-
Understanding solid nitrogen through machine learning simulation
Authors:
Marcin Kirsz,
Ciprian G. Pruteanu,
Peter I. C. Cooke,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We construct a fast, transferable, general purpose, machine-learning interatomic potential suitable for large-scale simulations of $N_2$. The potential is trained only on high quality quantum chemical molecule-molecule interactions, no condensed phase information is used. The potential reproduces the experimental phase diagram including the melt curve and the molecular solid phases of nitrogen up…
▽ More
We construct a fast, transferable, general purpose, machine-learning interatomic potential suitable for large-scale simulations of $N_2$. The potential is trained only on high quality quantum chemical molecule-molecule interactions, no condensed phase information is used. The potential reproduces the experimental phase diagram including the melt curve and the molecular solid phases of nitrogen up to 10 GPa. This demonstrates that many-molecule interactions are unnecessary to explain the condensed phases of $N_2$. With increased pressure, transitions are observed from cubic ($α-N_2$), which optimises quadrupole-quadrupole interactions, through tetragonal ($γ-N_2$) which allows more efficient packing, through to monoclinic ($λ-N_2$) which packs still more efficiently. On heating, we obtain the hcp 3D rotor phase ($β-N_2$) and, at pressure, the cubic $δ-N_2$ phase which contains both 3D and 2D rotors, tetragonal $δ^\star-N_2$ phase with 2D rotors and the rhombohedral $ε-N_2$. Molecular dynamics demonstrates where these phases are indeed rotors, rather than frustrated order. The model does not support the existence of the wide range of bondlengths reported for the complex $ι-N_2$ phase. The thermodynamic transitions involve both shifts of molecular centres and rotations of molecules. We simulate these phase transitions between finding that the onset of rotation is rapid whereas motion of molecular centres is inhibited and the cause of the observed sluggishness of transitions. Routine density functional theory calculations give a similar picture to the potential.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024; v1 submitted 8 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
A comparison of different Fourier transform procedures for analysis of diffraction data from noble gas fluids
Authors:
John E. Proctor,
Ciprian G. Pruteanu,
Benjamin Moss,
Mikhail A. Kuzovnikov,
Graeme J. Ackland,
Christopher W. Monk,
Simone Anzellini
Abstract:
A comparison is made between the three principal methods for analysis of neutron and X-ray diffraction data from noble gas fluids by direct Fourier transform. All three methods (standard Fourier transform, Lorch modification and Soper-Barney modification) are used to analyse four different sets of diffraction data from noble gas fluids. The results are compared to the findings of a full-scale real…
▽ More
A comparison is made between the three principal methods for analysis of neutron and X-ray diffraction data from noble gas fluids by direct Fourier transform. All three methods (standard Fourier transform, Lorch modification and Soper-Barney modification) are used to analyse four different sets of diffraction data from noble gas fluids. The results are compared to the findings of a full-scale real space structure determination, namely Empirical Potential Structure Refinement. Conclusions are drawn on the relative merits of the three Fourier transform methods, what information can be reliably obtained using each method, and which method is most suitable for analysis of different kinds of diffraction data. The mathematical validity of the Lorch method is critically analysed.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Breaking the H2 chemical bond in a crystalline environment
Authors:
Miriam Marqués,
Miriam Pena Alvarez,
Miguel Martinez-Canales,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
Through density functional theory and molecular dynamics calculations, we have analysed various metal polyhydrides to understand whether hydrogen is present in its molecular or atomic form - tetrahydrides of Ba,Sr,Ra, Cs and La; Ba$_8$H$_{46}$ and BaH$_{12}$.
We show that, in experimentally reported binary barium hydrides (BaH$_x$), molecular H$_2$ and atomic H$^-$ can coexist with the metallic…
▽ More
Through density functional theory and molecular dynamics calculations, we have analysed various metal polyhydrides to understand whether hydrogen is present in its molecular or atomic form - tetrahydrides of Ba,Sr,Ra, Cs and La; Ba$_8$H$_{46}$ and BaH$_{12}$.
We show that, in experimentally reported binary barium hydrides (BaH$_x$), molecular H$_2$ and atomic H$^-$ can coexist with the metallic cations.
In this thorough study of differences between BaH$_4$, higher barium hydrides, and other binary tetrahydrides we find the number of atomic hydrogens is equal to the formal charge of the cations. The remaining hydrogen forms molecules in proportions yielding, e.g. BaH$_2$(H$_2)_x$, at pressures as high as 200 GPa. At room temperature these are highly dynamic structures with the hydrogens switching between H$^-$ and H$_2$ while retaining the 2:x ratio.
We find some qualitative differences between our static DFT calculations and previously reported structural and spectroscopic experimental results. Two factors allow us to resolve such discrepancies: Firstly, in static relaxation H$_2$ must be regarded as a non-spherical object, which breaks symmetry in a way invisible to X-rays; Secondly the required number of molecules $x$ may be incompatible with the experimental space group (e.g. $BaH_2(H_2)_5$). In molecular dynamics, bond-breaking transitions between various structural symmetry configurations happen on a picosecond timescale via an H$_3^-$ intermediate. Rebonding is slow enough to allow a spectroscopic signal but frequent enough to average out over the lengthscale involved in diffraction.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Competition between superconductivity and molecularization in quantum nuclear behavior of Lanthanum Hydride
Authors:
Sebastiaan van de Bund,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
Lanthanum hydride is the superconductor with the highest known critical temperature. It is believed that the superconductivity is of standard BCS-type, with electrons forming Cooper pairs and opening the superconducting band gap. Here we show that the BCS electron pairing is in competition with an alternative pairing: covalent bonding. We show that the covalent pairing is favored at lower pressure…
▽ More
Lanthanum hydride is the superconductor with the highest known critical temperature. It is believed that the superconductivity is of standard BCS-type, with electrons forming Cooper pairs and opening the superconducting band gap. Here we show that the BCS electron pairing is in competition with an alternative pairing: covalent bonding. We show that the covalent pairing is favored at lower pressures, the superconducting cubic phase becomes unstable as pressure is reduced. Previous calculations based on static relaxation neglect three factors, all of which are important in stabilizing the cubic phase. Finite temperature plays a role, and two quantum effects are also important - the nuclear wavefunction contributes to destablizing the H$_2$ molecules, and the zero-point pressure means that calculated pressures are significantly overestimated by standard methods. We demonstrate these phenomena using Born-Oppenheimer and path-integral molecular dynamics: these give the same qualitative picture, with nuclear quantum effects (NQE) increasing the transition pressure significantly. This competition between molecularization and superconducting gap formation is the fundamental reason why hydride superconductors have so far been found only at high pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2023; v1 submitted 2 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Compression and information entropy of binary strings from the collision history of three hard balls
Authors:
Matej Vedak,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
We investigate how to measure and define the entropy of a simple chaotic system, three hard spheres on a ring. A novel approach is presented, which does not assume the ergodic hypothesis. It consists of transforming the particles collision history into a sequence of binary digits. We then investigate three approaches which should demonstrate the non-randomness of these collision-generated strings…
▽ More
We investigate how to measure and define the entropy of a simple chaotic system, three hard spheres on a ring. A novel approach is presented, which does not assume the ergodic hypothesis. It consists of transforming the particles collision history into a sequence of binary digits. We then investigate three approaches which should demonstrate the non-randomness of these collision-generated strings compared with random number generator created strings: Shannon entropy, diehard randomness tests and compression percentage. We show that the Shannon information entropy is unable to distinguish random from deterministic strings. The Diehard test performs better, but for certain mass-ratios the collision-generated strings are misidentified as random with high confidence. The zlib and bz2 compression algorithms are efficient at detecting non-randomness and low information content, with compression efficiencies that tend to 100% in the limit of infinite strings. Thus compression algorithm entropy is non-extensive for this chaotic system, in marked contrast to the extensive entropy determined from phase-space integrals by assuming ergodicity.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2023; v1 submitted 14 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
On the existence of an intermediate phase in the antiferromagnetic Ising model on an face-centered cubic lattice
Authors:
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
We use Monte Carlo simulation to determine the stable structures in the second-neighbour Ising model on the face-centred cubic lattice. Those structures are L1_1 for strongly antiferromagnetic second neighbour interactions and L1_0 for ferromagnetic and weakly antiferromagnetic second neighbours. We find a third stable "intermediate" antiferromagnetic phase with I4_1/amd symmetry, and calculate th…
▽ More
We use Monte Carlo simulation to determine the stable structures in the second-neighbour Ising model on the face-centred cubic lattice. Those structures are L1_1 for strongly antiferromagnetic second neighbour interactions and L1_0 for ferromagnetic and weakly antiferromagnetic second neighbours. We find a third stable "intermediate" antiferromagnetic phase with I4_1/amd symmetry, and calculate the paramagnetic transition temperature for each.
