating inner sphere is directly measured. It is found that the organization of the mean flow does not change much throughout the entire range of parameters covered by our experiment. The direct measurements of zonal velocity give a nice illustration of Ferraro's law of isorotation in the vicinity of the inner sphere where magnetic forces dominate inertial ones. The transition from a Ferraro regime in the interior to a geostrophic regime, where inertial forces predominate, in the outer regions has been well documented. It takes place where the local Elsasser number is about 1. A quantitative agreement with non-linear numerical simulations is obtained when kee** the same Elsasser number. The experiments also reveal a region that violates Ferraro's law just above the inner sphere.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2011; v1 submitted 25 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
On the existence and structure of a mush at the inner core boundary of the Earth
Authors:
Renaud Deguen,
Thierry Alboussière,
Daniel Brito
Abstract:
It has been suggested about 20 years ago that the liquid close to the inner core boundary (ICB) is supercooled and that a sizable mushy layer has developed during the growth of the inner core. The morphological instability of the liquid-solid interface which usually results in the formation of a mushy zone has been intensively studied in metallurgy, but the freezing of the inner core occurs in v…
▽ More
It has been suggested about 20 years ago that the liquid close to the inner core boundary (ICB) is supercooled and that a sizable mushy layer has developed during the growth of the inner core. The morphological instability of the liquid-solid interface which usually results in the formation of a mushy zone has been intensively studied in metallurgy, but the freezing of the inner core occurs in very unusual conditions: the growth rate is very small, and the pressure gradient has a key role, the newly formed solid being hotter than the adjacent liquid. We investigate the linear stability of a solidification front under such conditions, pointing out the destabilizing role of the thermal and solutal fields, and the stabilizing role of the pressure gradient. The main consequence of the very small solidification rate is the importance of advective transport of solute in liquid, which tends to remove light solute from the vicinity of the ICB and to suppress supercooling, thus acting against the destabilization of the solidification front. For plausible phase diagrams of the core mixture, we nevertheless found that the ICB is likely to be morphologically unstable, and that a mushy zone might have developed at the ICB. The thermodynamic thickness of the resulting mushy zone can be significant, from $\sim100$ km to the entire inner core radius, depending on the phase diagram of the core mixture. However, such a thick mushy zone is predicted to collapse under its own weight, on a much smaller length scale ($\lesssim 1$ km). We estimate that the interdendritic spacing is probably smaller than a few tens of meter, and possibly only a few meters.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
Bound of dissipation on a plane Couette dynamo
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere
Abstract:
Variational turbulence is among the few approaches providing rigorous results in turbulence. In addition, it addresses a question of direct practical interest, namely the rate of energy dissipation. Unfortunately, only an upper bound is obtained as a larger functional space than the space of solutions to the Navier-Stokes equations is searched. Yet, in general, this upper bound is in good agreem…
▽ More
Variational turbulence is among the few approaches providing rigorous results in turbulence. In addition, it addresses a question of direct practical interest, namely the rate of energy dissipation. Unfortunately, only an upper bound is obtained as a larger functional space than the space of solutions to the Navier-Stokes equations is searched. Yet, in general, this upper bound is in good agreement with experimental results in terms of order of magnitude and power law of the imposed Reynolds number. In this paper, the variational approach to turbulence is extended to the case of dynamo action and an upper bound is obtained for the global dissipation rate (viscous and Ohmic). A simple plane Couette flow is investigated. For low magnetic Prandtl number $P_m$ fluids, the upper bound of energy dissipation is that of classical turbulence (i.e. proportional to the cubic power of the shear velocity) for magnetic Reynolds numbers below $P_m^{-1}$ and follows a steeper evolution for magnetic Reynolds numbers above $P_m^{-1}$ (i.e. proportional to the shear velocity to the power four) in the case of electrically insulating walls. However, the effect of wall conductance is crucial : for a given value of wall conductance, there is a value for the magnetic Reynolds number above which energy dissipation cannot be bounded. This limiting magnetic Reynolds number is inversely proportional to the square root of the conductance of the wall. Implications in terms of energy dissipation in experimental and natural dynamos are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 27 October, 2009; v1 submitted 10 January, 2008;
originally announced January 2008.
