-
Prioritizing High-Precision Photometric Monitoring of Exoplanet and Brown Dwarf Companions with JWST -- Strategic Exoplanet Initiatives with HST and JWST White Paper
Authors:
Ben J. Sutlieff,
Xueqing Chen,
Pengyu Liu,
Emma E. Bubb,
Stanimir A. Metchev,
Brendan P. Bowler,
Johanna M. Vos,
Raquel A. Martinez,
Genaro Suárez,
Yifan Zhou,
Samuel M. Factor,
Zhoujian Zhang,
Emily L. Rickman,
Arthur D. Adams,
Elena Manjavacas,
Julien H. Girard,
Bokyoung Kim,
Trent J. Dupuy
Abstract:
We advocate for the prioritization of high-precision photometric monitoring of exoplanet and brown dwarf companions to detect brightness variability arising from features in their atmospheres. Measurements of photometric variability provide not only an insight into the physical appearances of these companions, but are also a direct probe of their atmospheric structures and dynamics, and yield valu…
▽ More
We advocate for the prioritization of high-precision photometric monitoring of exoplanet and brown dwarf companions to detect brightness variability arising from features in their atmospheres. Measurements of photometric variability provide not only an insight into the physical appearances of these companions, but are also a direct probe of their atmospheric structures and dynamics, and yield valuable estimates of their rotation periods. JWST is uniquely capable of monitoring faint exoplanet companions over their full rotation periods, thanks to its inherent stability and powerful high-contrast coronagraphic imaging modes. Rotation period measurements can be further combined with measurements of v sin i obtained using high-resolution spectroscopy to infer the viewing angle of a companion. Photometric monitoring over multiple rotation periods and at multiple epochs will allow both short- and long-term time evolution in variability signals to be traced. Furthermore, the differences between the layers in a companion's atmosphere can be probed by obtaining simultaneous photometric monitoring at different wavelengths through NIRCam dual-band coronagraphy. Overall, JWST will reach the highest sensitivities to variability to date and enable the light curves of substellar companions to be characterised with unprecedented cadence and precision at the sub-percent level.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Turning Earth into Venus: A Stochastic Model of Possible Evolutions of Terrestrial Topography
Authors:
Arthur D. Adams,
Greg Laughlin
Abstract:
Venus may have had both an Earth-like climate as well as extensive water oceans and active (or incipient) plate tectonics for an extended interval of its history. The topographical power spectrum of Venus provides important clues to the planet's past evolution. By drawing detailed contrast with the strong low-order odd-$l$ dominated global topography of Earth, we demonstrate that the relatively fl…
▽ More
Venus may have had both an Earth-like climate as well as extensive water oceans and active (or incipient) plate tectonics for an extended interval of its history. The topographical power spectrum of Venus provides important clues to the planet's past evolution. By drawing detailed contrast with the strong low-order odd-$l$ dominated global topography of Earth, we demonstrate that the relatively flat Venusian topography can be interpreted to have arisen from the transition from active terrestrial-like plate tectonics to the current stagnant lid configuration at a time $τ= 544^{+886}_{-193}$ million years before present. This scenario is plausible if loss of oceans and the attendant transition to a CO$_2$-dominated atmosphere were accompanied by rapid continental-scale erosion, followed by gradual lava resurfacing at an outflow rate $\sim$ 1 km$^{3}$ yr$^{-1}$. We study Venus' proposed topographical relaxation with a global diffusion-like model that adopts terrestrial erosion rates scaled to account for the increased rainfall and temperatures that would accompany a planet-wide transition from an Earth-like climate to the runaway greenhouse climate that could ultimately yield present-day Venus, with an estimate of $5.1^{+1.8}_{-1.1}$ Myr if the global erosion operated as efficiently as that of a typical bedrock river basin on Earth.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Atmospheric Retrieval of L Dwarfs: Benchmarking Results and Characterizing the Young Planetary Mass Companion HD 106906 b in the Near-Infrared