The transition temperature depends strongly on second neighbour interactions which are not frustrated. Our results contradict a recent paper, which also reported two different AFM structures and a new "intermediate" phase exists in this system. Here we show that the assumed sublattice structure in is inconsistent with the ground state. We determine a sublattice structure suitable for solving this problem with mean field theory.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2023; v1 submitted 2 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Detectability of core level crossing and electronic topological transformations: the case of Osmium
Authors:
Gavin Armstrong Woolman,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
Osmium, the least compressible metal, has recently been observed to undergo abrupt changes in the c/a ratio at extreme pressures. These are claimed to provide evidence for two unusual electronic behaviors: a crossing of the semicore 4f and 5p levels, and an electronic topological transition. We demonstrate that these two electronic phenomena are readily reproduced and understood in density functio…
▽ More
Osmium, the least compressible metal, has recently been observed to undergo abrupt changes in the c/a ratio at extreme pressures. These are claimed to provide evidence for two unusual electronic behaviors: a crossing of the semicore 4f and 5p levels, and an electronic topological transition. We demonstrate that these two electronic phenomena are readily reproduced and understood in density functional theory, but that neither perturbs the trend in c/a ratio against pressure. Hence the observed anomalies in c/a must have another cause. Osmium is also notable for its high yield stress: the c/a anomalies lie well within the differential strains which osmium can support. We propose that observed c/a changes can arise from mechanical yield of crystallites with strong preferred orientation under high deviatoric stress in the experimental data. We discuss what evidence remains for the more general hypothesis that core-level overlap under pressure can have measurable effects on the crystal structure in any material.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022; v1 submitted 21 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Calculating the Raman Signal Beyond Perturbation Theory for a Diatomic Molecular Crystal
Authors:
Peter I. C. Cooke,
Ioan B. Magdău,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We calculate the eigenstates of a diatomic molecule in a range of model mean-field potentials, and evaluate the evolution of their associated Raman spectra with field strength. We demonstrate that dramatic changes in the appearance of the Raman spectrum for a diatomic molecule occur without any associated change in the symmetry of the surrounding potential. The limiting cases of the quantum eigens…
▽ More
We calculate the eigenstates of a diatomic molecule in a range of model mean-field potentials, and evaluate the evolution of their associated Raman spectra with field strength. We demonstrate that dramatic changes in the appearance of the Raman spectrum for a diatomic molecule occur without any associated change in the symmetry of the surrounding potential. The limiting cases of the quantum eigenstates correspond, in the classical sense, to free rotation, and libration of well-oriented molecules. However, there are also many mixed modes which are neither rotons nor librons. The consequence for Raman spectroscopy is a series of complications - the non-harmonic potential splits the Raman active modes, and breaks the selection rules on forbidden modes. The mass-dependence of the various states is different - rotors, oscillators and reorientations have $1/m$, $1/\sqrt{m}$ and weaker mass dependence respectively. This may allow one to identify the character of the mode with isotope spectroscopy. However it is complicated by mixed modes and transitions between two different eigenstates with different character. We conclude that significant changes in the Raman spectrum of molecular systems are insufficient to demonstrate a phase transition since such changes can also occur in a fixed symmetry potential upon increasing field strength.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Two state model for critical points and the negative slope of the melting-curve
Authors:
Graeme J. Ackland,
Hongxiang Zong,
Victor Naden Robinson Sandro Scandolo,
Andreas Hermann
Abstract:
We present a thermodynamic model which explains the presence of a negative slope in the melt curve, as observed in systems as diverse as the alkali metals and molecular hydrogen at high pressure. We assume that components of the system can be in one of two well defined states - one associated with low energy, the other with low volume.
The model exhibits a number of measurable features which are…
▽ More
We present a thermodynamic model which explains the presence of a negative slope in the melt curve, as observed in systems as diverse as the alkali metals and molecular hydrogen at high pressure. We assume that components of the system can be in one of two well defined states - one associated with low energy, the other with low volume.
The model exhibits a number of measurable features which are also observed in these systems and are therefore expected to be associated with all negative Clapeyron-slope systems: first order phase transitions, thermodynamic anomalies along Widom lines.
The melt curve maximum is a feature of the model, but appears well below the pressures where the change in state occurs in the solid: the solid-solid transition is related to the melt line minimum. An example of the model fitted to the electride transition in potassium is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 12 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Isotope quantum effects in the metallization transition in liquid hydrogen
Authors:
Sebastiaan van de Bund,
Heather Wiebe,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
Quantum effects in condensed matter normally only occur at low temperatures. Here we show a large quantum effect in high-pressure liquid hydrogen at thousands of Kelvins. We show that the metallization transition in hydrogen is subject to a very large isotope effect, occurring hundreds of degrees lower than the equivalent transition in deuterium. We examined this using path integral molecular dyna…
▽ More
Quantum effects in condensed matter normally only occur at low temperatures. Here we show a large quantum effect in high-pressure liquid hydrogen at thousands of Kelvins. We show that the metallization transition in hydrogen is subject to a very large isotope effect, occurring hundreds of degrees lower than the equivalent transition in deuterium. We examined this using path integral molecular dynamics simulations which identify a liquid-liquid transition involving atomization, metallization, and changes in viscosity, specific heat and compressibility. The difference between H$_2$ and D$_2$ is a quantum mechanical effect which can be associated with the larger zero-point energy in H$_2$ weakening the covalent bond. Our results mean that experimental results on deuterium must be corrected before they are relevant to understanding hydrogen at planetary conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2021; v1 submitted 11 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Non-existence of the s-f transition in structures of solid gadolinium at pressure
Authors:
Qingchen Li,
Hossein Ehteshami,
Keith Munro,
Malcolm I McMahon,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
Gadolinium has long been believed to undergo a high pressure phase transition with a volume collapse around 5%. Theoretical explanations have focused on the idea of electrons transferring from the extended s-orbital to the compact f-orbital. However, experimental measurement has been unable to detect any associated change in the magnetic properties of the f-electrons. Here we resolve this discrepa…
▽ More
Gadolinium has long been believed to undergo a high pressure phase transition with a volume collapse around 5%. Theoretical explanations have focused on the idea of electrons transferring from the extended s-orbital to the compact f-orbital. However, experimental measurement has been unable to detect any associated change in the magnetic properties of the f-electrons. Here we resolve this discrepancy by showing that there is no significant volume collapse, beyond what is typical in high pressure phase transformations. We present density functional theory calculations of solid gadolinium under high pressure using a range of methods, and revisit the experimental situation using X-ray diffraction (XRD). The standard lanthanide pressure-transformation sequence involving different stackings of close-packed planes: hcp to 9R to dhcp to fcc to d-fcc is reproduced. The so-called "volume collapsed" high-pressure phase is shown to be an unusual stacking of close-packed planes, with Fddd symmetry and a density change less than 2%. The distorted fcc (d-fcc) structure is revealed to arise as a consequence of antiferromagnetism. The theoretical results are shown to be remarkably robust to various treatments of the f-electrons. The key result is that there is no XRD evidence for volume collapse in Gadolinium. The sequence of phase transitions is well described by standard DFT. There is no need for special treatment of the f-electrons or evidence of f-electron bonding. Noting previous spectroscopic evidence is that there is no change in the f-electrons we conclude that high pressure Gadolinium has no complicated f-electron physics such as Mott-Hubbard, Kondo or valence transition.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2021; v1 submitted 21 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Phase behaviour of the quantum Lennard-Jones solid
Authors:
Heather Wiebe,
Tom L. Underwood,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
The Lennard-Jones potential is perhaps one of the most widely-used models for the interaction of uncharged particles, such as noble gas solids. The phase diagram of the classical LJ solid is known to exhibit transitions between hcp and fcc phases. However, the phase behaviour of the quantum Lennard-Jones solid remains unknown. Thermodynamic integration based on path integral molecular dynamics and…
▽ More
The Lennard-Jones potential is perhaps one of the most widely-used models for the interaction of uncharged particles, such as noble gas solids. The phase diagram of the classical LJ solid is known to exhibit transitions between hcp and fcc phases. However, the phase behaviour of the quantum Lennard-Jones solid remains unknown. Thermodynamic integration based on path integral molecular dynamics and lattice dynamics calculations are used to study the phase stability of the hcp and fcc Lennard-Jones solids. The hcp phase is shown to be stabilized by quantum effects in PIMD while fcc is shown to be favoured by lattice dynamics, which suggests a possible re-entrant low pressure hcp phase for highly quantum systems. Implications for the phase stability of noble gas solids are discussed. For parameters equating to Helium, the expansion due to zero-point vibrations is associated with quantum melting: neither crystal structure is stable at zero pressure.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Understanding high pressure hydrogen with a hierarchical machine-learned potential
Authors:
Hongxiang Zong,
Heather Wiebe,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
