-
ZIJI: a model to calculate X-ray spectra of black hole X-ray binaries
Authors:
Temurbek Mirzaev,
Cosimo Bambi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Jiachen Jiang,
Honghui Liu,
Shafqat Riaz,
Swarnim Shashank
Abstract:
In the disk-corona model, the X-ray spectrum of a stellar-mass black hole in an X-ray binary is characterized by three components: a thermal component from a thin and cold accretion disk, a Comptonized component from a hot corona, and a reflection component produced by illumination of the cold disk by the hot corona. In this paper, we present ZIJI, which is a model to calculate the X-ray spectrum…
▽ More
In the disk-corona model, the X-ray spectrum of a stellar-mass black hole in an X-ray binary is characterized by three components: a thermal component from a thin and cold accretion disk, a Comptonized component from a hot corona, and a reflection component produced by illumination of the cold disk by the hot corona. In this paper, we present ZIJI, which is a model to calculate the X-ray spectrum of black hole X-ray binaries in the disk-corona model. The accretion disk is described by the Novikov-Thorne model. The reflection spectrum is produced by the direct radiation from the corona as well as by the returning radiation of the thermal and reflection components and is calculated considering the actual spectrum illuminating the disk. If we turn the corona off, the reflection spectrum is completely generated by the returning radiation of the thermal component, as it may happen for some sources in soft spectral states. The user decides the radial density profile of the accretion disk and the ionization parameter is calculated self-consistently at any radial coordinate of the disk from the illuminating X-ray flux and the local electron density. We show the predictions of ZIJI in different regimes. We discuss current limitations of our model as well as the next steps to improve it.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Towards more accurate synthetic reflection spectra: improving the calculations of returning radiation
Authors:
Temurbek Mirzaev,
Shafqat Riaz,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Jiachen Jiang,
Honghui Liu,
Swarnim Shashank
Abstract:
We present a new model to calculate reflection spectra of thin accretion disks in Kerr spacetimes. Our model includes the effect of returning radiation, which is the radiation that is emitted by the disk and returns to the disk because of the strong light bending near a black hole. The major improvement with respect to the existing models is that it calculates the reflection spectrum at every poin…
▽ More
We present a new model to calculate reflection spectra of thin accretion disks in Kerr spacetimes. Our model includes the effect of returning radiation, which is the radiation that is emitted by the disk and returns to the disk because of the strong light bending near a black hole. The major improvement with respect to the existing models is that it calculates the reflection spectrum at every point on the disk by using the actual spectrum of the incident radiation. Assuming a lamppost coronal geometry, we simulate simultaneous observations of NICER and NuSTAR of bright Galactic black holes and we fit the simulated data with the latest version of RELXILL (modified to read the table of REFLIONX, which is the non-relativistic reflection model used in our calculations). We find that RELXILL with returning radiation cannot fit well the simulated data when the black hole spin parameter is very high and the coronal height and disk's ionization parameter are low, and some parameters can be significantly overestimated or underestimated. We can find better fits and recover the correct input parameters as the value of the black hole spin parameter decreases and the value of the coronal height increases.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024; v1 submitted 10 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Testing General Relativity with Black Hole X-Ray Data and ABHModels
Authors:
Cosimo Bambi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Honghui Liu,
Shafqat Riaz,
Swarnim Shashank,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
The past 10 years have seen tremendous progress in our capability of testing General Relativity in the strong field regime with black hole observations. 10 years ago, the theory of General Relativity was almost completely unexplored in the strong field regime. Today, we have gravitational wave data of the coalescence of stellar-mass black holes, radio images of the supermassive black holes SgrA…
▽ More
The past 10 years have seen tremendous progress in our capability of testing General Relativity in the strong field regime with black hole observations. 10 years ago, the theory of General Relativity was almost completely unexplored in the strong field regime. Today, we have gravitational wave data of the coalescence of stellar-mass black holes, radio images of the supermassive black holes SgrA$^*$ and M87$^*$, and high-quality X-ray data of stellar-mass black holes in X-ray binaries and supermassive black holes in active galactic nuclei. In this manuscript, we will review current efforts to test General Relativity with black hole X-ray data and we will provide a detailed description of the public codes available on ABHModels.
△ Less
Submitted 23 April, 2024; v1 submitted 24 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Testing Regular Black Holes with X-ray data of GX~339--4
Authors:
Shafqat Riaz,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
Regular black holes are singularity-free black hole spacetimes proposed to solve the problem of the presence of spacetime singularities that plagues the black holes of general relativity and most theories of gravity. In this work, we consider the regular black holes recently proposed by Mazza, Franzin \& Liberati and we extend previous studies to get a more stringent observational constraint on th…
▽ More
Regular black holes are singularity-free black hole spacetimes proposed to solve the problem of the presence of spacetime singularities that plagues the black holes of general relativity and most theories of gravity. In this work, we consider the regular black holes recently proposed by Mazza, Franzin \& Liberati and we extend previous studies to get a more stringent observational constraint on the regularization parameter $l$. We study simultaneous observations of \textit{NuSTAR} and \textit{Swift} of the Galactic black hole in GX~339--4 during its outburst in 2015. The quality of the \textit{NuSTAR} data is exceptionally good and the spectrum of the source presents both a strong thermal component and prominent relativistically blurred reflection features. This permits us to measure the regularization parameter $l$ from the simultaneous analysis of the thermal spectrum and the reflection features. From our analysis, we find the constraint $l/M < 0.39$ (90\% CL), which is stronger than previous constraints inferred with X-ray and gravitational wave data.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Impact of the returning radiation in current tests of the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Shafqat Riaz,
Temurbek Mirzaev,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
The past 10 years have seen remarkable progress in our capability of analyzing reflection features in the X-ray spectra of accreting black holes. Today X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a mature technique and a powerful tool for studying the accretion process around black holes, measuring black hole spins, and testing Einstein's theory of General Relativity in the strong field regime. However, curr…
▽ More
The past 10 years have seen remarkable progress in our capability of analyzing reflection features in the X-ray spectra of accreting black holes. Today X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a mature technique and a powerful tool for studying the accretion process around black holes, measuring black hole spins, and testing Einstein's theory of General Relativity in the strong field regime. However, current reflection models still rely on a number of simplifications and caution is necessary when we derive very precise measurements. In this paper, we study the impact of the returning radiation on our capability of measuring the properties of black holes using X-ray reflection spectroscopy, and in particular on our capability of testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis. While the returning radiation alters the reflection spectrum of the disk, from the analysis of our simulations we find that models without returning radiation can normally recover well the correct black hole spin parameters and can test the Kerr metric. Our study thus confirms that current tests of the Kerr hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy can be robust.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2023; v1 submitted 22 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Testing the $δ$-Kerr metric with black hole X-ray data
Authors:
Jiahao Tao,
Shafqat Riaz,
Biao Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Cosimo Bambi,
Daniele Malafarina
Abstract:
The spacetime around astrophysical black holes is thought to be described by the Kerr solution. However, even within general relativity, there is not yet a proof that the final product of the complete collapse of an uncharged body can only be a Kerr black hole. We can thus speculate on the possibility that the spacetime around astrophysical black holes may be described by other solutions of the Ei…
▽ More