Authors:
Arthur D. Adams,
Michael R. Meyer,
Alex R. Howe,
Ben Burningham,
Sebastian Daemgen,
Jonathan Fortney,
Mike Line,
Mark Marley,
Sascha P. Quanz,
Kamen Todorov
Abstract:
We present model constraints on the atmospheric structure of HD 106906 b, a planetary-mass companion orbiting at a ~700 AU projected separation around a 15 Myr-old stellar binary, using the APOLLO retrieval code on spectral data spanning 1.1-2.5 $μ$m. C/O ratios can provide evidence for companion formation pathways, as such pathways are ambiguous both at wide separations and at star-to-companion m…
▽ More
We present model constraints on the atmospheric structure of HD 106906 b, a planetary-mass companion orbiting at a ~700 AU projected separation around a 15 Myr-old stellar binary, using the APOLLO retrieval code on spectral data spanning 1.1-2.5 $μ$m. C/O ratios can provide evidence for companion formation pathways, as such pathways are ambiguous both at wide separations and at star-to-companion mass ratios in the overlap between the distributions of planets and brown dwarfs. We benchmark our code against an existing retrieval of the field L dwarf 2M2224-0158, returning a C/O ratio consistent with previous fits to the same JHKs data, but disagreeing in the thermal structure, cloud properties, and atmospheric scale height. For HD 106906 b, we retrieve C/O $=0.53^{+0.15}_{-0.25}$, consistent with the C/O ratios expected for HD 106906's stellar association and therefore consistent with a stellar-like formation for the companion. We find abundances of H$_2$O and CO near chemical equilibrium values for a solar metallicity, but a surface gravity lower than expected, as well as a thermal profile with sharp transitions in the temperature gradient. Despite high signal-to-noise and spectral resolution, more accurate constraints necessitate data across a broader wavelength range. This work serves as preparation for subsequent retrievals in the era of JWST, as JWST's spectral range provides a promising opportunity to resolve difficulties in fitting low-gravity L dwarfs, and also underscores the need for simultaneous comparative retrievals on L dwarf companions with multiple retrieval codes.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Planet Eclipse Map** with Long-Term Baseline Drifts
Authors:
Everett Schlawin,
Ryan Challener,
Megan Mansfield,
Emily Rauscher,
Arthur D. Adams,
Jacob Lustig-Yaeger
Abstract:
High precision lightcurves combined with eclipse map** techniques can reveal the horizontal and vertical structure of a planet's thermal emission and the dynamics of hot Jupiters. Someday, they even may reveal the surface maps of rocky planets. However, inverting lightcurves into maps requires an understanding of the planet, star and instrumental trends because they can resemble the gradual flux…
▽ More
High precision lightcurves combined with eclipse map** techniques can reveal the horizontal and vertical structure of a planet's thermal emission and the dynamics of hot Jupiters. Someday, they even may reveal the surface maps of rocky planets. However, inverting lightcurves into maps requires an understanding of the planet, star and instrumental trends because they can resemble the gradual flux variations as the planet rotates (ie. partial phase curves). In this work, we simulate lightcurves with baseline trends and assess the impact on planet maps. Baseline trends can be erroneously modeled by incorrect astrophysical planet map features, but there are clues to avoid this pitfall in both the residuals of the lightcurve during eclipse and sharp features at the terminator of the planet. Models that use a Gaussian process or polynomial to account for a baseline trend successfully recover the input map even in the presence of systematics but with worse precision for the m=1 spherical harmonic terms. This is also confirmed with the ThERESA eigencurve method where fewer lightcurve terms can model the planet without correlations between the components. These conclusions help aid the decision on how to schedule observations to improve map precision. If the m=1 components are critical, such as measuring the East/West hotspot shift on a hot Jupiter, better characterization of baseline trends can improve the m=1 terms' precision. For latitudinal North/South information from the remaining map** terms, it is preferable to obtain high signal-to-noise at ingress/egress with more eclipses.