The hydrogen phase diagram has a number of unusual features which are generally well reproduced by density functional calculations. Unfortunately, these calculations fail to provide good physical insights into why those features occur. In this paper, we parameterize a model potential for molecular hydrogen which permits long and large simulations. The model shows excellent reproduction of the phas…
▽ More
The hydrogen phase diagram has a number of unusual features which are generally well reproduced by density functional calculations. Unfortunately, these calculations fail to provide good physical insights into why those features occur. In this paper, we parameterize a model potential for molecular hydrogen which permits long and large simulations. The model shows excellent reproduction of the phase diagram, including the broken-symmetry Phase II, an efficiently-packed phase III and the maximum in the melt curve. It also gives an excellent reproduction of the vibrational frequencies, including the maximum in the vibrational frequency $ν(P)$ and negative thermal expansion. By detailed study of lengthy molecular dynamics, we give intuitive explanations for observed and calculated properties. All solid structures approximate to hexagonal close packed, with symmetry broken by molecular orientation. At high pressure, Phase I shows significant short-ranged correlations between molecular orientations. The turnover in Raman frequency is due to increased coupling between neighboring molecules, rather than weakening of the bond. The liquid is denser than the close-packed solid because, at molecular separations below 2.3Å, the favoured relative orientation switches from quadrupole-energy-minimising to steric-repulsion-minimising. The latter allows molecules to get closer together, without atoms getting closer but this cannot be achieved within the constraints of a close-packed layer.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
The raman signal of a hindered rotor
Authors:
Peter I. C. Cooke,
Ioan B. Magdǎu,
Miriam Peña-Alvarez,
Veronika Afonina,
Philip Dalladay-Simpson,
Xiao-Di Liu,
Ross T. Howie,
Eugene Gregoryanz,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We present a method for calculation of Raman modes of the quantum solid phase I solid hydrogen and deuterium. We use the mean-field assumption that the quantised excitations are localized on one molecule. This is done by explicit solution of the time-dependent Schroedinger equation in an angle-dependent potential, and direct calculation of the polarisation. We show that in the free-rotor limit, th…
▽ More
We present a method for calculation of Raman modes of the quantum solid phase I solid hydrogen and deuterium. We use the mean-field assumption that the quantised excitations are localized on one molecule. This is done by explicit solution of the time-dependent Schroedinger equation in an angle-dependent potential, and direct calculation of the polarisation. We show that in the free-rotor limit, the H$_2$ and D$_2$ frequencies differ by a factor of 2, which evolves toward $\sqrt{2}$ as the modes acquire librational character due to stronger interactions. The ratio overshoots $\sqrt{2}$ if anharmonic terms weaken the harmonic potential. We also use density functional theory and molecular dynamics to calculate the E$_{2_g}$ optical phonon frequency and the Raman linewidths. The molecular dynamics shows that the molecules are not free rotors except at very low pressure and high temperature, and become like oscillators as phase II is approached. We fit the interaction strengths to experimental frequencies, but good agreement for intensities requires us to also include strong preferred-orientation and stimulated Raman effects between S$_0$(1) and S$_0$(0) contributions. The experimental Raman spectrum for phase II cannot be reproduced, showing that the mean-field assumption is invalid in that case.
△ Less
Submitted 9 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Equation of state and strength of diamond in high pressure ramp loading
Authors:
Damian C. Swift,
Olivier Heuze,
Amy Lazicki,
Sebastien Hamel,
Lorin X. Benedict,
Raymond F. Smith,
James M. McNaney,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
Diamond is used extensively as a component in high energy density experiments, but existing equation of state (EOS) models do not capture its observed response to dynamic loading. In particular, in contrast with first principles theoretical EOS models, no solid-solid phase changes have been detected, and no general-purpose EOS models match the measured ambient isotherm. We have performed density f…
▽ More
Diamond is used extensively as a component in high energy density experiments, but existing equation of state (EOS) models do not capture its observed response to dynamic loading. In particular, in contrast with first principles theoretical EOS models, no solid-solid phase changes have been detected, and no general-purpose EOS models match the measured ambient isotherm. We have performed density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the diamond phase to ~10TPa, well beyond its predicted range of thermodynamic stability, and used these results as the basis of a Mie-Greuneisen EOS. We also performed DFT calculations of the elastic moduli, and calibrated an algebraic elasticity model for use in simulations. We then estimated the flow stress of diamond by comparison with the stress-density relation measured experimentally in ramp-loading experiments. The resulting constitutive model allows us to place a constraint on the Taylor-Quinney factor (the fraction of plastic work converted to heat) from the observation that diamond does not melt on ramp compression.
△ Less
Submitted 31 August, 2021; v1 submitted 6 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Thermodynamic anomalies and three distinct liquid-liquid transitions in warm dense liquid hydrogen
Authors:
Hua Y. Geng,
Q. Wu,
Miriam Marqués,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
The properties of hydrogen at high pressure have wide implications in astrophysics and high-pressure physics. Its phase change in the liquid is variously described as a metallization, H2-dissociation, density discontinuity or plasma phase transition. It has been tacitly assumed that these phenomena coincide at a first-order liquid-liquid transition (LLT). In this work, the relevant pressure-temper…
▽ More
The properties of hydrogen at high pressure have wide implications in astrophysics and high-pressure physics. Its phase change in the liquid is variously described as a metallization, H2-dissociation, density discontinuity or plasma phase transition. It has been tacitly assumed that these phenomena coincide at a first-order liquid-liquid transition (LLT). In this work, the relevant pressure-temperature conditions are thoroughly explored with first-principles molecular dynamics. We show there is a large dependency on exchange-correlation functional and significant finite size effects. We use hysteresis in a number of measurable quantities to demonstrate a first-order transition up to a critical point, above which molecular and atomic liquids are indistinguishable. At higher temperature beyond the critical point, H2-dissociation becomes a smooth cross-over in the supercritical region that can be modelled by a pseudo-transition, where the H2-2H transformation is localized and does not cause a density discontinuity at metallization. Thermodynamic anomalies and counter-intuitive transport behavior of protons are also discovered even far beyond the critical point, making this dissociative transition highly relevant to the interior dynamics of Jovian planets. Below the critical point, simulation also reveals a dynamic H2-2H chemical equilibrium with rapid interconversion, showing that H2 and H are miscible. The predicted critical temperature lies well below the ionization temperature. Our calculations unequivocally demonstrate that there are three distinct regimes in the liquid-liquid transition of warm dense hydrogen.
△ Less
Submitted 14 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Quadrupole Arrangements and the Ground State of Solid Hydrogen
Authors:
Sebastiaan van de Bund,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
The electric quadrupole-quadrupole ($\mathcal{E}_{qq}$) interaction is believed to play an important role in the broken symmetry transition from Phase I to II in solid hydrogen. To evaluate this, we study structures adopted by purely classical quadrupoles using Markov Chain Monte Carlo simulations of fcc and hcp quadrupolar lattices. Both undergo first-order phase transitions from rotationally ord…
▽ More
The electric quadrupole-quadrupole ($\mathcal{E}_{qq}$) interaction is believed to play an important role in the broken symmetry transition from Phase I to II in solid hydrogen. To evaluate this, we study structures adopted by purely classical quadrupoles using Markov Chain Monte Carlo simulations of fcc and hcp quadrupolar lattices. Both undergo first-order phase transitions from rotationally ordered to disordered structures, as indicated by a discontinuity in both quadrupole interaction energy ($\mathcal{E}_{qq}$) and its heat capacity. Cooling fcc reliably induced a transition to the P$a3$ structure, whereas cooling hcp gave inconsistent, frustrated and $c/a$-ratio-dependent broken symmetry states. Analysing the lowest-energy hcp states using simulated annealing, we found P$6_3/m$ and P$ca2_1$ structures found previously as minimum-energy structures in full electronic structure calculations. The candidate structures for hydrogen Phases III-V were not observed. This demonstrates that $\mathcal{E}_{qq}$ is the dominant interaction determining the symmetry breaking in Phase II. The disorder transition occurs at significantly lower temperature in hcp than fcc, showing that the $\mathcal{E}_{qq}$ cannot be responsible for hydrogen Phase II being based on hcp.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Structures of solid hydrogen at 300K
Authors:
Graeme J. Ackland,
John S. Loveday
Abstract:
We present results predicting experimentally measurable structural quantities from molecular dynamics studies of hydrogen. In doing this, we propose a paradigm shift for experimentalists -- that the predictions from such calculations should be seen as the most likely hypotheses. Specifically, the experimental results should be aiming to distinguish between the candidate low-energy structures, rath…
▽ More
We present results predicting experimentally measurable structural quantities from molecular dynamics studies of hydrogen. In doing this, we propose a paradigm shift for experimentalists -- that the predictions from such calculations should be seen as the most likely hypotheses. Specifically, the experimental results should be aiming to distinguish between the candidate low-energy structures, rather than aiming to solve the simplest structure consistent with the data. We show that the room temperature X-ray diffraction patterns for hydrogen phases I, III, IV and V are very similar, with only small peaks denoting symmetry-breaking from the hcp Phase I. Because they incorporate atomic displacements the XRD patterns implied by molecular dynamics calculations are very different from those arising from the static minimum enthalpy structures found by structure searching. Simulations also show that within Phase I the molecular becomes increasingly confined to the basal plane and suggest the possibility of an unusual critical point terminating the Phase I-III boundary line.