The spacetime around astrophysical black holes is thought to be described by the Kerr solution. However, even within general relativity, there is not yet a proof that the final product of the complete collapse of an uncharged body can only be a Kerr black hole. We can thus speculate on the possibility that the spacetime around astrophysical black holes may be described by other solutions of the Einstein Equations and we can test such a hypothesis with observations. In this work, we consider the $δ$-Kerr metric, which is an exact solution of the field equations in vacuum and can be obtained from a non-linear superposition of the Kerr metric with a static axially symmetric solution, often referred to as the $δ$-metric. The parameter $δ=1+q$ quantifies the departure of the source from the Kerr metric and for $q=0$ we recover the Kerr solution. From the analysis of the reflection features in the X-ray spectrum of the Galactic black hole in EXO 1846-031, we find $-0.1 < q < 0.7$ (90% CL), which is consistent with the hypothesis that the spacetime around the compact object in EXO 1846-031 is a Kerr black hole but does not entirely rule out the $δ$-Kerr metric.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2023; v1 submitted 28 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Testing relativistic reflection models with GRMHD simulations of accreting black holes
Authors:
Swarnim Shashank,
Shafqat Riaz,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is currently one of the leading techniques for studying the inner part of accretion disks around black holes, measuring black hole spins, and even testing fundamental physics in strong gravitational fields. However, the accuracy of these measurements depends on the reflection models employed for the spectral analysis, which are sometimes questioned. In this work, we u…
▽ More
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is currently one of the leading techniques for studying the inner part of accretion disks around black holes, measuring black hole spins, and even testing fundamental physics in strong gravitational fields. However, the accuracy of these measurements depends on the reflection models employed for the spectral analysis, which are sometimes questioned. In this work, we use a general relativistic magnetohydrodynamic (GRMHD) code to generate a thin accretion disk in Kerr spacetime and ray-tracing techniques to calculate its relativistically broadened reflection spectrum. We simulate NuSTAR observations and we test the capability of current reflection models based on Novikov-Thorne disks to recover the correct input parameters. Our study shows that we can measure the correct input parameters in the case of high inclination angle sources, while we find some minor discrepancy when the inclination angle of the disk is low.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2022; v1 submitted 23 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Probing bumblebee gravity with black hole X-ray data
Authors:
Jiale Gu,
Shafqat Riaz,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
Bumblebee gravity is one of the simplest gravity theories with spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking. Since we know a rotating black hole solution in bumblebee gravity, we can potentially test this model with the available astrophysical observations of black holes. In this work, we construct a reflection model in bumblebee gravity and we use our model to analyze the reflection features of a NuSTAR…
▽ More
Bumblebee gravity is one of the simplest gravity theories with spontaneous Lorentz symmetry breaking. Since we know a rotating black hole solution in bumblebee gravity, we can potentially test this model with the available astrophysical observations of black holes. In this work, we construct a reflection model in bumblebee gravity and we use our model to analyze the reflection features of a NuSTAR spectrum of the Galactic black hole EXO 1846-031 in order to constrain the Lorentz-violating parameter $\ell$. We find that the analysis of the reflection features in the spectrum of EXO 1846-031 cannot constrain the parameter $\ell$ because of a very strong degeneracy between the estimates of $\ell$ and of the black hole spin parameter $a_*$. Such a degeneracy may be broken by combining other observations.
△ Less
Submitted 15 August, 2022; v1 submitted 29 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Testing regular black holes with X-ray and GW data
Authors:
Shafqat Riaz,
Swarnim Shashank,
Rittick Roy,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Zuobin Zhang,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
The presence of spacetime singularities in physically relevant solutions of the Einstein Equations is normally interpreted as a symptom of the breakdown of classical general relativity at very high densities/curvatures. However, despite significant efforts in the past decades, we do not have yet any robust theoretical framework to solve the problem of spacetime singularities. In this context, the…
▽ More
The presence of spacetime singularities in physically relevant solutions of the Einstein Equations is normally interpreted as a symptom of the breakdown of classical general relativity at very high densities/curvatures. However, despite significant efforts in the past decades, we do not have yet any robust theoretical framework to solve the problem of spacetime singularities. In this context, the past few years have seen an increasing interest in the study of phenomenological scenarios to describe singularity-free black holes, gravitational collapses, and cosmological models. In the present work, we consider the recent proposal by Mazza, Franzin & Liberati for a rotating regular black hole and we measure their regularization parameter $l$ from the available X-ray and gravitational wave black hole data. For $l = 0$, we recover the singular Kerr solution of general relativity, while for $l \neq 0$ we can have a regular black hole or a regular wormhole. Our analysis shows that the available data are consistent with a vanishing regularization parameter $l$ and we can constrain its value. From a NuSTAR spectrum of the Galactic black hole in EXO 1846-031, we find $l/M < 0.49$ (90% CL). From the gravitational wave event GW190707A, we find $l/M < 0.72$ (90% CL).
△ Less
Submitted 5 November, 2022; v1 submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Impact of ionization and electron density gradients in X-ray reflection spectroscopy measurements
Authors:
Gitika Mall,
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
The models currently used for the analysis of the reflection spectra of black holes usually assume a disk with constant ionization and electron density. However, there is some debate on the impact of these assumptions on the estimate of the properties of the sources, in particular when the fits suggest very steep emissivity profiles in the inner part of the accretion disk. In this work, we re-anal…
▽ More
The models currently used for the analysis of the reflection spectra of black holes usually assume a disk with constant ionization and electron density. However, there is some debate on the impact of these assumptions on the estimate of the properties of the sources, in particular when the fits suggest very steep emissivity profiles in the inner part of the accretion disk. In this work, we re-analyze a selected set of high-quality NuSTAR and Suzaku data of Galactic black holes and we fit the reflection component with three different models: RELXILL_NK, in which the ionization parameter and the electron density are constant, RELXILLION_NK, where the electron density is still constant but the ionization profile is described by a power law, and RELXILLDGRAD_NK, where the electron density profile is described by a power law and the ionization profile is calculated self-consistently from the electron density and the emissivity. While RELXILLION_NK may provide slightly better fits, we do not find any substantial difference in the estimate of the properties of the sources among the three models. Our conclusion is that models with constant electron density and ionization parameter are probably sufficient, in most cases, to fit the currently available X-ray data of accreting black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 25 November, 2022; v1 submitted 7 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Black Hole Spin Measurements Based on a Thin Disc Model with Finite Thickness I. An example study of MCG-06-30-15
Authors:
Jiachen Jiang,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Cosimo Bambi,
Christopher S. Reynolds
Abstract:
We present a re-analysis of the XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observing campaign for the well-studied, X-ray-bright AGN MCG-06-30-15. In particular, we consider a disc model with finite thickness. By fitting the disc reflection spectra in the data, we obtain a black hole spin of 0.87--0.99 (90\% confidence range) after taking the thickness of the disc into consideration. Spectral models with a grid of mas…
▽ More
We present a re-analysis of the XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observing campaign for the well-studied, X-ray-bright AGN MCG-06-30-15. In particular, we consider a disc model with finite thickness. By fitting the disc reflection spectra in the data, we obtain a black hole spin of 0.87--0.99 (90\% confidence range) after taking the thickness of the disc into consideration. Spectral models with a grid of mass accretion rate from 0 to $30\%\dot{M}_{\rm Edd}$ are calculated for MCG-06-30-15. This result is obtained by considering a free disc reflection fraction parameter $f_{\rm refl}$ and is consistent with previous measurements based on razor-thin disc models. Besides, an isotropic, point-like geometry, i.e. the `lamppost' geometry, is assumed for the corona in our model. We find that such a geometry overestimates $f_{\rm refl}$ in the data. Therefore, thin disc models with consistent `lamppost' values of $f_{\rm refl}$ provide a worse fit than ones with a free $f_{\rm refl}$ parameter. We discuss possible reasons for the discrepancy between the observed and theoretical values of $f_{\rm refl}$ at the end of the paper. Modifications for the over-simplified lamppost model might be needed when the thickness of the thin disc is considered in future work.