-
A case for variational geomagnetic data assimilation: insights from a one-dimensional, nonlinear, and sparsely observed MHD system
Authors:
Alexandre Fournier,
Céline Eymin,
Thierry Alboussière
Abstract:
Secular variations of the geomagnetic field have been measured with a continuously improving accuracy during the last few hundred years, culminating nowadays with satellite data. It is however well known that the dynamics of the magnetic field is linked to that of the velocity field in the core and any attempt to model secular variations will involve a coupled dynamical system for magnetic field…
▽ More
Secular variations of the geomagnetic field have been measured with a continuously improving accuracy during the last few hundred years, culminating nowadays with satellite data. It is however well known that the dynamics of the magnetic field is linked to that of the velocity field in the core and any attempt to model secular variations will involve a coupled dynamical system for magnetic field and core velocity. Unfortunately, there is no direct observation of the velocity. Independently of the exact nature of the above-mentioned coupled system -- some version being currently under construction -- the question is debated in this paper whether good knowledge of the magnetic field can be translated into good knowledge of core dynamics. Furthermore, what will be the impact of the most recent and precise geomagnetic data on our knowledge of the geomagnetic field of the past and future? These questions are cast into the language of variational data assimilation, while the dynamical system considered in this paper consists in a set of two oversimplified one-dimensional equations for magnetic and velocity fields. This toy model retains important features inherited from the induction and Navier-Stokes equations: non-linear magnetic and momentum terms are present and its linear response to small disturbances contains Alfvén waves. It is concluded that variational data assimilation is indeed appropriate in principle, even though the velocity field remains hidden at all times; it allows us to recover the entire evolution of both fields from partial and irregularly distributed information on the magnetic field. This work constitutes a first step on the way toward the reassimilation of historical geomagnetic data and geomagnetic forecast.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Rapidly rotating spherical Couette flow in a dipolar magnetic field: an experimental study of the mean axisymmetric flow
Authors:
Henri-Claude Nataf,
Thierry Alboussiere,
Daniel Brito,
Philippe Cardin,
Nadège Gagnière,
Dominique Jault,
Denys Schmitt
Abstract:
In order to explore the magnetostrophic regime expected for planetary cores, experiments have been conducted in a rotating sphere filled with liquid sodium, with an imposed dipolar magnetic field (the DTS setup). The field is produced by a permanent magnet enclosed in an inner sphere, which can rotate at a separate rate, producing a spherical Couette flow. The flow properties are investigated by…
▽ More
In order to explore the magnetostrophic regime expected for planetary cores, experiments have been conducted in a rotating sphere filled with liquid sodium, with an imposed dipolar magnetic field (the DTS setup). The field is produced by a permanent magnet enclosed in an inner sphere, which can rotate at a separate rate, producing a spherical Couette flow. The flow properties are investigated by measuring electric potentials on the outer sphere, the induced magnetic field in the laboratory frame, and velocity profiles inside the liquid sodium using ultrasonic Doppler velocimetry. The present article focuses on the time-averaged axisymmetric part of the flow. The Doppler profiles show that the angular velocity of the fluid is relatively uniform in most of the fluid shell, but rises near the inner sphere, revealing the presence of a magnetic wind, and gently drops towards the outer sphere. The transition from a magnetostrophic flow near the inner sphere to a geostrophic flow near the outer sphere is controlled by the local Elsasser number. For Rossby numbers up to order 1, the observed velocity profiles all show a similar shape. Numerical simulations in the linear regime are computed, and synthetic velocity profiles are compared with the measured ones. In the geostrophic region, a torque-balance model provides very good predictions. We find that the induced magnetic field varies in a consistent fashion, and displays a peculiar peak in the counter-rotating regime. This happens when the fluid rotation rate is almost equal and opposite to the outer sphere rotation rate. The fluid is then almost at rest in the laboratory frame, and the Proudman-Taylor constraint vanishes, enabling a strong meridional flow. We suggest that dynamo action might be favored in such a situation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2008; v1 submitted 10 May, 2007;
originally announced May 2007.
-
Experimental study of super-rotation in a magnetostrophic spherical Couette flow
Authors:
Henri-Claude Nataf,
Thierry Alboussière,
Daniel Brito,
Philippe Cardin,
Nadège Gagnière,
Dominique Jault,
Jean-Paul Masson,
Denys Schmitt
Abstract:
We report measurements of electric potentials at the surface of a spherical container of liquid sodium in which a magnetized inner core is differentially rotating. The azimuthal angular velocities inferred from these potentials reveal a strong super-rotation of the liquid sodium in the equatorial region, for small differential rotation. Super-rotation was observed in numerical simulations by Dor…
▽ More
We report measurements of electric potentials at the surface of a spherical container of liquid sodium in which a magnetized inner core is differentially rotating. The azimuthal angular velocities inferred from these potentials reveal a strong super-rotation of the liquid sodium in the equatorial region, for small differential rotation. Super-rotation was observed in numerical simulations by Dormy et al. [1]. We find that the latitudinal variation of the electric potentials in our experiments differs markedly from the predictions of a similar numerical model, suggesting that some of the assumptions used in the model - steadiness, equatorial symmetry, and linear treatment for the evolution of both the magnetic and velocity fields - are violated in the experiments. In addition, radial velocity measurements, using ultrasonic Doppler velocimetry, provide evidence of oscillatory motion near the outer sphere at low latitude: it is viewed as the signature of an instability of the super-rotating region.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2005;
originally announced December 2005.
-
A geostrophic-like model for large Hartmann number flows
Authors:
Thierry Alboussiere
Abstract:
A flow of electrically conducting fluid in the presence of a steady magnetic field has a tendency to become quasi two-dimensional, i.e. uniform in the direction of the magnetic field, except in thin so-called Hartmann boundary layers. The condition for this tendency is that of a strong magnetic field, corresponding to large values of the dimensionless Hartmann number (Ha >> 1). This is analogous…
▽ More
A flow of electrically conducting fluid in the presence of a steady magnetic field has a tendency to become quasi two-dimensional, i.e. uniform in the direction of the magnetic field, except in thin so-called Hartmann boundary layers. The condition for this tendency is that of a strong magnetic field, corresponding to large values of the dimensionless Hartmann number (Ha >> 1). This is analogous to the case of low Ekman number rotating flows, with Ekman layers replacing Hartmann layers. This has been at the origin of the homogeneous model for flows in a rotating frame of reference, with its rich structure: geostrophic contours and shear layers of Stewartson, Munk and Stommel. In magnetohydrodynamics, the characteristic surfaces introduced by Kulikovskii play a role similar to the role of the geostrophic contours. However, a general theory for quasi two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics is lacking. In this paper, a model is proposed which provides a general framework for quasi two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic flows. Not only can this model account for otherwise disconnected past results, but it is also used to predict a new type of shear layer, of typical thickness Ha^{-1/4}.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2005;
originally announced March 2005.