△ Less
Submitted 11 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Equations of state for ruthenium and rhodium
Authors:
Damian C. Swift,
Thomas Lockard,
Olivier Heuze,
Mungo Frost,
Siegfried Glenzer,
Kenneth J. McClellan,
Sebastien Hamel,
John E. Klepeis,
Lorin X. Benedict,
Philip A. Sterne,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
Ru and Rh are interesting cases for comparing equations of state (EOS), because most general purpose EOS are semi-empirical, relying heavily on shock data, and none has been reported for Ru. EOS were calculated for both elements using all-electron atom-in-jellium theory, and cold compression curves were calculated for the common crystal types using the multi-ion pseudopotential approach. Previous…
▽ More
Ru and Rh are interesting cases for comparing equations of state (EOS), because most general purpose EOS are semi-empirical, relying heavily on shock data, and none has been reported for Ru. EOS were calculated for both elements using all-electron atom-in-jellium theory, and cold compression curves were calculated for the common crystal types using the multi-ion pseudopotential approach. Previous EOS constructed for these elements used Thomas-Fermi (TF) theory for the electronic behavior at high temperatures, which neglects electronic shell structure; the atom-in-jellium EOS exhibited pronounced features from the excitation of successive electron shells. Otherwise, the EOS matched surprisingly well, especially considering the lack of experimental data for Ru. The TF-based EOS for Ru may however be inaccurate in the multi-terapascal range needed for some high energy density experiments. The multi-ion calculations predicted that the hexagonal close-packed phase of Ru remains stable to at least 2.5 TPa and possibly 10 TPa, and that its c/a should gradually increase to the ideal value. A method was devised to estimate the variation in Debye temperature from the cold curve, and thus estimate the ion-thermal EOS without requiring relatively expensive dynamical force calculations, in a form convenient for adjusting EOS or phase boundaries. The Debye temperature estimated in this way was similar to the result from atom-in-jellium calculations. We also predict the high-pressure melt loci of both elements.
△ Less
Submitted 11 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
The Observed Vibron Shift in Helium-Hydrogen Mixtures are due to Quantum Nuclear and Localisation Effects, not bonding
Authors:
Sam B Ramsey,
Miriam Pena-Alvarez,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
The vibrational frequency of hydrogen molecules has been observed to increase strongly with He concentration in helium hydrogen fluid mixtures. This has been associated with He-H interactions, either directly through chemical bonding, or indirectly through increased local pressure. Here, we demonstrate that the increase in the Raman frequency of the hydrogen molecule vibron is due to the number of…
▽ More
The vibrational frequency of hydrogen molecules has been observed to increase strongly with He concentration in helium hydrogen fluid mixtures. This has been associated with He-H interactions, either directly through chemical bonding, or indirectly through increased local pressure. Here, we demonstrate that the increase in the Raman frequency of the hydrogen molecule vibron is due to the number of H$_2$ molecules participating in the mode. There is no chemical bonding between He and H$_2$, helium acts only to separate the molecules. The variety of possible environments for H$_2$ gives rise to many Raman active modes, which causes broadening the vibron band. As the Raman active modes tend to be the lower frequency vibrons, these effects work together to produce the majority of the shift seen in experiment. We used Density Functional Theory (DFT) methods in both solid and fluid phases to demonstrate this effect. DFT also reveals that the pressure in these H$_2$-He mixture is primarily due to quantum nuclear effects, again the weak chemical bonding makes it a secondary effect.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Observation of a metastable intermediate during solid-solid phase transformation in response to rapid compression
Authors:
Michael R. Armstrong,
Harry B. Radousky,
Ryan A. Austin,
Elissaios Stavrou,
Hongxiang Zong,
Graeme J. Ackland,
Shaughnessy Brown,
Jonathan C. Crowhurst,
Arianna E. Gleason,
Eduardo Granados,
Paulius Grivickas,
Nicholas Holtgrewe,
Hae Ja Lee,
Tian T. Li,
Sergey Lobanov,
Joseph T. McKeown,
Robert Nagler,
Inhyuk Nam,
Art J. Nelson,
Vitali Prakapenka,
Clemens Prescher,
John D. Roehling,
Nick E. Teslich,
Peter Walter,
Alexander F. Goncharov
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In order to probe the mechanism of solid-solid phase transformations, we have applied ultrafast shock wave compression (120 picosecond duration) and ultrashort (130 femtosecond) x-ray diffraction at the Linac Coherent Light Source (LCLS) to probe the compression-induced phase transition pathway in zirconium. Surprisingly, rather than transform from alpha-Zr to the more disordered hex-3 equilibrium…
▽ More
In order to probe the mechanism of solid-solid phase transformations, we have applied ultrafast shock wave compression (120 picosecond duration) and ultrashort (130 femtosecond) x-ray diffraction at the Linac Coherent Light Source (LCLS) to probe the compression-induced phase transition pathway in zirconium. Surprisingly, rather than transform from alpha-Zr to the more disordered hex-3 equilibrium omega-Zr phase, in its place we find the formation of a non-equilibrium body-centered cubic (bcc) metastable intermediate. Theoretically hypothesized for several decades, this bcc intermediate state has now been found to be dynamically stabilized under uniaxial loading at sub-nanosecond timescales. Molecular dynamics simulations of shock-wave propagation in zirconium predict this transformation via the dynamical intermediate state. In contrast with longer timescale experiments where the phase diagram alone is an adequate predictor of the crystalline structure of a material, our recent study highlights the importance of metastability and time-dependence in the kinetics of phase transformation at extreme conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
The Icosahedral (H$_2)_{13}$ Supermolecule
Authors:
Graeme J. Ackland,
Jack Binns,
Ross Howie,
Miguel Martinez-Canales
Abstract:
We investigate a range of possible materials containing the supermolecular form of hydrogen comprising 13 hydrogen molecules arranged in an icosahedral arrangement. This supermolecule consists of freely rotating 12 hydrogen molecules in an icosahedral arrangement, enclosing another freely rotating molecule. To date, this supermolecule has only been observed in a compound with Iodane (HI). The extr…
▽ More
We investigate a range of possible materials containing the supermolecular form of hydrogen comprising 13 hydrogen molecules arranged in an icosahedral arrangement. This supermolecule consists of freely rotating 12 hydrogen molecules in an icosahedral arrangement, enclosing another freely rotating molecule. To date, this supermolecule has only been observed in a compound with Iodane (HI). The extremely high hydrogen content suggests possible application in hydrogen storage so we examine the possibility of supermolecule formation at ambient pressures. We show that ab initio molecular dynamics calculations give a good description of the known properties of the HI(H2)13 material, and make predictions of the existence of related compounds Xe(H2)1, HBr(H2)13 and HCl(H2)13, including a symmetry-breaking phase transition at low temperature. The icosahedral (H2)13 supermolecule, remains stable in all these compounds. This suggests (H2)13 is a widespread feature in hydrogen compounds, and that appropriately-sized cavities could hold hydrogen supermolecules even at low pressure. The structure of the supermolecule network is shown to be independent of the compound at equivalent density.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
MIST: A Simple and Efficient Molecular Dynamics Abstraction Library for Integrator Development
Authors:
Iain Bethune,
Ralf Banisch,
Elena Breitmoser,
Antonia B K Collis,
Gordon Gibb,
Gianpaolo Gobbo,
Charles Matthews,
Graeme J Ackland,
Benedict J Leimkuhler
Abstract:
We present MIST, the Molecular Integration Simulation Toolkit, a lightweight and efficient software library written in C++ which provides an abstract in- terface to common molecular dynamics codes, enabling rapid and portable development of new integration schemes for molecular dynamics. The initial release provides plug-in interfaces to NAMD-Lite, GROMACS and Amber, and includes several standard…
▽ More
We present MIST, the Molecular Integration Simulation Toolkit, a lightweight and efficient software library written in C++ which provides an abstract in- terface to common molecular dynamics codes, enabling rapid and portable development of new integration schemes for molecular dynamics. The initial release provides plug-in interfaces to NAMD-Lite, GROMACS and Amber, and includes several standard integration schemes, a constraint solver, tem- perature control using Langevin Dynamics, and two tempering schemes. We describe the architecture and functionality of the library and the C and For- tran APIs which can be used to interface additional MD codes to MIST. We show, for a range of test systems, that MIST introduces negligible overheads for serial, shared-memory parallel, and GPU-accelerated cases, except for Amber where the native integrators run directly on the GPU itself. As a demonstration of the capabilities of MIST, we describe a simulated tempering simulation used to study the free energy landscape of Alanine-12 in both vacuum and detailed solvent conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2018; v1 submitted 18 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
On the Diffusion of Sticky Particles in 1D
Authors:
Joshua D M Hellier,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
The 1D Ising model is the simplest Hamiltonian-based model in statistical mechanics. The sim- plest interacting particle process is the Symmetric Exclusion Process (SEP), a 1D lattice gas of particles that hop symmetrically and cannot overlap. Combining the two gives a model for sticky particle diffusion, SPM, which is described here. SPM dynamics are based on SEP with short-range interaction, all…
▽ More