△ Less
Submitted 17 May, 2022; v1 submitted 13 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Observational appearance of Kaluza-Klein black holes
Authors:
Temurbek Mirzaev,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Ahmadjon A. Abdujabbarov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Bobomurat Ahmedov,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
The optical properties of rotating black holes in Kaluza-Klein theory described by the total mass, spin, and electric and magnetic charges are investigated in detail. Using a developed general relativistic ray-tracing code to calculate the motion of photons, the numerous shadows of Kaluza-Klein black holes are generated. The properties of the black hole shadow and the light deflection angle around…
▽ More
The optical properties of rotating black holes in Kaluza-Klein theory described by the total mass, spin, and electric and magnetic charges are investigated in detail. Using a developed general relativistic ray-tracing code to calculate the motion of photons, the numerous shadows of Kaluza-Klein black holes are generated. The properties of the black hole shadow and the light deflection angle around these black holes are also studied in order to put constraints on the parameters of Kaluza-Klein black holes using M87* shadow observations. The possibility of imposing constraints on Kaluza-Klein black holes using shadow observations is investigated. Moreover, we find that small charges (electric and magnetic) of the black hole can meet these constraints. We conclude that with the current precision of the M87* black hole shadow image observation by the EHT collaboration, the shadow observations of Kaluza-Klein black holes are indistinguishable from that of the Kerr black hole. Much better observational accuracy than the current capabilities of the EHT collaboration are required in order to place verified constraints on the parameters of modified theories of gravity in the strong field regime.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2023; v1 submitted 4 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
A reflection model with a radial disk density profile
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Honghui Liu,
Ashutosh Tripathi
Abstract:
In this paper we present RELXILLDGRAD_NK, a relativistic reflection model in which the electron density of the accretion disk is allowed to have a radial power-law profile. The ionization parameter has also a non-constant radial profile and is calculated self-consistently from the electron density and the emissivity. We show the impact of the implementation of the electron density gradient in our…
▽ More
In this paper we present RELXILLDGRAD_NK, a relativistic reflection model in which the electron density of the accretion disk is allowed to have a radial power-law profile. The ionization parameter has also a non-constant radial profile and is calculated self-consistently from the electron density and the emissivity. We show the impact of the implementation of the electron density gradient in our model by analyzing a NuSTAR spectrum of the Galactic black hole in EXO 1846-031 during its last outburst in 2019 and a putative future observation of the same source with Athena and eXTP. For the NuSTAR spectrum, we find that the new model provides a better fit, but there is no significant difference in the estimation of the model parameters. For the Athena+eXTP simulation, we find that a model without a disk density profile is unsuitable to test the spacetime metric around the compact object, in the sense that modeling uncertainties can incorrectly lead to finding a non-vanishing deformation from the Kerr solution.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2021; v1 submitted 1 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Constraining the Konoplya-Rezzolla-Zhidenko deformation parameters II: limits from stellar-mass black hole X-ray data
Authors:
Zhibo Yu,
Qunfeng Jiang,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Honghui Liu,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Ashutosh Tripathi
Abstract:
Astrophysical black holes are thought to be the Kerr black holes predicted by general relativity, but macroscopic deviations from the Kerr solution can be expected from a number of scenarios involving new physics. In Paper I, we studied the reflection features in NuSTAR and XMM-Newton spectra of the supermassive black hole at the center of the galaxy MCG-06-30-15 and we constrained a set of deform…
▽ More
Astrophysical black holes are thought to be the Kerr black holes predicted by general relativity, but macroscopic deviations from the Kerr solution can be expected from a number of scenarios involving new physics. In Paper I, we studied the reflection features in NuSTAR and XMM-Newton spectra of the supermassive black hole at the center of the galaxy MCG-06-30-15 and we constrained a set of deformation parameters proposed by Konoplya, Rezzolla & Zhidenko (Phys. Rev. D93, 064015, 2016). In the present work, we analyze the X-ray data of a stellar-mass black hole within the same theoretical framework in order to probe a different curvature regime. We consider a NuSTAR observation of the X-ray binary EXO 1846-031 during its outburst in 2019. As in the case of Paper I, all our fits are consistent with the Kerr black hole hypothesis, but some deformation parameters cannot be constrained well.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2021; v1 submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis with the continuum-fitting and the iron line methods: the case of GRS 1915+105
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Victoria Grinberg,
Honghui Liu,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
The continuum-fitting and the iron line methods are currently the two leading techniques for probing the strong gravity region around accreting black holes. In the present work, we test the Kerr black hole hypothesis with the stellar-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105 by analyzing five disk-dominated RXTE spectra and one reflection-dominated Suzaku spectrum. The combination of the constraints from th…
▽ More
The continuum-fitting and the iron line methods are currently the two leading techniques for probing the strong gravity region around accreting black holes. In the present work, we test the Kerr black hole hypothesis with the stellar-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105 by analyzing five disk-dominated RXTE spectra and one reflection-dominated Suzaku spectrum. The combination of the constraints from the continuum-fitting and the iron line methods has the potential to provide more stringent tests of the Kerr metric. Our constraint on the Johannsen deformation parameter $α_{13}$ is $-0.15 < α_{13} < 0.14$ at 3$σ$, where the Kerr metric is recovered when $α_{13} = 0$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2022; v1 submitted 21 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis with GRS 1716-249 by combining the continuum-fitting and the iron-line methods
Authors:
Zuobin Zhang,
Honghui Liu,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
The continuum-fitting and the iron-line methods are currently the two leading techniques for measuring the spins of accreting black holes. In the past few years, these two methods have been developed for testing fundamental physics. In the present work, we employ state-of-the-art models to test black holes through the continuum-fitting and the iron-line methods and we analyze three NuSTAR observat…
▽ More
The continuum-fitting and the iron-line methods are currently the two leading techniques for measuring the spins of accreting black holes. In the past few years, these two methods have been developed for testing fundamental physics. In the present work, we employ state-of-the-art models to test black holes through the continuum-fitting and the iron-line methods and we analyze three NuSTAR observations of the black hole binary GRS 1716-249 during its outburst in 2016-2017. In these three observations, the source was in a hard-intermediate state and the spectra show both a strong thermal component and prominent relativistic reflection features. Our analysis confirms the Kerr nature of the black hole in GRS 1716-249 and provides quite stringent constraints on possible deviations from the predictions of general relativity.