△ Less
Submitted 13 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
A Theoretical Framework for the Mass Distribution of Gas Giant Planets forming through the Core Accretion Paradigm
Authors:
Fred C Adams,
Michael R Meyer,
Arthur D Adams
Abstract:
This paper constructs a theoretical framework for calculating the distribution of masses for gas giant planets forming via the core accretion paradigm. Starting with known properties of circumstellar disks, we present models for the planetary mass distribution over the range $0.1M_J < M_{\rm p} < 10M_J$. If the circumstellar disk lifetime is solely responsible for the end of planetary mass accreti…
▽ More
This paper constructs a theoretical framework for calculating the distribution of masses for gas giant planets forming via the core accretion paradigm. Starting with known properties of circumstellar disks, we present models for the planetary mass distribution over the range $0.1M_J < M_{\rm p} < 10M_J$. If the circumstellar disk lifetime is solely responsible for the end of planetary mass accretion, the observed (nearly) exponential distribution of disk lifetime would imprint an exponential fall-off in the planetary mass function. This result is in apparent conflict with observations, which suggest that the mass distribution has a (nearly) power-law form $dF/dM_{\rm p}\sim M_{\rm p}^{-p}$, with index $p\approx1.3$, over the relevant planetary mass range (and for stellar masses $\sim0.5-2M_\odot$). The mass accretion rate onto the planet depends on the fraction of the (circumstellar) disk accretion flow that enters the Hill sphere, and on the efficiency with which the planet captures the incoming material. Models for the planetary mass function that include distributions for these efficiencies, with uninformed priors, can produce nearly power-law behavior, consistent with current observations. The disk lifetimes, accretion rates, and other input parameters depend on the mass of the host star. We show how these variations lead to different forms for the planetary mass function for different stellar masses. Compared to stars with masses $M_\ast$ = $0.5-2M_\odot$, stars with smaller masses are predicted to have a steeper planetary mass function (fewer large planets).
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Eigenspectra: A Framework for Identifying Spectra from 3D Eclipse Map**
Authors:
Megan Mansfield,
Everett Schlawin,
Jacob Lustig-Yaeger,
Arthur D. Adams,
Emily Rauscher,
Jacob Arcangeli,
Y. Katherina Feng,
Prashansa Gupta,
Dylan Keating,
Kevin B. Stevenson,
Thomas G. Beatty
Abstract:
Planetary atmospheres are inherently 3D objects that can have strong gradients in latitude, longitude, and altitude. Secondary eclipse map** is a powerful way to map the 3D distribution of the atmosphere, but the data can have large correlations and errors in the presence of photon and instrument noise. We develop a technique to mitigate the large uncertainties of eclipse maps by identifying a s…
▽ More
Planetary atmospheres are inherently 3D objects that can have strong gradients in latitude, longitude, and altitude. Secondary eclipse map** is a powerful way to map the 3D distribution of the atmosphere, but the data can have large correlations and errors in the presence of photon and instrument noise. We develop a technique to mitigate the large uncertainties of eclipse maps by identifying a small number of dominant spectra to make them more tractable for individual analysis via atmospheric retrieval. We use the eigencurves method to infer a multi-wavelength map of a planet from spectroscopic secondary eclipse light curves. We then apply a clustering algorithm to the planet map to identify several regions with similar emergent spectra. We combine the similar spectra together to construct an "eigenspectrum" for each distinct region on the planetary map. We demonstrate how this approach could be used to isolate hot from cold regions and/or regions with different chemical compositions in observations of hot Jupiters with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). We find that our method struggles to identify sharp edges in maps with sudden discontinuities, but generally can be used as a first step before a more physically motivated modeling approach to determine the primary features observed on the planet.