The 1D Ising model is the simplest Hamiltonian-based model in statistical mechanics. The sim- plest interacting particle process is the Symmetric Exclusion Process (SEP), a 1D lattice gas of particles that hop symmetrically and cannot overlap. Combining the two gives a model for sticky particle diffusion, SPM, which is described here. SPM dynamics are based on SEP with short-range interaction, allowing flow due to non-equilibrium boundary conditions. We prove that SPM is also a detailed-balance respecting, particle-conserving, Monte Carlo (MC) description of the Ising model. Neither the Ising model nor SEP have a phase transition in 1D, but the SPM exhibits a non-equilibrium transition from a diffusing to a blocked state as stickiness increases. This transition manifests in peaks in the MC density fluctuation, a change in the dependency of flow-rate on stickiness, and odd structure in the eigenspectrum of the transition rate matrix. We derive and solve a fully non-linear, analytic, mean-field solution, which has a crossover from a positive to a negative diffusion constant where the MC shows the transition. The negative diffusion constant in fact indicates a breakdown of the mean-field approximation, with close to zero flow and breaking into a two-phase mixture, and thus the mean field theory successfully predicts its own demise. We also present an analytic solution for the flow via direct analysis of the transition rate matrix. The simplicity of the model suggest a wide range of possible applications.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2018; v1 submitted 26 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Stability of Metallic Hydrogen at Ambient Conditions
Authors:
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
The possibility of metallic hydrogen was first mooted by Wigner and Huntington in 1935. Here it is show that the calculations from that paper are in remarkably good agreement with modern density functional theory results. The possibility that metallic hydrogen could be recovered to ambient pressure is often attributed to papers by Brovman, although in fact they only say it would be metastable with…
▽ More
The possibility of metallic hydrogen was first mooted by Wigner and Huntington in 1935. Here it is show that the calculations from that paper are in remarkably good agreement with modern density functional theory results. The possibility that metallic hydrogen could be recovered to ambient pressure is often attributed to papers by Brovman, although in fact they only say it would be metastable with undetermined lifetime. Density functional theory calculations presented here show that reasonable candidate structures for metallic hydrogen are wildly unstable at ambient conditions, and molecular dynamics calculations show that the lifetime to which Brovman et al refer is considerably less than a picosecond. It is concluded that the prospects of using recovered metallic hydrogen as rocket fuel or for electricity distribution may have been overstated.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Stacking Characteristics of Close Packed Materials
Authors:
Christian H. Loach,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
It is shown that the enthalpy of any close packed structure for a given element can be characterised as a linear expansion in a set of continuous variables $α_n$ which describe the stacking configuration. This enables us to represent the infinite, discrete set of stacking sequences within a finite, continuous space of the expansion parameters $H_n$. These $H_n$ determine the stable structure and v…
▽ More
It is shown that the enthalpy of any close packed structure for a given element can be characterised as a linear expansion in a set of continuous variables $α_n$ which describe the stacking configuration. This enables us to represent the infinite, discrete set of stacking sequences within a finite, continuous space of the expansion parameters $H_n$. These $H_n$ determine the stable structure and vary continuously in the thermodynamic space of pressure, temperature or composition. The continuity of both spaces means that only transformations between stable structures adjacent in the $H_n$ space are possible, giving the model predictive and well as descriptive ability. We calculate the $H_n$ using density functional theory and interatomic potentials for a range of materials. Some striking results are found: e.g. the Lennard-Jones potential model has 11 possible stable structures and over 50 phase transitions as a function of cutoff range. The very different phase diagrams of Sc, Tl, Y and the lanthanides are understood within a single theory. We find that the widely-reported 9R-fcc transition is not allowed in equilibrium thermodynamics, and in cases where it has been reported in experiments (Li, Na), we show that DFT theory is also unable to predict it.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Origin of the abnormal diffusion of transition metal in rutile
Authors:
Linggang Zhu,
Graeme J. Ackland,
Qing-Miao Hu,
Jian Zhou,
Zhimei Sun
Abstract:
Diffusion of dopants in rutile is the fundamental process that determines the performance of many devices in which rutile is used. The diffusion behavior is known to be highly sample-dependent, but the reasons for this are less well understood. Here, rutile is studied by using first-principles calculations, in order to unravel the microscopic origins of the diverse diffusion behaviors for differen…
▽ More
Diffusion of dopants in rutile is the fundamental process that determines the performance of many devices in which rutile is used. The diffusion behavior is known to be highly sample-dependent, but the reasons for this are less well understood. Here, rutile is studied by using first-principles calculations, in order to unravel the microscopic origins of the diverse diffusion behaviors for different do** elements. Anomalous diffusion behavior in the open channel along [001] direction is found: larger atoms include Sc and Zr have lower energy barrier for diffusion via interstitial mechanism, apparently contradicting their known slow diffusion rate. To resolve this, we present an alternate model for the overall diffusion rate of the large-size dopants in rutile, showing that parallel to the [001] channel, it is limited by the formation of the interstitial states, whereas in the direction perpendicular to [001], it proceeds via a kick-out mechanism. By contrast, Co and Ni, prefer to stay in the interstitial site of rutile, and have conventional diffusion with a very small migration barrier in the [001] channel. This leads to highly anisotropic and fast diffusion. The diffusion mechanisms found in the present study can explain the diffusion data measured by experiments, and these findings provide novel understanding for the classic diffusion topic.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
The role of van der Waals and exchange interactions in high-pressure solid hydrogen
Authors:
Sam Azadi,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We investigate the van der Waals interactions in solid molecular hydrogen structures. We calculate enthalpy and the Gibbs free energy to obtain zero and finite temperature phase diagrams, respectively. We employ density functional theory (DFT) to calculate the electronic structure and Density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) with van der Waals (vdW) functionals to obtain phonon spectra. We fo…
▽ More
We investigate the van der Waals interactions in solid molecular hydrogen structures. We calculate enthalpy and the Gibbs free energy to obtain zero and finite temperature phase diagrams, respectively. We employ density functional theory (DFT) to calculate the electronic structure and Density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) with van der Waals (vdW) functionals to obtain phonon spectra. We focus on the solid molecular $C2/c$, $Cmca$-12, $P6_3/m$, $Cmca$, and $Pbcn$ structures within the pressure range of 200 $<$ P $<$ 450 GPa. We propose two structures of the $C2/c$ and $Pbcn$ for phase III which are stabilized within different pressure range above 200 GPa. We find that vdW functionals have a big effect on vibrations and finite-temperature phase stability, however, different vdW functionals have different effects. We conclude that, in addition to the vdW interaction, a correct treatment of the high charge gradient limit is essential. We show that the dependence of molecular bond-lengths on exchange-correlation also has a considerable influence on the calculated metallization pressure, introducing errors of up to 100GPa.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
A simple thermodynamic model for the hydrogen phase diagram
Authors:
Ioan B Magdău,
Miriam Marques,
Balint Borgulya,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
We describe a classical thermodynamic model that reproduces the main features of the solid hydrogen phase diagram. In particular, we show how the general structure types that are found by electronic structure calculations and the quantum nature of the protons can also be understood from a classical viewpoint. The model provides a picture not only of crystal structure, but also for the anomalous me…
▽ More
We describe a classical thermodynamic model that reproduces the main features of the solid hydrogen phase diagram. In particular, we show how the general structure types that are found by electronic structure calculations and the quantum nature of the protons can also be understood from a classical viewpoint. The model provides a picture not only of crystal structure, but also for the anomalous melting curve and insights into isotope effects, liquid metallisation and InfraRed activity. The existence of a classical picture for this most quantum of condensed matter systems provides a surprising extension of the correspondence principle of quantum mechanics, in particular the equivalent effects of classical and quantum uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Development of an Interatomic Potential for the Simulation of Defects, Plasticity and Phase Transformations in Titanium
Authors:
M. I. Mendelev,
T. L. Underwood,
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
New interatomic potentials describing defects, plasticity and high temperature phase transitions for Ti are presented. Fitting the martensitic hcp-bcc phase transformation temperature requires an efficient and accurate method to determine it. We apply a molecular dynamics (MD) method based on determination of the melting temperature of competing solid phases, and Gibbs-Helmholtz integration, and a…
▽ More
New interatomic potentials describing defects, plasticity and high temperature phase transitions for Ti are presented. Fitting the martensitic hcp-bcc phase transformation temperature requires an efficient and accurate method to determine it. We apply a molecular dynamics (MD) method based on determination of the melting temperature of competing solid phases, and Gibbs-Helmholtz integration, and a lattice-switch Monte Carlo method (LSMC): these agree on the hcp-bcc transformation temperatures to within 2 K. We were able to develop embedded atom potentials which give a good fit to either low or high temperature data, but not both. The first developed potential (Ti1) reproduces the hcp-bcc transformation and melting temperatures and is suitable for the simulation of phase transitions and bcc Ti. Two other potentials (Ti2 and Ti3) correctly describe defect properties, and can be used to simulate plasticity or radiation damage in hcp Ti. The fact that a single EAM potential cannot describe both low and high temperature phases may be attributed to neglect of electronic degrees of freedom, notably bcc has a much higher electronic entropy. A temperature-dependent potential obtained from the combination of potentials Ti1 and Ti2 may be used to simulate Ti properties at any temperature.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2016;
originally announced December 2016.