△ Less
Submitted 13 January, 2022; v1 submitted 6 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Constraining the KRZ deformation parameters I: limits from supermassive black hole X-ray data
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Ashutosh Tripathi
Abstract:
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a powerful technique for probing the nature of gravity around black holes in the so-called strong field regime. One of the most popular of such probes is to look at theory-agnostic deviations away from the Kerr solution, which is the only astrophysically relevant black hole solution within classical general relativity, in order to verify whether astrophysical black…
▽ More
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a powerful technique for probing the nature of gravity around black holes in the so-called strong field regime. One of the most popular of such probes is to look at theory-agnostic deviations away from the Kerr solution, which is the only astrophysically relevant black hole solution within classical general relativity, in order to verify whether astrophysical black holes are described by the Kerr metric. We have recently extended our X-ray reflection spectroscopy framework to a class of very general axisymmetric non-Kerr black holes proposed by Konoplya, Rezzolla & Zhidenko (Phys. Rev. D93, 064015, 2016). Here, we analyze XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations of the supermassive black hole in the Seyfert 1 galaxy MCG-06-30-15 with six different deviation parameters of this extended model. We recover the Kerr solution in all cases, but some deformation parameters are poorly constrained. We discuss the implications of this verification and future possibilities.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2021; v1 submitted 9 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Testing the Weak Equivalence Principle near black holes
Authors:
Rittick Roy,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Shafqat Riaz,
Ashutosh Tripathi
Abstract:
Today we have quite stringent constraints on possible violations of the Weak Equivalence Principle from the comparison of the acceleration of test-bodies of different composition in Earth's gravitational field. In the present paper, we propose a test of the Weak Equivalence Principle in the strong gravitational field of black holes. We construct a relativistic reflection model in which either the…
▽ More
Today we have quite stringent constraints on possible violations of the Weak Equivalence Principle from the comparison of the acceleration of test-bodies of different composition in Earth's gravitational field. In the present paper, we propose a test of the Weak Equivalence Principle in the strong gravitational field of black holes. We construct a relativistic reflection model in which either the massive particles of the gas of the accretion disk or the photons emitted by the disk may not follow the geodesics of the spacetime. We employ our model to analyze the reflection features of a NuSTAR spectrum of the black hole binary EXO 1846-031 and we constrain two parameters that quantify a possible violation of the Weak Equivalence Principle by massive particles and X-ray photons, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2021; v1 submitted 16 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Constraints on Einstein-Maxwell dilaton-axion gravity from X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Biao Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
Einstein-Maxwell dilaton-axion gravity is a string-inspired model arising from the low energy effective action of heterotic string theory and an important candidate as alternative to General Relativity. Recently, some authors have explored its astrophysical implications in the spectra of accreting black holes and inferred the constraint $r_2 < 0.1$, where $r_2 \ge 0$ is the black hole dilaton char…
▽ More
Einstein-Maxwell dilaton-axion gravity is a string-inspired model arising from the low energy effective action of heterotic string theory and an important candidate as alternative to General Relativity. Recently, some authors have explored its astrophysical implications in the spectra of accreting black holes and inferred the constraint $r_2 < 0.1$, where $r_2 \ge 0$ is the black hole dilaton charge and General Relativity is recovered for $r_2 = 0$. In the present paper, we study the impact of a non-vanishing black hole dilaton charge on the reflection spectrum of the disk. From the analysis of a NuSTAR spectrum of the black hole binary EXO 1846-031, we find the constraint $r_2 < 0.011$ (90% CL), which is an order of magnitude more stringent.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2021; v1 submitted 12 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Impact of the disk thickness on X-ray reflection spectroscopy measurements
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Honghui Liu
Abstract:
In a previous paper, we presented an extension of our reflection model RELXILL_NK to include the finite thickness of the accretion disk following the prescription in Taylor & Reynolds (2018). In this paper, we apply our model to fit the 2013 simultaneous observations by NuSTAR and XMM-Newton of the supermassive black hole in MCG-06-30-15 and the 2019 NuSTAR observation of the Galactic black hole i…
▽ More
In a previous paper, we presented an extension of our reflection model RELXILL_NK to include the finite thickness of the accretion disk following the prescription in Taylor & Reynolds (2018). In this paper, we apply our model to fit the 2013 simultaneous observations by NuSTAR and XMM-Newton of the supermassive black hole in MCG-06-30-15 and the 2019 NuSTAR observation of the Galactic black hole in EXO 1846-031. The high-quality data of these spectra had previously led to precise black hole spin measurements and very stringent constraints on possible deviations from the Kerr metric. We find that the disk thickness does not change previous spin results found with a model employing an infinitesimally thin disk, which confirms the robustness of spin measurements in high radiative efficiency disks, where the impact of disk thickness is minimal. Similar analysis on lower accretion rate systems will be an important test for measuring the effect of disk thickness on black hole spin measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2021; v1 submitted 9 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Implementation of a radial disk ionization profile in the RELXILL_NK model
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Honghui Liu,
Yuexin Zhang
Abstract:
Very steep reflection emissivity profiles in the inner part of accretion disks are commonly found in the analysis of X-ray observations of black hole binaries and AGN, but there is some debate about their exact origin. While steep reflection emissivity profiles can be naturally produced by compact coronae close to black holes, the measured radial emissivity parameter can be further increased by th…
▽ More
Very steep reflection emissivity profiles in the inner part of accretion disks are commonly found in the analysis of X-ray observations of black hole binaries and AGN, but there is some debate about their exact origin. While steep reflection emissivity profiles can be naturally produced by compact coronae close to black holes, the measured radial emissivity parameter can be further increased by the radial disk ionization profile when the theoretical model assumes a disk with constant ionization. In this paper, we implement the possibility of a radial disk ionization profile in the reflection model RELXILL_NK, which is a package designed to calculate reflection spectra of "deformed" Kerr black holes. We analyze a NuSTAR observation of the black hole binary EXO 1846-031, which was previously found to have a very high inner emissivity index. We find that the model with a radial disk ionization profile improves the fit, but the impact on the estimate of the black hole spin parameter and on the constraint of the deformation parameter is modest. However, we show that the analysis of future observations of Athena and eXTP will necessarily require models with a radial disk ionization profile to have accurate constraints of the deformation parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2021; v1 submitted 25 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Testing General Relativity with NuSTAR data of Galactic Black Holes
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Yuexin Zhang,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Jiachen Jiang,
Honghui Liu,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
Einstein's theory of General Relativity predicts that the spacetime metric around astrophysical black holes is described by the Kerr solution. In this work, we employ state-of-the-art in relativistic reflection modeling to analyze a selected set of NuSTAR spectra of Galactic black holes to obtain the most robust and precise constraints on the Kerr black hole hypothesis possible today. Our constrai…
▽ More
Einstein's theory of General Relativity predicts that the spacetime metric around astrophysical black holes is described by the Kerr solution. In this work, we employ state-of-the-art in relativistic reflection modeling to analyze a selected set of NuSTAR spectra of Galactic black holes to obtain the most robust and precise constraints on the Kerr black hole hypothesis possible today. Our constraints are much more stringent than those from other electromagnetic techniques, and with some sources we get stronger constraints than those currently available from gravitational waves.
△ Less
Submitted 28 May, 2021; v1 submitted 19 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Reflection spectra of accretion disks illuminated by disk-like coronae
Authors:
Shafqat Riaz,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Haiyang Wang,
Zhibo Yu
Abstract:
Relativistic reflection features in the X-ray spectra of black hole binaries and AGNs are thought to be produced through illumination of a cold accretion disk by a hot corona. In this work, we assume that the corona has the shape of an infinitesimally thin disk with its central axis the same as the rotational axis of the black hole. The corona can either be static or corotate with the accretion di…
▽ More
Relativistic reflection features in the X-ray spectra of black hole binaries and AGNs are thought to be produced through illumination of a cold accretion disk by a hot corona. In this work, we assume that the corona has the shape of an infinitesimally thin disk with its central axis the same as the rotational axis of the black hole. The corona can either be static or corotate with the accretion disk. We calculate the disk's emissivity profiles and iron line shapes for a set of coronal radii and heights. We incorporate these emissivity profiles into RELXILL_NK and we simulate some observations of a black hole binary with NuSTAR to study the impact of a disk-like coronal geometry on the measurement of the properties of the system and, in particular, on the possibility of testing the Kerr nature of the source. We find that, in general, the astrophysical properties of the accretion disk are recovered well even if we fit the data with a model employing a broken power-law or a lamppost emissivity profile, while it is more challenging to constrain the geometric properties of the black hole spacetime.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 14 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Probing the near-horizon region of Cygnus X-1 with Suzaku and NuSTAR
Authors:
Zuobin Zhang,
Honghui Liu,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
Astrophysical black holes are ideal laboratories for testing Einstein's theory of general relativity in the strong field regime. In this manuscript, we present an analysis of Suzaku and NuSTAR spectra of the black hole binary Cygnus X-1 using RELXILL_NK. Unlike our previous study on Cygnus X-1 with NuSTAR data, here we are able to constrain the Johannsen deformation parameter $α_{13}$. However, de…
▽ More