△ Less
Submitted 5 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Signatures of Obliquity in Thermal Phase Curves of Hot Jupiters
Authors:
Arthur D. Adams,
Sarah Millholland,
Gregory P. Laughlin
Abstract:
Recent work suggests that many short-period extrasolar planets may have spin obliquities that are significantly tilted with respect to their orbital planes. These large obliquities are a natural outcome of ``secular spin-orbit resonance'', a configuration in which the planetary spin precession frequency matches the frequency of orbit nodal regression, or a Fourier component thereof. While exoplane…
▽ More
Recent work suggests that many short-period extrasolar planets may have spin obliquities that are significantly tilted with respect to their orbital planes. These large obliquities are a natural outcome of ``secular spin-orbit resonance'', a configuration in which the planetary spin precession frequency matches the frequency of orbit nodal regression, or a Fourier component thereof. While exoplanet spin obliquities have not yet been measured directly, they may be detectable indirectly through their signatures in various observations, such as photometric measurements across the full phase of a planet's orbit. In this work, we employ a thermal radiative model to explore how large polar tilts affect full-phase light curves, and we discuss the range of unique signatures that are expected to result. We show that the well-studied short-period planets HD 149026 b, WASP-12 b, and CoRoT-2 b all exhibit phase curve features that may arise from being in high-obliquity states. We also constrain the parameters and assess the detectability of hypothetical perturbing planets that could maintain the planets in these states. Among the three planets considered, CoRoT-2 b has the tightest constraints on its proposed obliquity ($45.8^{\circ} \pm 1.4^{\circ}$) and axial orientation. For HD 149026 b, we find no significant evidence for a non-zero obliquity, and the phase curve of WASP-12 b is too complicated by strong tidal distortions for a conclusive assessment.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Aquaplanet Models on Eccentric Orbits: Effects of Rotation Rate on Observables
Authors:
Arthur D. Adams,
William R. Boos,
Eric T. Wolf
Abstract:
Rotation and orbital eccentricity both strongly influence planetary climate. Eccentricities can often be measured for exoplanets, but rotation rates are currently difficult or impossible to constrain. Here we examine how the combined effects of rotation and eccentricity on observed emission from ocean-rich terrestrial planets can be used to infer their rotation rates in circumstances where their e…
▽ More
Rotation and orbital eccentricity both strongly influence planetary climate. Eccentricities can often be measured for exoplanets, but rotation rates are currently difficult or impossible to constrain. Here we examine how the combined effects of rotation and eccentricity on observed emission from ocean-rich terrestrial planets can be used to infer their rotation rates in circumstances where their eccentricities are known. We employ an Earth climate model with no land and a slab ocean, and consider two eccentricities ($e=0.3$ and 0.6) and two rotation rates: a fast Earth-like period of 24 hours, and a slower pseudo-synchronous period that generalizes spin synchronization for eccentric orbits. We adopt bandpasses of the Mid-Infrared Instrument on the James Webb Space Telescope as a template for future photometry. At $e=0.3$ the rotation rates can be distinguished if the planet transits near periastron, because slow rotation produces a strong day-night contrast and thus an emission minimum during periastron. However, light curves behave similarly if the planet is eclipsed near periastron, as well as for either viewing geometry at $e=0.6$. Rotation rates can nevertheless be distinguished using ratios of emission in different bands, one in the water vapor window with another in a region of strong water absorption. These ratios vary over an orbit by $\lesssim\!0.1$ dex for Earth-like rotation, but by 0.3--0.5 dex for pseudo-synchronous rotation because of large day-night contrast in upper-tropospheric water. For planets with condensible atmospheric constituents in eccentric orbits, rotation regimes might thus be distinguished with infrared observations for a range of viewing geometries.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Reassessing Exoplanet Light Curves with a Thermal Model
Authors:
Arthur D. Adams,
Gregory Laughlin
Abstract:
We present a uniform assessment of existing near-infrared Spitzer Space Telescope observations of planet-bearing stars. Using a simple four-parameter blackbody thermal model, we analyze stars for which photometry in at least one of Spitzer's IRAC bands has been obtained over either the entirety or a significant fraction of the planetary orbit. Systems in this category comprise ten well-studied sys…
▽ More