-
Monteswitch: A package for evaluating solid-solid free energy differences via lattice-switch Monte Carlo
Authors:
T. L. Underwood,
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
Lattice-switch Monte Carlo (LSMC) is a method for evaluating the free energy between two given solid phases. LSMC is a general method, being applicable to a wide range of problems and interatomic potentials. Furthermore it is extremely efficient, ostensibly more efficient than other existing general methods. Here we introduce a package, monteswitch, which can be used to perform LSMC simulations. T…
▽ More
Lattice-switch Monte Carlo (LSMC) is a method for evaluating the free energy between two given solid phases. LSMC is a general method, being applicable to a wide range of problems and interatomic potentials. Furthermore it is extremely efficient, ostensibly more efficient than other existing general methods. Here we introduce a package, monteswitch, which can be used to perform LSMC simulations. The package can be used to evaluate the free energy differences between pairs of solid phases, including multicomponent phases, via LSMC for atomic (i.e., non-molecular) systems in the NVT and NPT ensembles. It could also be used to evaluate the free energy cost associated with interfaces and defects. Regarding interatomic potentials, monteswitch currently supports various commonly-used pair potentials, including the hard-sphere, Lennard-Jones, and Morse potentials, as well as the embedded atom model. However the main strength of the package is its versatility: it is designed so that users can easily implement their own potentials.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Rapid Equilibration by algorithmic quenching the ringing mode in molecular dynamics
Authors:
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
Long wavelength acoustic phonons are normally weakly coupled to other vibrational modes in a crystalline system. This is particularly problematic in molecular dynamics calculations where vibrations at the system size scale are typically excited at initiation. The equilibration time for these vibrations depends on the strength of coupling to other modes, so is typically very long. A very simple det…
▽ More
Long wavelength acoustic phonons are normally weakly coupled to other vibrational modes in a crystalline system. This is particularly problematic in molecular dynamics calculations where vibrations at the system size scale are typically excited at initiation. The equilibration time for these vibrations depends on the strength of coupling to other modes, so is typically very long. A very simple deterministic method which avoids the use of is presented which removes this problem.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Infrared Peak-Splitting from phonon localization in Solid Hydrogen
Authors:
Ioan B. Magdău,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We show that the isotope effect leads to a completely different spectroscopic signal in hydrogen-deuterium mixtures, compared to pure elements that have the same crystal structure. This is particularly true for molecular vibrations, which are the main source of information about the structure of high-pressure hydrogen. Mass disorder breaks translational symmetry, meaning that vibrations are locali…
▽ More
We show that the isotope effect leads to a completely different spectroscopic signal in hydrogen-deuterium mixtures, compared to pure elements that have the same crystal structure. This is particularly true for molecular vibrations, which are the main source of information about the structure of high-pressure hydrogen. Mass disorder breaks translational symmetry, meaning that vibrations are localized almost to single molecules, and are not zone-center phonons. In mixtures, each observable IR peak corresponds to a collection of many such molecular vibrations, which have a distribution of frequencies depending on local environment. Furthermore discrete groups of environments cause the peaks to split. We illustrate this issue by considering the IR spectrum of the high pressure Phase III structure of hydrogen, recently interpreted as showing novel phases in isotopic mixtures. We calculate the IR spectrum of hydrogen/deuterium mixtures in the $C2/c$ and $Cmca$-12 structures, showing that isotopic disorder gives rise to mode localization of the high frequency vibrons. The local coordination of the molecules leads to discrete IR peaks. The spread of frequencies is strongly enhanced with pressure, such that more peaks become resolvable at higher pressures, in agreement with the recent measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2017; v1 submitted 6 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
Appraisal of the realistic accuracy of Molecular dynamics of high pressure hydrogen
Authors:
Graeme J Ackland,
Ioan B Magdău
Abstract:
Molecular dynamics is a powerful method for studying the behaviour of materials at high temperature. In practice, however, its effectiveness in representing real systems is limited by the accuracy of the forces, finite size effects, quantization, and equilibration methods. In this paper we report and discuss some calculations carried out using molecular dynamics on high pressure hydrogen, reviewin…
▽ More
Molecular dynamics is a powerful method for studying the behaviour of materials at high temperature. In practice, however, its effectiveness in representing real systems is limited by the accuracy of the forces, finite size effects, quantization, and equilibration methods. In this paper we report and discuss some calculations carried out using molecular dynamics on high pressure hydrogen, reviewing a number of sources of error. We find that the neglect of zero-point vibrations is quantitively the largest. We show that simulations using ab initio molecular dynamics with the PBE functional predict a large stability field for the molecular Cmca-4 structure at pressures just above those achieved in current experiments above the stability range of the mixed- molecular layered Phase IV. However, the various errors in the simulation all point towards a much smaller stability range, and the likelihood of a non-molecular phase based on low-coordination networks or chains of atoms.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
Shear Melting and High Temperature Embrittlement: Theory and Application to Machining Titanium
Authors:
Graeme J Ackland,
Con Healy,
Sascha Koch,
Florian Brunke,
Carsten Siemers
Abstract:
We show that alloying with rare earth metals (REMs) can dramatically improve the machineability of a range of titanium alloys, even though the REM is not incorporated in the alloy matrix. The mechanism for this is that under cutting, shear bands are formed within which the nano-precipitates of REM are shear mixed. This lowers the melting point such that the mechanism of deformation changes from di…
▽ More
We show that alloying with rare earth metals (REMs) can dramatically improve the machineability of a range of titanium alloys, even though the REM is not incorporated in the alloy matrix. The mechanism for this is that under cutting, shear bands are formed within which the nano-precipitates of REM are shear mixed. This lowers the melting point such that the mechanism of deformation changes from dislocation mechanism to localised amorphisation and shear softening. The material then fractures along the thin, amorphous shear-band. Outside the shear band, the REM remains as precipitates. The new alloys have similar mechanical properties and biocompatibility to conventional materials.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
-
Relating melting trends and elasticity in simple metals: an empirical potential approach
Authors:
Alan Nichol,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We demonstrate that the melting points and other thermodynamic quantities of the alkali metals can be calculated based on static crystalline properties. To do this we derive analytic interatomic potentials for the alkali metals fitted precisely to cohesive and vacancy energies, elastic moduli, lattice parameter and crystal stability. These potentials are then used to calculate melting points by si…
▽ More
We demonstrate that the melting points and other thermodynamic quantities of the alkali metals can be calculated based on static crystalline properties. To do this we derive analytic interatomic potentials for the alkali metals fitted precisely to cohesive and vacancy energies, elastic moduli, lattice parameter and crystal stability. These potentials are then used to calculate melting points by simulating the equilibration of solid and liquid samples in thermal contact at ambient pressure. With the exception of lithium, remarkably good agreement is found with experimental values. The instability of the bcc structure in Li and Na at low temperatures is also reproduced, and, unusually, is not due to a soft T1N phonon mode. No forces or finite temperature properties are included in the fit, so this demonstrates a surprisingly high level of intrinsic transferrability in the simple potentials. Currently, there are few potentials available for the alkali metals, so in, addition to demonstrating trends in behaviour, we expect that the potentials will be of broad general use.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2016; v1 submitted 25 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Theory of high pressure hydrogen, made simple
Authors:
Ioan B Magdau,
Floris Balm,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
Phase I of hydrogen has several peculiarities. Despite having a close-packed crystal structure, it is less dense than either the low temperature Phase II or the liquid phase. At high pressure, it transforms into either phase III or IV, depending on the temperature. Moreover, spectroscopy suggests that the quantum rotor behaviour disappears with pressurisation, without any apparent phase transition…
▽ More
Phase I of hydrogen has several peculiarities. Despite having a close-packed crystal structure, it is less dense than either the low temperature Phase II or the liquid phase. At high pressure, it transforms into either phase III or IV, depending on the temperature. Moreover, spectroscopy suggests that the quantum rotor behaviour disappears with pressurisation, without any apparent phase transition. Here we present a simple thermodynamic model for this behaviour based on packing atoms and molecules and discuss the thermodynamics of the phase boundaries. We also report first principles molecular dynamics calculations for a more detailed look at the same phase transitions.