Astrophysical black holes are ideal laboratories for testing Einstein's theory of general relativity in the strong field regime. In this manuscript, we present an analysis of Suzaku and NuSTAR spectra of the black hole binary Cygnus X-1 using RELXILL_NK. Unlike our previous study on Cygnus X-1 with NuSTAR data, here we are able to constrain the Johannsen deformation parameter $α_{13}$. However, despite the high energy resolution near the iron line provided by Suzaku, our constraints on the Kerr metric from Cygnus X-1 are not very stringent in comparison with those that have been obtained from other sources, confirming that Cygnus X-1 is quite a complicated source.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2021; v1 submitted 2 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Testing the Kerr Black Hole Hypothesis with GX 339-4 by a combined analysis of its thermal spectrum and reflection features
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Victoria Grinberg,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
We analyze simultaneous observations with NuSTAR and Swift of the black hole binary GX 339-4 in which we clearly detect both a strong thermal component and prominent relativistic reflection features. We employ NKBB and RELXILL_NK, which are the state of the art of, respectively, the thermal and reflection models to test the Kerr black hole hypothesis. We obtain unprecedented precise measurements o…
▽ More
We analyze simultaneous observations with NuSTAR and Swift of the black hole binary GX 339-4 in which we clearly detect both a strong thermal component and prominent relativistic reflection features. We employ NKBB and RELXILL_NK, which are the state of the art of, respectively, the thermal and reflection models to test the Kerr black hole hypothesis. We obtain unprecedented precise measurements of the Johannsen deformation parameter $α_{13}$: $α_{13} = -0.012_{-0.039}^{+0.011}$ (lamppost coronal geometry) and $α_{13} = -0.010_{-0.018}^{+0.024}$ (broken power-law emissivity profile) at a 90% confidence level, where the Kerr metric corresponds to $α_{13} = 0$. We investigate the systematic uncertainties by fitting the data with different models.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021; v1 submitted 26 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Testing the Keplerian disk hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Biao Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
The Novikov-Thorne model is the standard framework for the description of geometrically thin and optically thick accretion disks around black holes and is widely used to study the electromagnetic spectra of accreting black holes. One of the assumptions of the model is that the particles of the gas move on nearly-geodesic circular orbits on the equatorial plane. In this work, we propose to test the…
▽ More
The Novikov-Thorne model is the standard framework for the description of geometrically thin and optically thick accretion disks around black holes and is widely used to study the electromagnetic spectra of accreting black holes. One of the assumptions of the model is that the particles of the gas move on nearly-geodesic circular orbits on the equatorial plane. In this work, we propose to test the Keplerian velocity of the particles in the accretion disk using X-ray reflection spectroscopy. We present a modified version of RELXILL in which we introduce a phenomenological parameter, $α$, to quantify possible deviations from Keplerian motion. We use our model to fit a Suzaku observation of the black hole binary GRS 1915+105. We find that the estimate of $α$ is correlated to that of the inclination angle of the disk, $i$, and that we could test the Keplerian disk hypothesis in the presence of a robust and independent measurement of $i$.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2020; v1 submitted 5 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Shining X-rays on asymptotically safe quantum gravity
Authors:
Biao Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Ashutosh Tripathi
Abstract:
Asymptotically safe quantum gravity is a promising candidate scenario to provide a UV extension for the effective quantum field theory of Einstein's gravity. The theory has its foundations on the very successful framework of quantum field theory, which has been extensively tested for electromagnetic and nuclear interactions. However, observational tests of asymptotically safe quantum gravity are m…
▽ More
Asymptotically safe quantum gravity is a promising candidate scenario to provide a UV extension for the effective quantum field theory of Einstein's gravity. The theory has its foundations on the very successful framework of quantum field theory, which has been extensively tested for electromagnetic and nuclear interactions. However, observational tests of asymptotically safe quantum gravity are more challenging. Recently, a rotating black hole metric inspired by asymptotically safe quantum gravity has been proposed, and this opens the possibility of astrophysical tests of the theory. In the present paper, we show the capabilities of X-ray reflection spectroscopy to constrain the inverse dimensionless fixed-point value $γ$ from the analysis of a Suzaku observation of the X-ray binary GRS 1915+105. We compare these constraints with those obtained from black hole imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2021; v1 submitted 26 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
X-ray reflection spectroscopy with Kaluza-Klein black holes
Authors:
Jiachen Zhu,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Mustapha Azreg-Ainou,
Cosimo Bambi,
Mubasher Jamil,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
Kaluza-Klein theory is a popular alternative theory of gravity, with both non-rotating and rotating black hole solutions known. This allows for the possibility that the theory could be observationally tested. We present a model which calculates the reflection spectrum of a black hole accretion disk system, where the black hole is described by a rotating solution of the Kaluza-Klein theory. We also…
▽ More
Kaluza-Klein theory is a popular alternative theory of gravity, with both non-rotating and rotating black hole solutions known. This allows for the possibility that the theory could be observationally tested. We present a model which calculates the reflection spectrum of a black hole accretion disk system, where the black hole is described by a rotating solution of the Kaluza-Klein theory. We also use this model to analyze X-ray data from the stella-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105 and provide constraints on the free parameters of the Kaluza-Klein black holes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2020; v1 submitted 30 April, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Thermal spectra of thin accretion disks of finite thickness around Kerr black holes
Authors:
Menglei Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Victoria Grinberg,
Ashutosh Tripathi
Abstract:
The analysis of the thermal spectrum of geometrically thin and optically thick accretion disks of black holes, the so-called continuum-fitting method, is one of the leading techniques for measuring black hole spins. Current models normally approximate the disk as infinitesimally thin, while in reality the disk thickness is finite and increases as the black hole mass accretion rate increases. Here…
▽ More
The analysis of the thermal spectrum of geometrically thin and optically thick accretion disks of black holes, the so-called continuum-fitting method, is one of the leading techniques for measuring black hole spins. Current models normally approximate the disk as infinitesimally thin, while in reality the disk thickness is finite and increases as the black hole mass accretion rate increases. Here we present an XSPEC model to calculate the multi-temperature blackbody spectrum of a thin accretion disk of finite thickness around a Kerr black hole. We test our new model with an RXTE observation of the black hole binary GRS 1915+105. We find that the spin value inferred with the new model is slightly higher than the spin value obtained with a model with an infinitesimally thin disk, but the difference is small and the effect is currently subdominant with respect to other sources of uncertainties in the final spin measurement.
△ Less
Submitted 3 June, 2020; v1 submitted 27 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Reflection features in the X-ray spectrum of Fairall 9 and implications for tests of general relativity
Authors:
Honghui Liu,
Haiyang Wang,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is potentially a powerful tool to probe the spacetime geometry around astrophysical black holes and test general relativity in the strong field regime. However, precision tests of general relativity are only possible if we employ the correct astrophysical model and we can limit the systematic uncertainties. It is thus crucial to select the sources and the observations…
▽ More
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is potentially a powerful tool to probe the spacetime geometry around astrophysical black holes and test general relativity in the strong field regime. However, precision tests of general relativity are only possible if we employ the correct astrophysical model and we can limit the systematic uncertainties. It is thus crucial to select the sources and the observations most suitable for these tests. In this work, we analyze simultaneous observations of XMM-Newton and NuSTAR of the supermassive black hole in Fairall 9. This source has a number of properties that make it a promising candidate for tests of general relativity using X-ray reflection spectroscopy. Nevertheless, we find that with the available data there is not a unique interpretation of the spectrum of Fairall 9, which prevents, for the moment, to use this source for robust tests of general relativity. This issue may be solved by future X-ray missions with a higher energy resolution near the iron line.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy and a thin disk model with finite thickness
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a powerful tool for probing the strong gravity region of black holes and can be used for testing general relativity in the strong field regime. Simplifications of the available relativistic reflection models limit the capability of performing accurate measurements of the properties of black holes. In this paper, we present an extension of the model RELXILL_NK in wh…
▽ More
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a powerful tool for probing the strong gravity region of black holes and can be used for testing general relativity in the strong field regime. Simplifications of the available relativistic reflection models limit the capability of performing accurate measurements of the properties of black holes. In this paper, we present an extension of the model RELXILL_NK in which the accretion disk has a finite thickness rather than being infinitesimally thin. We employ the accretion disk geometry proposed by Taylor & Reynolds (2018) and we construct relativistic reflection models for different values of the mass accretion rate of the black hole. We apply the new model to high quality Suzaku data of the X-ray binary GRS 1915+105 to explore the impact of the thickness of the disk on tests of the Kerr metric.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2020; v1 submitted 21 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Singularity-free black holes in conformal gravity: new observational constraints
Authors:
Menglei Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Leonardo Modesto,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Yerong Xu
Abstract:
We consider the family of singularity-free rotating black hole solutions in Einstein's conformal gravity found in Bambi, Modesto & Rachwal (2017) and we constrain the value of the conformal parameter $L$ from the analysis of a 30 ks NuSTAR observation of the stellar-mass black hole in GS 1354-645 during its outburst in 2015. Our new constraint is much stronger than that found in previous work. Her…
▽ More
We consider the family of singularity-free rotating black hole solutions in Einstein's conformal gravity found in Bambi, Modesto & Rachwal (2017) and we constrain the value of the conformal parameter $L$ from the analysis of a 30 ks NuSTAR observation of the stellar-mass black hole in GS 1354-645 during its outburst in 2015. Our new constraint is much stronger than that found in previous work. Here we obtain $L/M < 0.12$ (99% confidence level, statistical uncertainty only).