We present a uniform assessment of existing near-infrared Spitzer Space Telescope observations of planet-bearing stars. Using a simple four-parameter blackbody thermal model, we analyze stars for which photometry in at least one of Spitzer's IRAC bands has been obtained over either the entirety or a significant fraction of the planetary orbit. Systems in this category comprise ten well-studied systems with Hot Jupiters on circular or near-circular orbits (HAT-P-7, HD 149026, HD 189733, HD 209458, WASP-12, WASP-14, WASP-18, WASP-19, WASP-33, and WASP-43), as well as three stars harboring planets on significantly eccentric orbits (GJ 436, HAT-P-2, and HD 80606). We find that our simple model, in almost all cases, accurately reproduces the minimum and maximum planetary emission, as well as the phase offsets of these extrema with respect to transits/secondary eclipses. For one notable exception, WASP-12 b, adding an additional parameter to account for its tidal distortion is not sufficient to reproduce its photometric features. Full-orbit photometry is available in multiple wavelengths for 10 planets. We find that the returned parameter values for independent fits to each band are largely in agreement. However, disagreements in night-side temperature suggest distinct atmospheric layers, each with their own characteristic minimum temperature. In addition, a diversity in albedos suggests variation in opacity of the photospheres. While previous works have pointed out trends in photometric features based on system properties, we cannot conclusively identify analogous trends for physical model parameters. To make the connection between full-phase data and physical models more robust, a higher signal-to-noise must come from both increased resolution and a careful treatment of instrumental systematics.
△ Less
Submitted 10 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Predicting Stellar Angular Diameters from $V$, $I_C$, $H$, $K$ Photometry
Authors:
Arthur D. Adams,
Tabetha S. Boyajian,
Kaspar von Braun
Abstract:
Determining the physical properties of microlensing events depends on having accurate angular sizes of the source star. Using long-baseline optical interferometry we are able to measure the angular sizes of nearby stars with uncertainties $\leq 2\%$. We present empirically derived relations of angular diameters that are calibrated using both a sample of dwarfs/subgiants and a sample of giant stars…
▽ More
Determining the physical properties of microlensing events depends on having accurate angular sizes of the source star. Using long-baseline optical interferometry we are able to measure the angular sizes of nearby stars with uncertainties $\leq 2\%$. We present empirically derived relations of angular diameters that are calibrated using both a sample of dwarfs/subgiants and a sample of giant stars. These relations are functions of five color indices in the visible and near-infrared, and have uncertainties of 1.8-6.5% depending on the color used. We find that a combined sample of both main-sequence and evolved stars of A-K spectral types is well fit by a single relation for each color considered. We find that in the colors considered, metallicity does not play a statistically significant role in predicting stellar size, leading to a means of predicting observed sizes of stars from color alone.
△ Less
Submitted 12 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Using Kepler Candidates to Examine the Properties of Habitable Zone Exoplanets
Authors:
Arthur D. Adams,
Stephen R. Kane
Abstract:
An analysis of the currently known exoplanets in the habitable zones (HZs) of their host stars is of interest in both the wake of the NASA Kepler mission and with prospects for expanding the known planet population through future ground- and space-based projects. In this paper we compare the empirical distributions of the properties of stellar systems with transiting planets to those with transiti…
▽ More
An analysis of the currently known exoplanets in the habitable zones (HZs) of their host stars is of interest in both the wake of the NASA Kepler mission and with prospects for expanding the known planet population through future ground- and space-based projects. In this paper we compare the empirical distributions of the properties of stellar systems with transiting planets to those with transiting HZ planets. This comparison includes two categories: confirmed/validated transiting planet systems, and Kepler planet and candidate planet systems. These two categories allow us to present quantitative analyses on both a conservative dataset of known planets and a more optimistic and numerous sample of Kepler candidates. Both are subject to similar instrumental and detection biases, and vetted against false positive detections. We examine whether the HZ distributions vary from the overall distributions in the Kepler sample with respect to planetary radius as well as stellar mass, effective temperature, and metallicity. We find that while the evidence is strongest in suggesting a difference between the size distributions of planets in the HZ and the overall size distribution, none of the statistical results provide strong empirical evidence for HZ planets or HZ planet-hosting stars to be significantly different from the full Kepler sample with respect to these properties.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2016; v1 submitted 22 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