△ Less
Submitted 30 November, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Charge density wave in hydrogen at high pressure
Authors:
Ioan B. Magdau,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We present extensive molecular dynamics (MD) simulations investigating numerous candidate crystal structures for hydrogen in conditions around the present experimental frontier (400GPa). Spontaneous phase transitions in the simulations reveal a new structure candidate comprising twofold coordinated chains of hydrogen atoms. We explain the electronic structure of this phase in terms of a charge den…
▽ More
We present extensive molecular dynamics (MD) simulations investigating numerous candidate crystal structures for hydrogen in conditions around the present experimental frontier (400GPa). Spontaneous phase transitions in the simulations reveal a new structure candidate comprising twofold coordinated chains of hydrogen atoms. We explain the electronic structure of this phase in terms of a charge density wave and calculate its experimental signature. In detailed tests of the accuracy of our calculation, we find that k-point sampling is far more important in MD than in static calculations, because of the freedom it give the atoms to rearrange themselves optimally for the given sampling.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Shear melting and high temperature embrittlement: theory and application to machining titanium
Authors:
Con Healy,
Sascha Koch,
Carsten Siemers,
Debashis Mukherji,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
We describe a dynamical phase transition occurring within a shear band at high temperature and under extremely high shear rates. With increasing temperature, dislocation deformation and grain boundary sliding is supplanted by amorphization in a highly localized nanoscale band, which allows massive strain and fracture. The mechanism is similar to shear melting and leads to liquid metal embrittlemen…
▽ More
We describe a dynamical phase transition occurring within a shear band at high temperature and under extremely high shear rates. With increasing temperature, dislocation deformation and grain boundary sliding is supplanted by amorphization in a highly localized nanoscale band, which allows massive strain and fracture. The mechanism is similar to shear melting and leads to liquid metal embrittlement at high temperature. From simulation, we find that the necessary conditions are, lack of dislocation slip systems, low thermal conduction and temperature near the melting point. The first two are exhibited by bcc titanium alloys, and we show that the final one can be achieved experimentally by adding low-melting point elements: specifically we use insoluble rare earth metals (REMs). Under high shear, the REM becomes mixed with the titanium, lowering the melting point within the shear band and triggering the shear-melting transition. This in turn generates heat which remains localized in the shear band due to poor heat conduction. The material fractures along the shear band. We show how to utilize this transition in the creation of new titanium-based alloys with improved machinability.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
Lattice-switch Monte Carlo: the fcc-bcc problem
Authors:
T. L. Underwood,
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
Lattice-switch Monte Carlo is an efficient method for calculating the free energy difference between two solid phases, or a solid and a fluid phase. Here, we provide a brief introduction to the method, and list its applications since its inception. We then describe a lattice switch for the fcc and bcc phases based on the Bain orientation relationship. Finally, we present preliminary results regard…
▽ More
Lattice-switch Monte Carlo is an efficient method for calculating the free energy difference between two solid phases, or a solid and a fluid phase. Here, we provide a brief introduction to the method, and list its applications since its inception. We then describe a lattice switch for the fcc and bcc phases based on the Bain orientation relationship. Finally, we present preliminary results regarding our application of the method to the fcc and bcc phases in the Lennard-Jones system. Our initial calculations reveal that the bcc phase is unstable, quickly degenerating into some as yet undetermined metastable solid phase. This renders conventional lattice-switch Monte Carlo intractable for this phase. Possible solutions to this problem are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 16 December, 2014; v1 submitted 3 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
MD Simulations of Compression of Nanoscale Iron Pillars
Authors:
Con J. Healy,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
It is now possible to create perfect crystal nanowires of many metals. The deformation of such objects requires a good understanding of the processes involved in plasticity at the nanoscale. Isotropic compression of such nanometre scale micropillars is a good model system to understand the plasticity. Here we investigate these phenomena using Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of nanometre scale…
▽ More
It is now possible to create perfect crystal nanowires of many metals. The deformation of such objects requires a good understanding of the processes involved in plasticity at the nanoscale. Isotropic compression of such nanometre scale micropillars is a good model system to understand the plasticity. Here we investigate these phenomena using Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations of nanometre scale single crystal BCC iron pillars in compression.
We find that pillars with large length to width ratio may buckle under high strain rates. The type of buckling behaviour depends sensitively on the boundary conditions used: periodic boundary conditions allow for rotation at top and bottom of the pillar, and result in an S shaped buckle, by contrast fixed boundaries enforce a C shape. Pillars with a length to width ratio closer to that used in experimental micropillar compression studies show deformation behaviour dominated by slip, in agreement with the experiments. For micropillars oriented along <100>, slip occurs on <110> planes and localized slip bands are formed. Pillars of this size experience higher stresses than bulk materials before yielding takes place. One might expect that this may be in part due to the lack of nucleation sites needed to induce slip. However, further simulations with possible dislocation sources: a shorter iron pillar containing a spherical grain boundary, and a similar pillar containing jagged edges did not show a decreased yield strength.
△ Less
Submitted 29 September, 2014;
originally announced September 2014.
-
Efficacious calculation of Raman spectra in high pressure hydrogen
Authors:
G. J. Ackland,
I. B. Magdau
Abstract:
We present and evaluate an efficient method for simulating Raman spectra from molecular dynamics (MD) calculations {\it without} defining normal modes. We apply the method to high pressure hydrogen in the high-temperature "Phase IV": a plastic crystal in which the conventional picture of fixed phonon eigenmodes breaks down.
Projecting trajectories onto in-phase molecular stretches is shown to be…
▽ More
We present and evaluate an efficient method for simulating Raman spectra from molecular dynamics (MD) calculations {\it without} defining normal modes. We apply the method to high pressure hydrogen in the high-temperature "Phase IV": a plastic crystal in which the conventional picture of fixed phonon eigenmodes breaks down.
Projecting trajectories onto in-phase molecular stretches is shown to be many orders of magnitude faster than polarisability calculations, allowing statistical averaging at high-temperature.
The simulations are extended into metastable regimes and identify several regimes associated with symmetry-breaking on different timescales, which are shown to exhibit features in the Raman spectra at the current experimental limit of resolvability. In this paper we have concentrated on the methodology, a fuller description of the structure of Phase IV hydrogen is given in a previous paper
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2014;
originally announced August 2014.