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Testing general relativity with the stellar-mass black hole in LMC X-1 using the continuum-fitting method
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Menglei Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Lijun Gou,
Victoria Grinberg,
Honghui Liu,
James F. Steiner
Abstract:
The iron line and the continuum-fitting methods are currently the two leading techniques for measuring black hole spins with electromagnetic radiation. They can be naturally extended for probing the spacetime geometry around black holes and testing general relativity in the strong field regime. In the past couple of years, there has been significant work to use the iron line method to test the nat…
▽ More
The iron line and the continuum-fitting methods are currently the two leading techniques for measuring black hole spins with electromagnetic radiation. They can be naturally extended for probing the spacetime geometry around black holes and testing general relativity in the strong field regime. In the past couple of years, there has been significant work to use the iron line method to test the nature of black holes. In this Letter, we use the continuum-fitting method and we show its capability of constraining the spacetime geometry around black holes by analyzing 17 RXTE data of the X-ray binary LMC X-1.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2020; v1 submitted 23 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Search for traversable wormholes in active galactic nuclei using X-ray data
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Biao Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi
Abstract:
In a previous paper, one of us calculated iron K$α$ line profiles emitted from possible accretion disks around traversable wormholes as a first step to use X-ray reflection spectroscopy to search for astrophysical wormholes in active galactic nuclei. In the present paper, we extend that work and construct an XSPEC model for the whole relativistic reflection spectrum. We apply our model to XMM-Newt…
▽ More
In a previous paper, one of us calculated iron K$α$ line profiles emitted from possible accretion disks around traversable wormholes as a first step to use X-ray reflection spectroscopy to search for astrophysical wormholes in active galactic nuclei. In the present paper, we extend that work and construct an XSPEC model for the whole relativistic reflection spectrum. We apply our model to XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations of the supermassive object in MCG-6-30-15 and we check whether these observations prefer the hypothesis that the central body is a Kerr black hole or a traversable wormhole. We find that the two models provide equally good fits, so with the available data we cannot distinguish the black hole and wormhole scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2020; v1 submitted 9 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
RELXILL_NK: A Black Hole Relativistic Reflection Model for Testing General Relativity
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
In this paper, we briefly present RELXILL_NK, the first and currently only readily available model of the relativistic reflection spectrum of black hole accretion disks that includes non-Kerr solutions for the black hole spacetime, thus allowing for tests of the Kerr hypothesis and GR. RELXILL_NK makes use of a general relativistic ray-tracing code to calculate the relativistic effects of any well…
▽ More
In this paper, we briefly present RELXILL_NK, the first and currently only readily available model of the relativistic reflection spectrum of black hole accretion disks that includes non-Kerr solutions for the black hole spacetime, thus allowing for tests of the Kerr hypothesis and GR. RELXILL_NK makes use of a general relativistic ray-tracing code to calculate the relativistic effects of any well-behaved, stationary, axisymmetric, and asymptotically flat black hole spacetime, while the disk physics is handled through the non-relativistic X-ray reflection code XILLVER. A number of different flavors are available within RELXILL_NK; we summarize and compare these flavors using the Johannsen metric for the black hole spacetime.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Relativistic reflection spectra of super-spinning black holes
Authors:
Biao Zhou,
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Menglei Zhou
Abstract:
We construct a relativistic reflection model in a non-Kerr spacetime in which, depending on the value of the deformation parameter of the metric, there are black hole solutions with spin parameter $|a_*| > 1$. We apply our model to fit Suzaku data of four Seyfert galaxies (Ton S180, Ark 120, 1H0419-577, and Swift J0501.9-3239). These galaxies host at the center supermassive black holes that were p…
▽ More
We construct a relativistic reflection model in a non-Kerr spacetime in which, depending on the value of the deformation parameter of the metric, there are black hole solutions with spin parameter $|a_*| > 1$. We apply our model to fit Suzaku data of four Seyfert galaxies (Ton S180, Ark 120, 1H0419-577, and Swift J0501.9-3239). These galaxies host at the center supermassive black holes that were previously interpreted as near-extremal Kerr black holes. For Ton S180 and 1H0419-577, our measurements are still consistent with the Kerr hypothesis. For Ark 120 and Swift J0501.9-3239, the Kerr solution is not recovered at 3-$σ$. We discuss our results and possible systematic uncertainties in the model.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2020; v1 submitted 14 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Tests of the Kerr hypothesis with GRS 1915+105 using different RELXILL flavors
Authors:
Yuexin Zhang,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
In a previous paper, we tried to test the Kerr nature of the stellar-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105 by analyzing NuSTAR data of 2012 with our reflection model RELXILL_NK. We found that the choice of the intensity profile of the reflection component is crucial and eventually we were not able to get any constraint on the spacetime metric around the black hole in GRS 1915+105. In the present paper,…
▽ More
In a previous paper, we tried to test the Kerr nature of the stellar-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105 by analyzing NuSTAR data of 2012 with our reflection model RELXILL_NK. We found that the choice of the intensity profile of the reflection component is crucial and eventually we were not able to get any constraint on the spacetime metric around the black hole in GRS 1915+105. In the present paper, we study the same source with Suzaku data of 2007. We confirm that the intensity profile plays an important role, but now we find quite stringent constraints consistent with the Kerr hypothesis. The key differences with respect to our previous study are likely the lower disk temperature in the Suzaku observation and the higher energy resolution near the iron line of the Suzaku data. We also apply different RELXILL flavors (different descriptions of the coronal spectrum and variable disk electron density) obtaining essentially the same results. We thus conclude that this choice is not very important for our tests of the Kerr hypothesis while the intensity profile does play an important role, and that with high quality data it is possible to measure both the spacetime metric and the intensity profile.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2019; v1 submitted 6 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Testing general relativity with supermassive black holes using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Jelen Wong,
Yerong Xu,
**li Yan,
Yunfeng Yan,
Yuchan Yang
Abstract:
In this paper, we review our current efforts to test General Relativity in the strong field regime by studying the reflection spectrum of supermassive black holes. So far we have analyzed 11 sources with observations of NuSTAR, Suzaku, Swift, and XMM-Newton. Our results are consistent with general relativity, according to which the spacetime metric around astrophysical black holes should be well a…
▽ More
In this paper, we review our current efforts to test General Relativity in the strong field regime by studying the reflection spectrum of supermassive black holes. So far we have analyzed 11 sources with observations of NuSTAR, Suzaku, Swift, and XMM-Newton. Our results are consistent with general relativity, according to which the spacetime metric around astrophysical black holes should be well approximated by the Kerr solution. We discuss the systematic uncertainties in our model and we present a preliminary study on the impact of some of them on the measurement of the spacetime metric.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Testing the Kerr hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy with NuSTAR data of Cygnus X-1 in the soft state
Authors:
Honghui Liu,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
We continue exploring the constraining capabilities of X-ray reflection spectroscopy to test the Kerr-nature of astrophysical black holes and we present the results of our analysis of two NuSTAR observations of Cygnus X-1 in the soft state. We find that the final measurement can strongly depend on the assumption of the intensity profile. We conclude that Cygnus X-1 is not suitable for tests of gen…
▽ More
We continue exploring the constraining capabilities of X-ray reflection spectroscopy to test the Kerr-nature of astrophysical black holes and we present the results of our analysis of two NuSTAR observations of Cygnus X-1 in the soft state. We find that the final measurement can strongly depend on the assumption of the intensity profile. We conclude that Cygnus X-1 is not suitable for tests of general relativity using X-ray reflection spectroscopy and we discuss the desired properties of a source to be a good candidate for our studies.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019; v1 submitted 16 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Black hole mimicker hiding in the shadow: Optical properties of the $γ$-metric
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Ahmadjon A. Abdujabbarov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Daniele Malafarina,
Cosimo Bambi,
Bobomurat Ahmedov
Abstract:
Can the observation of the "shadow" allow us to distinguish a black hole from a more exotic compact object? We study the motion of photons in a class of vacuum static axially-symmetric space-times that is continuously linked to the Schwarzschild metric through the value of one parameter that can be interpreted as a measure of the deformation of the source. We investigate the lensing effect and sha…
▽ More
Can the observation of the "shadow" allow us to distinguish a black hole from a more exotic compact object? We study the motion of photons in a class of vacuum static axially-symmetric space-times that is continuously linked to the Schwarzschild metric through the value of one parameter that can be interpreted as a measure of the deformation of the source. We investigate the lensing effect and shadow produced by the source with the aim of comparing the expected image with the shadow of a Schwarzschild black hole. In the context of astrophysical black holes we found that it may not be possible to distinguish an exotic source with small deformation parameter from a black hole. However, as the deformation increases noticeable effects arise. Therefore, the future more precise measurement of the shadow of astrophysical black hole candidates would in principle allow to put constraints on the deviation of the object from spherical symmetry.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2019; v1 submitted 11 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Testing General Relativity with X-ray reflection spectroscopy: The Konoplya-Rezzolla-Zhidenko parametrization
Authors:
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Shuo Xin,
Shubham Srivastava,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Ashutosh Tripathi
Abstract:
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a promising technique for testing general relativity in the strong field regime, as it can be used to test the Kerr black hole hypothesis. In this context, the parametrically deformed black hole metrics proposed by Konoplya, Rezzolla \& Zhidenko (Phys. Rev. D93, 064015, 2016) form an important class of non-Kerr black holes. We implement this class of black hole met…
▽ More
X-ray reflection spectroscopy is a promising technique for testing general relativity in the strong field regime, as it can be used to test the Kerr black hole hypothesis. In this context, the parametrically deformed black hole metrics proposed by Konoplya, Rezzolla \& Zhidenko (Phys. Rev. D93, 064015, 2016) form an important class of non-Kerr black holes. We implement this class of black hole metrics in \textsc{relxill\_nk}, which is a framework we have developed for testing for non-Kerr black holes using X-ray reflection spectroscopy. We perform a qualitative analysis of the effect of the leading order strong-field deformation parameters on typical observables like the innermost stable circular orbits and the reflection spectra. We also present the first X-ray constraints on some of the deformation parameters of this metric, using \textit{Suzaku} data from the supermassive black hole in Ark~564, and compare them with those obtained (or expected) from other observational techniques like gravitational waves and black hole imaging.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2021; v1 submitted 28 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
XSPEC model for testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis using the continuum-fitting method
Authors:
Menglei Zhou,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Honghui Liu,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
We present NKBB, an XSPEC model for the thermal spectrum of thin accretion disks in parametric black hole spacetimes. We employ the Novikov-Thorne model for the description of the accretion disk and the formalism of the transfer function proposed by Cunningham for storing all the relativistic effects of the spacetime metric. The current version of the model assumes the Johannsen metric, but it can…
▽ More
We present NKBB, an XSPEC model for the thermal spectrum of thin accretion disks in parametric black hole spacetimes. We employ the Novikov-Thorne model for the description of the accretion disk and the formalism of the transfer function proposed by Cunningham for storing all the relativistic effects of the spacetime metric. The current version of the model assumes the Johannsen metric, but it can be easily extended to any stationary, axisymmetric, and asymptotically-flat spacetime without pathological properties. The model can be used within the XSPEC package to test the Kerr nature of astrophysical black holes with the continuum-fitting method.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2019; v1 submitted 23 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Constraining the Johannsen deformation parameter $ε_3$ with black hole X-ray data
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
We extend our previous work on tests of the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy and we infer observational constraints on the Johannsen deformation parameter $ε_3$. We analyze a NuSTAR observation of the stellar-mass black hole in GS 1354-645, Suzaku data of the supermassive black holes in Ark 564, 1H0419-577, and PKS 0558-504, and some simultaneous XMM-Newton and NuSTAR…
▽ More
We extend our previous work on tests of the Kerr black hole hypothesis using X-ray reflection spectroscopy and we infer observational constraints on the Johannsen deformation parameter $ε_3$. We analyze a NuSTAR observation of the stellar-mass black hole in GS 1354-645, Suzaku data of the supermassive black holes in Ark 564, 1H0419-577, and PKS 0558-504, and some simultaneous XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations of the supermassive black hole in MCG-6-30-15. All our measurements of $ε_3$ are consistent with the Kerr metric and we find quite strong constraints from Ark 564 and MCG-6-30-15. We discuss the implications of our results and the next steps to improve our tests.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2019; v1 submitted 10 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Public Release of RELXILL_NK: A Relativistic Reflection Model for Testing Einstein's Gravity
Authors:
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
We present the public release version of relxill_nk, an X-ray reflection model for testing the Kerr hypothesis and general relativity. This model extends the relxill model that assumes the black hole spacetime is described by the Kerr metric. We also present relxilllp_nk, the first non-Kerr X-ray reflection model with a lamppost corona configuration, as well as all other models available in the fu…
▽ More
We present the public release version of relxill_nk, an X-ray reflection model for testing the Kerr hypothesis and general relativity. This model extends the relxill model that assumes the black hole spacetime is described by the Kerr metric. We also present relxilllp_nk, the first non-Kerr X-ray reflection model with a lamppost corona configuration, as well as all other models available in the full relxill_nk package. In all models the relevant relativistic effects are calculated through a general relativistic ray-tracing code that can be applied to any well-behaved, stationary, axisymmetric, and asymptotically flat black hole spacetime. We show that the numerical error introduced by using a ray-tracing code is not significant as compared with the observational error present in current X-ray reflection spectrum observations. In addition, we present the reflection spectrum for the Johannsen metric as calculated by relxill_nk.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2019; v1 submitted 25 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
About the Kerr nature of the stellar-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105
Authors:
Yuexin Zhang,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
We employ the accretion disk reflection model RELXILL_NK to test the spacetime geometry around the stellar-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105. We adopt the Johannsen metric with the deformation parameters $α_{13}$ and $α_{22}$, for which the Kerr solution is recovered when $α_{13} = α_{22} = 0$. We analyze a NuSTAR observation of 2012, obtaining vanishing and non-vanishing values of the deformation p…
▽ More