-
Transition metal solute interactions with point defects in austenitic iron from first principles
Authors:
D. J. Hepburn,
E. MacLeod,
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
We present a comprehensive set of first principles electronic structure calculations to study transition metal solutes and their interactions with point defects in austenite. Clear trends were observed across the series. Solute-defect interactions were strongly correlated to the solute size factors, consistent with local strain field effects. Strong correlations with results in ferrite show insens…
▽ More
We present a comprehensive set of first principles electronic structure calculations to study transition metal solutes and their interactions with point defects in austenite. Clear trends were observed across the series. Solute-defect interactions were strongly correlated to the solute size factors, consistent with local strain field effects. Strong correlations with results in ferrite show insensitivity to the underlying crystal structure in Fe. Oversized solutes act as strong traps for vacancy and self-interstitial defects and as nucleation sites for the development of proto-voids and small self-interstitial loops. The reduction in defect mobility and net defect concentrations explains the observed radiation-damage resistance in austenitic steels doped with oversized solutes. Oversized solutes remaining dissolved in oxide dispersion-strengthened (ODS) steels could contribute to their radiation-damage resistance. Ni and Co diffuse more slowly than Fe, along with any vacancy flux produced under irradiation below a critical temperature, which is 400 K for Co and their concentrations should be enhanced at defect sinks. Cr and Cu diffuse more quickly than Fe, against a vacancy flux and will be depleted at defect sinks. Oversized solutes early in the transition metal series form highly-stable solute-centred divacancy (SCD) defects with a nearest-neighbour vacancy. The vacancy-mediated diffusion of these solutes is dominated by the dissociation and reassociation of the SCDs, with a lower activation energy than for self-diffusion, which has important implications for the nucleation and growth of complex oxide nanoparticles containing these solutes in ODS steels. Interstitial-mediated solute diffusion is energetically disfavoured for all except Cr, Mn, Co and Ni. The central role that solute size plays in the results presented here means they should apply to other solvent metals and alloys.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Probing atomic environments in alloys by electron spectroscopy
Authors:
T. L. Underwood,
G. J. Ackland,
R. J. Cole
Abstract:
In alloys exhibiting substitutional disorder, the variety of atomic environments manifests itself as a `disorder broadening' in their core level binding energy spectra. Disorder broadening can be measured experimentally, and in principle can be used to deduce information about specific atomic environments within a sample. However, progress in this endeavor is hampered by the lack of a model for th…
▽ More
In alloys exhibiting substitutional disorder, the variety of atomic environments manifests itself as a `disorder broadening' in their core level binding energy spectra. Disorder broadening can be measured experimentally, and in principle can be used to deduce information about specific atomic environments within a sample. However, progress in this endeavor is hampered by the lack of a model for this phenomenon which can treat complex systems. In this work we describe such a model. The model is used to elucidate the relationship between charge transfer, atomic environment, and disorder broadening in complex systems, with a focus on the problem of characterizing the interface quality of CuNi multilayers. We also validate the model against the results of ab initio electronic structure calculations. Several counterintuitive aspects of the disorder broadening phenomenon are uncovered, an understanding of which is essential for the correct interpretation of experimental results. For instance, it is shown that systems with inhomogeneous concentration profiles can exhibit disorder broadenings significantly larger than random alloys. Furthermore in some systems a `disorder narrowing' is even possible.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2014; v1 submitted 10 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Mechanism for Radiation Damage Resistance in Yttrium Oxide Dispersion Strengthened Steels
Authors:
J. Brodrick,
D. J. Hepburn,
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
ODS steels based on yttrium oxide have been suggested as potential fusion reactor wall materials due to their observed radiation resistance properties. Presumably this radiation resistance can be related to the interaction of the particle with vacancies,self-interstitial atoms (SIAs) and other radiation damage debris. Density functional theory has been used to investigate this at the atomic scale.…
▽ More
ODS steels based on yttrium oxide have been suggested as potential fusion reactor wall materials due to their observed radiation resistance properties. Presumably this radiation resistance can be related to the interaction of the particle with vacancies,self-interstitial atoms (SIAs) and other radiation damage debris. Density functional theory has been used to investigate this at the atomic scale. Four distinct interfaces, some based on HRTEM observations, between iron and yttrium oxide were investigated. It is been shown that the Y$_2$O$_3$-Fe interface acts as a strong trap with long-range attraction for both interstitial and vacancy defects, allowing recombination without altering the interface structure. The catalytic elimination of defects without change to the microstructure explains the improved behaviour of ODS steels with respect to radiation creep and swelling.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
High Temperature Raman analysis of Hydrogen Phase IV from Molecular Dynamics
Authors:
Ioan B Magdău,
Graeme J Ackland
Abstract:
We extend our previous studies on phase IV of solid hydrogen by employing larger cells and k-sampling. We show that uncorrelated hexagonal rotations in the weakly bounded G"-layers are needed to account for the experimentally measured Raman spectrum. In large simulations we find no evidence of proton diffusion or layer fluctuations, which we believe are the result of finite size effects. In calcul…
▽ More
We extend our previous studies on phase IV of solid hydrogen by employing larger cells and k-sampling. We show that uncorrelated hexagonal rotations in the weakly bounded G"-layers are needed to account for the experimentally measured Raman spectrum. In large simulations we find no evidence of proton diffusion or layer fluctuations, which we believe are the result of finite size effects. In calculations at higher pressures (above 400 GPa) we identify a new possible candidate for phase IV. We, finally, proposed a revised phase diagram based on our previous and present results.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Simulating Raman Spectra using molecular dynamics, and identification of high-pressure phases III and IV in hydrogen
Authors:
Ioan B. Magdau,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We present a technique for extracting Raman intensities from ab initio molecular dynamics (MD) simulations at high temperature. The method is applied to the highly anharmonic case of dense hydrogen up to 500 K for pressures ranging from 180 GPa to 300 GPa. On heating or pressurizing we find first-order phase transitions at the experimental conditions of the phase III - IV boundary. Direct comparis…
▽ More
We present a technique for extracting Raman intensities from ab initio molecular dynamics (MD) simulations at high temperature. The method is applied to the highly anharmonic case of dense hydrogen up to 500 K for pressures ranging from 180 GPa to 300 GPa. On heating or pressurizing we find first-order phase transitions at the experimental conditions of the phase III - IV boundary. Direct comparison of Raman vibrons with experiment provides excellent discrimination between subtly different structures, found in MD. We find candidate structures whose Raman spectra are in good agreement with experiment. The new phase obtained in high temperature simulations adopts a dynamic, simple hexagonal structure with three layer types: freely rotating hydrogen molecules, static hexagonal trimers and rotating hexagonal trimers. We show that previously calculated structures for phase IV are inconsistent with experiment, and their appearance in simulation is due to finite size effects.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
First principles study of helium, carbon and nitrogen in austenite, dilute austenitic iron alloys and nickel
Authors:
D. J. Hepburn,
D. Ferguson,
S. Gardner,
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
An extensive set of first-principles density functional theory calculations have been performed to study the behaviour of He, C and N solutes in austenite, dilute Fe-Cr-Ni austenitic alloys and Ni in order to investigate their influence on the microstructural evolution of austenitic steel alloys under irradiation.
An extensive set of first-principles density functional theory calculations have been performed to study the behaviour of He, C and N solutes in austenite, dilute Fe-Cr-Ni austenitic alloys and Ni in order to investigate their influence on the microstructural evolution of austenitic steel alloys under irradiation.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2013;
originally announced January 2013.
-
Binding of an oxide layer to a metal: the case of Ti(10-10)/TiO2(100)
Authors:
Linggang Zhu,
Graeme J. Ackland
Abstract:
We study the chemical nature of the bonding of an oxide layer to the parent metal. In order to disentangle chemical effects from strain/misfit, Ti(10$\bar{1}$0)/TiO$_{2}$(100) interface has been chosen. We use the density functional pseudopotential method which gives good agreement with experiment for known properties of bulk and surface Ti and TiO$_2$. Two geometries, a film-like model (with free…
▽ More
We study the chemical nature of the bonding of an oxide layer to the parent metal. In order to disentangle chemical effects from strain/misfit, Ti(10$\bar{1}$0)/TiO$_{2}$(100) interface has been chosen. We use the density functional pseudopotential method which gives good agreement with experiment for known properties of bulk and surface Ti and TiO$_2$. Two geometries, a film-like model (with free surface in the structure) and a bulk-like model (with no free surface in the structure) are used to simulate the interface, in each case with different terminations of Ti and TiO$_2$. For the single-oxygen interfaces, the interface energy obtained using these two models agree with each other; however for the double-oxygen ones, the relative stability is quite different. The disturbance to the electronic structure is confined within a few atomic layers of the interface. The interfacial bonding is mainly ionic, and surprisingly there is more charge transfer from Ti to O in the interface than in the bulk. In consequence the Ti/TiO$_2$ interface has stronger binding than the bulk of either material. This helps to explain why the oxide forms a stable, protective layer on Ti and Ti alloys.
△ Less
Submitted 7 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.
-
Molecular Dynamics and OKMC Study of Radiation Induced Motion of Voids and He Bubbles in BCC Iron
Authors:
G. J. Galloway,
G. J. Ackland
Abstract:
We show that voids adjacent to radiation damage cascades can be moved in their entirety by several lattice spacings. This is done using molecular dynamics cascade simulations in iron at energies of 1-5 keV. The effect of this mechanism is studied further using an OKMC code and shows enhancement of void diffusion by 2 orders of magnitude from 1x10^-22 cm^2/s to 3x10^-20 cm^2/s. Repeating the study…
▽ More
We show that voids adjacent to radiation damage cascades can be moved in their entirety by several lattice spacings. This is done using molecular dynamics cascade simulations in iron at energies of 1-5 keV. The effect of this mechanism is studied further using an OKMC code and shows enhancement of void diffusion by 2 orders of magnitude from 1x10^-22 cm^2/s to 3x10^-20 cm^2/s. Repeating the study on He bubbles shows that the movement is damped by the presence of helium in the void.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2013; v1 submitted 7 December, 2012;
originally announced December 2012.