We employ the accretion disk reflection model RELXILL_NK to test the spacetime geometry around the stellar-mass black hole in GRS 1915+105. We adopt the Johannsen metric with the deformation parameters $α_{13}$ and $α_{22}$, for which the Kerr solution is recovered when $α_{13} = α_{22} = 0$. We analyze a NuSTAR observation of 2012, obtaining vanishing and non-vanishing values of the deformation parameters depending on the astrophysical model adopted. Similar difficulties were not found in our previous tests with other sources. The results of this work can shed light on the choice of sources suitable for testing the Kerr metric using X-ray reflection spectroscopy and on the parts of our reflection models that more urgently require improvement.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2019; v1 submitted 18 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Constraints on the spacetime metric around seven "bare" AGNs using X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
**li Yan,
Yuchan Yang,
Yunfeng Yan,
Marcus Garnham,
Yu Yao,
Songcheng Li,
Ziyu Ding,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Jiachen Jiang,
Sourabh Nampalliwar
Abstract:
We present the study of a sample of seven "bare" active galactic nuclei (AGN) observed with Suzaku. We interpret the spectrum of these sources with a relativistic reflection component and we employ our model RELXILL_NK to test the Kerr nature of their supermassive black holes. We constrain the Johannsen deformation parameters $α_{13}$ and $α_{22}$, in which the Kerr metric is recovered when…
▽ More
We present the study of a sample of seven "bare" active galactic nuclei (AGN) observed with Suzaku. We interpret the spectrum of these sources with a relativistic reflection component and we employ our model RELXILL_NK to test the Kerr nature of their supermassive black holes. We constrain the Johannsen deformation parameters $α_{13}$ and $α_{22}$, in which the Kerr metric is recovered when $α_{13} = α_{22} = 0$. All our measurements are consistent with the hypothesis that the spacetime geometry around these supermassive objects is described by the Kerr solution. For some sources, we obtain quite strong constraints on $α_{13}$ and $α_{22}$ when compared to those found in our previous studies. We discuss the systematic uncertainties in our tests and the implications of our results.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2019; v1 submitted 10 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Towards precision tests of general relativity with black hole X-ray reflection spectroscopy
Authors:
Ashutosh Tripathi,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Andrea Marinucci
Abstract:
Astrophysical black hole systems are the ideal laboratories for testing Einstein's theory of gravity in the strong field regime. We have recently developed a framework which uses the reflection spectrum of black hole systems to perform precision tests of general relativity by testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis. In this paper, we analyze XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations of the supermassive bl…
▽ More
Astrophysical black hole systems are the ideal laboratories for testing Einstein's theory of gravity in the strong field regime. We have recently developed a framework which uses the reflection spectrum of black hole systems to perform precision tests of general relativity by testing the Kerr black hole hypothesis. In this paper, we analyze XMM-Newton and NuSTAR observations of the supermassive black hole in the Seyfert 1 galaxy MCG-06-30-15 with our disk reflection model. We consider the Johannsen metric with the deformation parameters $α_{13}$ and $α_{22}$, which quantify deviations from the Kerr metric. For $α_{22} = 0$, we obtain the black hole spin $0.928 < a_* < 0.983$ and $-0.44 < α_{13} < 0.15$. For $α_{13} = 0$, we obtain $0.885 < a_* < 0.987$ and $-0.12 < α_{22} < 1.05$. The Kerr solution is recovered for $α_{13} = α_{22} = 0$. Thus, our results include the Kerr solution within statistical uncertainties. Systematic uncertainties are difficult to account for, and we discuss some issues in this regard.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2019; v1 submitted 20 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Testing the Kerr metric with X-ray Reflection Spectroscopy of Mrk 335 Suzaku data
Authors:
Kishalay Choudhury,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia
Abstract:
Einstein's gravity has undergone extensive tests in the weak field gravitational limit, with results in agreement with theoretical predictions. There exist theories beyond general relativity (GR) which modify gravity in the strong field regime but agree with GR in the weak field. Astrophysical black holes are believed to be described by the Kerr metric and serve as suitable candidates to test stro…
▽ More
Einstein's gravity has undergone extensive tests in the weak field gravitational limit, with results in agreement with theoretical predictions. There exist theories beyond general relativity (GR) which modify gravity in the strong field regime but agree with GR in the weak field. Astrophysical black holes are believed to be described by the Kerr metric and serve as suitable candidates to test strong gravity with electromagnetic radiation. We perform such a test by fitting one Suzaku dataset of the narrow-line Seyfert 1 (NLS1) galaxy Mrk 335 with X-ray reflection spectroscopy, using the Johannsen metric to model the black hole spacetime and test for deviations from Kerr. We find the data is best modeled with a hybrid model that includes both partial covering absorption and a reflection component. This is the first time such a model has been proposed for a high-flux (low reflection) Mrk 335 dataset. We constrain the Johannsen deformation parameter $α_{13}$ to $-1.5<α_{13}<0.6$ with spin parameter $a_{*}>0.8$, and the $α_{22}$ parameter to $-0.4<α_{22}<2.1$ with $a_{*}>0.7$, both at the 99% confidence level. Although additional solutions at large deviations from the Kerr metric show statistical similarity with the ones above, further analysis suggests these solutions may be manifestations of uncertainties beyond our control and do not represent the data. Hence, our results are in agreement with the idea that the supermassive compact object at the center of Mrk 335 is described by the Kerr metric.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2019; v1 submitted 18 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A study of the strong gravity region of the black hole in GS 1354-645
Authors:
Yerong Xu,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Cosimo Bambi,
Thomas Dauser,
Javier A. Garcia,
Jiachen Jiang
Abstract:
It is thought that the spacetime metric around astrophysical black holes is well described by the Kerr solution of Einstein's gravity. However, a robust observational evidence of the Kerr nature of these objects is still lacking. Here we fit the X-ray spectrum of the stellar-mass black hole in GS 1354-645 with a disk reflection model beyond Einstein's gravity in order test the Kerr black hole hypo…
▽ More
It is thought that the spacetime metric around astrophysical black holes is well described by the Kerr solution of Einstein's gravity. However, a robust observational evidence of the Kerr nature of these objects is still lacking. Here we fit the X-ray spectrum of the stellar-mass black hole in GS 1354-645 with a disk reflection model beyond Einstein's gravity in order test the Kerr black hole hypothesis. We consider the Johannsen metric with the deformation parameters $α_{13}$ and $α_{22}$. The Kerr metric is recovered for $α_{13} = α_{22} = 0$. For $α_{22} = 0$, our measurements of the black hole spin and of the deformation parameter $α_{13}$ are $a_* > 0.975$ and $-0.34 < α_{13} < 0.16$, respectively. For $α_{13} = 0$, we find $a_* > 0.975$ and $-0.09 < α_{22} < 0.42$. All the reported uncertainties are at 99% of confidence level for two relevant parameters.
△ Less
Submitted 1 October, 2018; v1 submitted 26 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
RELXILL_NK: a relativistic reflection model for testing Einstein's gravity
Authors:
Cosimo Bambi,
Askar B. Abdikamalov,
Dimitry Ayzenberg,
Zheng Cao,
Honghui Liu,
Sourabh Nampalliwar,
Ashutosh Tripathi,
**gyi Wang-Ji,
Yerong Xu
Abstract:
Einstein's theory of general relativity was proposed over 100 years ago and has successfully passed a large number of observational tests in the weak field regime. However, the strong field regime is largely unexplored, and there are many modified and alternative theories that have the same predictions as Einstein's gravity for weak fields and present deviations when gravity becomes strong. RELXIL…
▽ More
Einstein's theory of general relativity was proposed over 100 years ago and has successfully passed a large number of observational tests in the weak field regime. However, the strong field regime is largely unexplored, and there are many modified and alternative theories that have the same predictions as Einstein's gravity for weak fields and present deviations when gravity becomes strong. RELXILL_NK is the first relativistic reflection model for probing the spacetime metric in the vicinity of astrophysical black holes and testing Einstein's gravity in the strong field regime. Here we present our current constraints on possible deviations from Einstein's gravity obtained from the black holes in 1H0707-495, Ark 564, GX 339-4, and GS 1354-645.
△ Less
Submitted 6 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
